3 ms·
> Which part of "bias is for the underrepresented group" do you not understand? The part where it's not power-conferring bias, and therefore irrelevant to the
by pron 9y ago
> Which part of "bias is for the underrepresented group" do you not understand?
The part where it's not power-conferring bias, and therefore irrelevant to the hypothesis. People may smile more to women; that doesn't mean there's no power imbalance. You need to understand the hypothesis in order to contradict it. The hypothesis is: society marginalizes women from positions of power.
> decidedly non-topical links you have provided.
Really? Why don't you do a Google Scholar search and see how typical or non-typical they are?
> Same with gender differences being socially caused.
Who said that? You said that you've read Pinker, but he's arguing against opinions that simply no longer exist (in any considerable strength, at least). That Pinker says that feminists don't believe that there are biological differences between the sexes doesn't mean that we really don't. It's just something that he wants you to believe to ridicule our true position. He argues with a strawman.
> Which again, completely guts your claims.
What claims? Pretty much everybody knows differences are a combination of biology and society. But if you think we know exactly the relative size and strength of each, then you are sorely mistaken about the current state of the science.
> But no worries, you have already made clear that evidence is of no interest you
Evidence of what? What are you even arguing? That there are biological differences between the sexes? You will have to try very hard to find feminists who disagree with you on that. Why do you think this has anything to do with sexism?
- mpweiher 9y ago>> decidedly non-topical links you have provided. > Really? Why don't you do a Google Scholar search and see how typical or non-typical they are? Topical. Reading skillz. They help. > everybody knows differences are a combination of biology and society. Excellent, so you've finally come around to Damore's point of view. So where did all the opposition and vitriol come from? > The hypothesis is: society marginalizes women from positions of power. No, that is not the hypothesis here. Do pay attention.
- pron 9y ago> Topical Sorry, I misread that word. > Excellent, so you've finally come around to Damore's point of view. So where did all the opposition and vitriol come from? Huh? Like virtually everyone (including feminists!), I've never doubted that there are biological cognitive differences between the sexes (why would I?). But that is not Damore's point of view, though; that is virtually everyone's point of view. Damore, using a kind of reasoning clear only to him, somehow uses that irrelevant premise to conclude that diversity programs at Google are useless. That is his point of view. Also, his point of view is that women are inherently inferior and/or less interested when it comes to technology, which is also not the conclusion of the sources he cites. Rather he takes some flights of fancy to deduce that. To the best of my knowledge, not a single expert claims to know the relative strengths of biological differences compared to social dynamics, and the overwhelming consensus is that this is simply not known. Therefore, to get from his premise to his conclusion, he either needs to manufacture knowledge we don't have (the relative strength of causes; some definite results about the fitness of women to technology), contradict evidence we do have (the prevalence of sexism), or use some strange logic (to reach his conclusion from an irrelevant premise). > No, that is not the hypothesis here. What is the hypothesis?
- mpweiher 9y ago> uses that irrelevant premise to conclude that diversity programs at Google are useless. You obviously didn't read the darn memo. And as it has been explained multiple times by many people, and you still spout the same nonsense, I am not going to explain it to you again.
- pron 9y agoI have read it, I don't need you to explain it to me (it's a 10-page memo, of which only 2 speak about the science of sex differences; maybe you haven't read the other 8), and it's good that you're stopping because your insistence on debating a topic that you clearly know absolutely nothing about and have no real interest in (like Damore himself) is truly mind-boggling. It reminds me of the famous LambdaConf incident, where the organizer "struggled" with a decision and decided to "rigorously" reason about it, so he "studied" the issue by mere contemplation, trying to deduce the answer from first principles, without opening a single book or consulting a single expert, as if ethics and jurisprudence weren't subject studied by some of the greatest minds in history for, oh, at least a couple of millennia. I guess that such is the strength of ideology that even people who like to think of themselves as rigorous and studious, all of a sudden forget to consult real research, and instead convince themselves that quiet contemplation in their Aristotelian minds would suffice to get at the Truth, which just so happens to correspond with their gut feelz.