3 ms·
> Linking to an Wikipedia article that do not says the statement you want to quote is also a nice touch for an article about science. Oh, I linked to other art
by pron 9y ago
> Linking to an Wikipedia article that do not says the statement you want to quote is also a nice touch for an article about science.
Oh, I linked to other articles, too, in my discussion with
mpweiher on another thread.
> where people of less hight has been marginalized from positions of power[1] at least for as the written history.
That may well be, and perhaps that problem needs addressing, but there is a question of extent. Women have been marginalized to a far greater extent than short people. You find many more short men in positions of power than you find women.
> If you show me research showing how socitey confers more power to people of smaller hight, then that would be something to consider. Only that data is worthy of consideration, and as you can't do that, we can just conclude that I am right and you are wrong.
There are literally mountains of evidence for the marginalization of women. A 1-minute Google-scholar search will confirm that. Just a few highlights: until recently, women weren't allowed to vote; they weren't allowed to join many professions; they weren't allowed to study or encouraged not to; they couldn't even control property unless in special circumstances. That has been going on for centuries. Like with blacks after slavery, the removal of legal barriers did not change the power imbalance over night. It took decades of political action to get a higher representation of women in politics, management and academia, and the struggle has been largely successful. For example, you can find research from 20-30 years ago showing that boys do better at math than girls (hinting at a biological difference), yet that difference has now largely disappeared. Let me just link a few introductory Wikipedia articles:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexism
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suffragette https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suffragette
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Female_education https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Female_education
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women_in_medicine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women_in_medicine
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women_in_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women_in_law
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women_in_government https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women_in_government
- mpweiher 9y agoJust a simple example of the one-sidedness of the "evidence" presented: > until recently, women weren't allowed to vote Until recently nobody was allowed to vote. Before that we had "the strongest rules", later locked into hereditary rule. When voting rights were extended to common men, they were (and mostly still are) inextricably linked to military service, that is your willingness to be killed for your country. Voting rights were extended to common women very soon after they were extended to common men (compared to the time no-one was allowed to vote), and with no such requirement attached. And of course, since women are statistically smaller than men, all evidence you present for the marginalization of women is evidence for the marginalization of smaller people. In fact, there is strong evidence that small men are in fact one of the most marginalized groups of all, far more than women, except they don't get treated as a group. http://www.jonathanrauch.com/jrauch_articles/height_discrimination_short_guys_finish_last/ http://www.jonathanrauch.com/jrauch_articles/height_discrimi... And finally, history is just that: history. Past tense. I have been ruled by a female chancellor for ... well can't actually remember how long. With the advent of Trump, she has been called "Leader of the free world" and so is arguable the most powerful person in the world. She is not marginalized. And if lack of female representation in the past is evidence of female marginalization in the past, then lack of representation in the present is evidence of male marginalization in the present (see overall rates of college attendance). Whereas unequal distribution of genders to areas of interest is evidence of unequal interests.
- pron 9y ago> Voting rights were extended to common women very soon after they were extended to common men (compared to the time no-one was allowed to vote), and with no such requirement attached. If by "very soon" you mean after decades of intense feminist political action, stronger than any feminist action we have now. But in any event, what does this have to do with the hypothesis? The hypothesis is that women have been marginalized relatively to men, not that some men have never been marginalized as well. Of course they have -- the prime example is men of color, at least in the past few centuries. > Voting rights were extended to common women very soon after they were extended to common men (compared to the time no-one was allowed to vote), and with no such requirement attached. This is factually incorrect. E.g., in the US, the Fifteenth Amendment was ratified in 1869. Women were given the vote only 50 years later. BTW, the abolitionist movement and the feminist movement in the US has been very intricately tied, and feminists/abolitionists were very strongly correlated, and yet it took women another 50 years to get the vote (of course, the vote was only given to blacks de jure, and they continue to face suppression to this day). You may claim that fifty years isn't a long time, but it was fifty years of a feminist action of stronger intensity and longer duration than the action you see now. > And of course, since women are statistically smaller than men, all evidence you present for the marginalization of women is evidence for the marginalization of smaller people. This is not true, because short men were allowed to study, practice a profession and vote. And we haven't even discussed cultural marginalization. Even when legal barriers against women were removed, society still discouraged women from practices that were considered masculine; this did not extend to short men. > In fact, there is strong evidence that small men are in fact one of the most marginalized groups of all, far more than women, except they don't get treated as a group. This is incorrect. The problem isn't just the existence of marginalization, but its extent. The extent of the marginalization of women (with respect to education, work and political rights) did not extend to short men. So it is very much possible that the marginalization of short people is a real problem requiring redress, but it is no doubt a smaller (no pun intended) problem than the marginalization of women. It should be noted (as above), however, that the feminist movement has long been associated with adressing many different kinds of marginalization (e.g. slavery and now abelism), so it's not as if we ignore other problems of a similar nature, even if they are of a smaller extent. On the contrary, feminists have often allied and even led other struggles (abolition in the US is a prime example). > She is not marginalized. What? And Oprah Winfrey is both powerful and rich, ergo, no marginalization of blacks and/or women? I don't understand how you tie the evidence to the hypothesis. There is no hypothesis of "all women are less powerful than all men". The fact that Merkel is still almost alone among heads of state (even among the Western countries) shows that this marginalization still exist, even if some exceptionally talented and persevering women do manage to break through (unless you think that German women are biologically superior to other women). > then lack of representation in the present is evidence of male marginalization in the present (see overall rates of college attendance). While women education (at least in the West) has improved considerably due to a long struggle (which, BTW, has been opposed constantly with claims that women are less naturally adept at intellectual pursuits), and things are not as bad as they used to be by any means -- feminism has had a lot of hard-earned success -- this improvement does not change the current state of affairs which is that overall women still have significantly less power than men, even though they have gained (again, through hard struggle) some pockets of considerable success.
- belorn 9y agoUnless you missed the sarcasm tag completely, you can't use history to define what causes segregation. It don't stand up to the scientific method, it create circular logic, and its frankly lazy. First establish a theory. Then use theory to predict the world. Show data that support that given a starting point and a influence you end up with data similar to current, and then address potential problems. Finally compare the theory to other theories that also can correctly predict and see which one is better. Only if all fails should you get into camps and start the ideological battle like the one you are doing, in which reason can be thrown out and people can just shout at each other until a unified theory can be created and the battle lines can be silently be forgotten.
- mpweiher 9y agoYou're forgetting that this is feminist/gender theory. So logic/reason/facts/data do not apply, they are just tools of the oppressor.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pron 9y agoIs that assessment based on your actual study of mainstream feminist theory (do you even know what it is?) or just something you've read on some blog written by someone who also hasn't actually studied the subject? Seriously, how can you make such bold assertions on a topic you know nothing about? Does it make any sense to you to form your opinion of a subject based on false information given by others who do not know the subject? Where's the logic/reason/facts/data in that? So far, you're the one who tried to contradict the validity of the examples I've provided with claims that are factually incorrect (re how women got the vote) or with hypotheses that are easily dismissed (that women marginalization is no more than a manifestation of the marginalization of short people), as I clearly demonstrated. So what exactly (other than common myths about mainstream feminism) makes you think that I'm less rigorous?
- mpweiher 9y ago