3 ms·
> Oh, and heavy metal too. To be fair though Heavy Metal has been playing on the Satanist/Gore imagery for years, and not just in graphics, but lyrics too. Not
by ekianjo 9y ago
> Oh, and heavy metal too.
To be fair though Heavy Metal has been playing on the Satanist/Gore imagery for years, and not just in graphics, but lyrics too. Not because they are satanists, but it because it sold well.
- cjslep 9y agoBecause it sold well, as compared to non-Satanist/non-gore Heavy Metal? Definitely would like to see the data you used to draw that conclusion. And how inclusive your definition of "gore imagery" is.
- _jal 9y agoTo be fair, I think Slayer gets a lot more play than Stryper, but I have no data for you. That said, the notion that metal bands are fine-tuning lyrical content to minimax paydays is pretty funny. I think income-maximizers generally gravitate towards different careers. But I like picturing a bunch of corpse-paint MBAs sitting on a conference call: "Nice, Sean, I like it, I like it a lot. What about the next line - I think 'Demons dining on your shame' will sell better than 'Demons know this ain't no game'. How does that grab you?"
- soundwave106 9y agoThis is a funny thought. But my guess is that if they were income-maximizers, they wouldn't be writing metal with "satanic" or "gore" content. Slayer certainly has been successful, and have built a nice consistent career. You can do well with niches. But by one statistic, album sales... well, they've never created an album that's gone platinum. (Stryper actually has once!) The "money" to "maximize" in music, if anything, is in pop. A large portion of pop these days is written by teams of people these days. I'm not sure how it goes down personally, but I can easily see conference calls coming up with the best love metaphors for a teen idol to croon. :)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- saiya-jin 9y agoDude you are mixing things too much. See this wiki article [1] about various subtypes, most dont care about religions (power metal fan here) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heavy_metal_genres https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heavy_metal_genres
- watersb 9y agoNew priest at our church here is a metal-head. Truth. Says Metallica saved his [temporal] life.
- CuriouslyC 9y agoSome acts (like Marilyn Manson) might have played up the satanist image for media attention, but it was really more about rebellion from established social mores and strictures. Metal took the disillusionment that Punk sang about and expressed it through escapism and fantasy. The ultimate source of the anger was the same though.