2 ms·
Unless you missed the sarcasm tag completely, you can't use history to define what causes segregation. It don't stand up to the scientific method, it create cir
by belorn 9y ago
Unless you missed the sarcasm tag completely, you can't use history to define what causes segregation. It don't stand up to the scientific method, it create circular logic, and its frankly lazy.
First establish a theory. Then use theory to predict the world. Show data that support that given a starting point and a influence you end up with data similar to current, and then address potential problems. Finally compare the theory to other theories that also can correctly predict and see which one is better. Only if all fails should you get into camps and start the ideological battle like the one you are doing, in which reason can be thrown out and people can just shout at each other until a unified theory can be created and the battle lines can be silently be forgotten.
- mpweiher 9y agoYou're forgetting that this is feminist/gender theory. So logic/reason/facts/data do not apply, they are just tools of the oppressor.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pron 9y agoIs that assessment based on your actual study of mainstream feminist theory (do you even know what it is?) or just something you've read on some blog written by someone who also hasn't actually studied the subject? Seriously, how can you make such bold assertions on a topic you know nothing about? Does it make any sense to you to form your opinion of a subject based on false information given by others who do not know the subject? Where's the logic/reason/facts/data in that? So far, you're the one who tried to contradict the validity of the examples I've provided with claims that are factually incorrect (re how women got the vote) or with hypotheses that are easily dismissed (that women marginalization is no more than a manifestation of the marginalization of short people), as I clearly demonstrated. So what exactly (other than common myths about mainstream feminism) makes you think that I'm less rigorous?
- mpweiher 9y ago> actual study of mainstream feminist theory Yes, and interactions with proponents of said theory. And I understand the difference between a religion and science. You obviously do not.
- pron 9y ago> Yes What feminist theory have you studied? > with proponents of said theory That you call those scholars "proponents" makes me pretty certain you don't know what that theory is[1], but were those interactions full of personal insults and arguments based on ignorance? > You obviously do not. What makes you say that? Being so rigorous, can you point to where I confuse the two? What truly boggles the mind is how someone who professes to respect rigor can debate a subject they know absolutely nothing about. Forget familiarity with methodology or finidings -- you are clearly unfamiliar even with the research questions[2]. I get the sense that you're instinctively objecting not any actual arguments made, but arguments that you believe are made due to a false portrayal of feminism you may have been exposed to. And, BTW, what is your hypothesis? That there is no social marginalization of women? If that's your (quite extraordinary) claim, the burden of proof at this point in time (i.e., given the extensive research of the past few decades) should be on you. If you wish to dismiss this extensive research, you'll have to do better than repeat the same tired hundred-years-old (at least!) quips about feminists being "illogical" and the like. [1]: Answer: Feminist theory is the name given to the cross-disciplinary study -- in history, sociology, anthropology, literature and others -- of gender inequality. Therefore, I am not sure what you mean by "proponents" in this case. People interested in studying this issue as opposed to, say, you? If you are not interested, how can you debate this at all? [2]: The question of nature vs. nurture when it comes to gender differences is not one of the research questions, and is largely orthogonal, though intersects at times. In other words, the claim that cognitive biological differences between the sexes are nonexistent or even necessarily small is not a claim made by me, or, to the best of my knowledge, by mainstream feminist scholarship
- pron 9y ago> Unless you missed the sarcasm tag completely, you can't use history to define what causes segregation. It don't stand up to the scientific method, it create circular logic, and its frankly lazy. That's a nice general statement, but it's unclear to me what you think I've been trying to establish and why you think I failed to do that. Anyway, all I tried was to provide some examples that clearly demonstrate the existence of social marginalization of women; not to exclude additional causes nor to present the complete theory. > First establish a theory. We have. > Then use theory to predict the world. That's not quite the methodology in some intractable fields. In some intractable fields we prefer to explain historic events rather than try to make future predictions. It's less rigorous but it's the best we can do, both because of inherent intractability and because of time-scales and human scales (i.e. number of people) involved and other problems that make lab experiments difficult. > Show data that support that given a starting point and a influence you end up with data similar to current, and then address potential problems. Done. > Finally compare the theory to other theories that also can correctly predict and see which one is better. Yep. That's precisely most of the work being done. > Only if all fails should you get into camps and start the ideological battle like the one you are doing I haven't even started the ideological debate, and the theory I presented is so mainstream that I doubt any serious scholar contends it at all, and therefore did not know it requires further support here in addition to the mountains of evidence we've accumulated over the years, and is available to anyone who's even slightly interested in the subject with a simple Google Scholar search. However, you are very wrong about how ideology find their way into science, as the article we're discussing demonstrates: scientists judge the quality of a research based on how well it conforms with their ideology. This is something we just have to acknowledge, and yet one more problem these fields of study have to contend with that others, like physics, don't (or, at least, not to a similar degree). And look, I am quite familiar with both scientific methodology and historiographical methodology. What you want is either already most of what's being done or not the correct methodology. If you've actually read the scholarly debates, you'll see that the methodology is not too far from where we'd want it to be (sure, there are places where it can be more rigorous, but the same goes for medicine). It appears that you base your criticims based on some mental image you have that doesn't quite square with reality. It's as if you haven't actually looked at social scholarship at all. Also, it's unclear to me what hypotheses (for example, for the cause of women being denied the vote or attending university) do you think are being dismissed. Finally, it's unclear to me why you think that the political action you're hinting at depends on a very specific causal explanation. What hypothesis for the cause of women being denied entrance to universities would negate the political action that has brought us to where we are today? In other words, the only hypothesis that would make political action ineffective (and bear in mind that historically it's been very effective) is that 1. there are no significant social causes in the marginalization of women and 2. the effects are such that social action cannot change them (actually 2 subsumes 1). Otherwise, political action is both justified and necessary. What supportable hypothesis of that kind would you propose?