3 ms·
Is that assessment based on your actual study of mainstream feminist theory (do you even know what it is?) or just something you've read on some blog written by
by pron 9y ago
Is that assessment based on your actual study of mainstream feminist theory (do you even know what it is?) or just something you've read on some blog written by someone who also hasn't actually studied the subject? Seriously, how can you make such bold assertions on a topic you know nothing about? Does it make any sense to you to form your opinion of a subject based on false information given by others who do not know the subject? Where's the logic/reason/facts/data in that?
So far, you're the one who tried to contradict the validity of the examples I've provided with claims that are factually incorrect (re how women got the vote) or with hypotheses that are easily dismissed (that women marginalization is no more than a manifestation of the marginalization of short people), as I clearly demonstrated. So what exactly (other than common myths about mainstream feminism) makes you think that I'm less rigorous?
- mpweiher 9y ago> actual study of mainstream feminist theory Yes, and interactions with proponents of said theory. And I understand the difference between a religion and science. You obviously do not.
- pron 9y ago> Yes What feminist theory have you studied? > with proponents of said theory That you call those scholars "proponents" makes me pretty certain you don't know what that theory is[1], but were those interactions full of personal insults and arguments based on ignorance? > You obviously do not. What makes you say that? Being so rigorous, can you point to where I confuse the two? What truly boggles the mind is how someone who professes to respect rigor can debate a subject they know absolutely nothing about. Forget familiarity with methodology or finidings -- you are clearly unfamiliar even with the research questions[2]. I get the sense that you're instinctively objecting not any actual arguments made, but arguments that you believe are made due to a false portrayal of feminism you may have been exposed to. And, BTW, what is your hypothesis? That there is no social marginalization of women? If that's your (quite extraordinary) claim, the burden of proof at this point in time (i.e., given the extensive research of the past few decades) should be on you. If you wish to dismiss this extensive research, you'll have to do better than repeat the same tired hundred-years-old (at least!) quips about feminists being "illogical" and the like. [1]: Answer: Feminist theory is the name given to the cross-disciplinary study -- in history, sociology, anthropology, literature and others -- of gender inequality. Therefore, I am not sure what you mean by "proponents" in this case. People interested in studying this issue as opposed to, say, you? If you are not interested, how can you debate this at all? [2]: The question of nature vs. nurture when it comes to gender differences is not one of the research questions, and is largely orthogonal, though intersects at times. In other words, the claim that cognitive biological differences between the sexes are nonexistent or even necessarily small is not a claim made by me, or, to the best of my knowledge, by mainstream feminist scholarship