2 ms·
"Android is perfectably usable without any of the Google proprietary software." In a virtual machine maybe, surely not on any phone where most device drivers a
by squarefoot 9y ago
"Android is perfectably usable without any of the Google proprietary software."
In a virtual machine maybe, surely not on any phone where most device drivers are closed blobs. H4x0r5 may hide backdoors into compromised play store apps, but governments do it in device drivers, with 100% success rate because a closed source device driver is something 100% of the user base has installed, keeps running 24/7 at maximum privileges and has 0 chances to audit or examine.
Today closed device drivers, binary blobs etc. are places to look for malware; until a device is completely open it cannot call itself safe or secure.
- pedroaraujo 9y agoThe binary blobs are not part of Android at all. And Sailfish OS doesn't solve the problem of binary blobs as well.
- squarefoot 9y agoClosed device drivers aren't part of Android, but are part of any working installation of Android. Name one device which can run Android and can call itself 100% open. Of course Sailfish doesn't solve that problem, neither does Linux, BSD or whatever. I wasn't making a pissing contest between operating system (which is likely what trigger happy downvoters got) but simply stating a sad fact: closed device drivers are the best place to put spyware on and get 100% success, period. They can't be audited, they can't be uninstalled, they always run and they have maximum privileges. If I'm wrong (and trust me, I hope so) I want facts proving it.