6 ms·
Paraphrasing somewhat snarkily, you seem to be saying that selling securities of limited intrinsic value to as many clueless investors a as you can find is the
by amluto 9y ago
Paraphrasing somewhat snarkily, you seem to be saying that selling securities of limited intrinsic value to as many clueless investors a as you can find is the future of fundraising. Screw Reg D, the SEC, any concept of selling only to informed investors, having some legal force behind your securities, etc.
Why bother pitching to people who are actually qualified to review your claims and business model?
IANAL, but I think the penalties for improperly selling securities are pretty severe, for good reason.
- seibelj 9y agoNo, we are selling utility tokens which will be redeemable for mobile data, never did I say nor would I suggest that we are selling securities of any kind. As an entrepreneur, you can now raise funds to develop a product based on an idea - you get potential users excited, pre-sell access to a future product, and then use those funds to build the product. I can't begin to explain this to someone who has been locked into the traditional mindset. Everyone on HN knew about bitcoin before everyone else did yet most still missed out on 450,000% gains if buying in at $1. Sometimes the future is staring you in the face but you can't accept reality.
- ameister14 9y agoSo it's essentially just a mobile data pre-sale with fancy tech? Why is this better than crowdfunding in general??
- seibelj 9y agoThe tokens are immediately transferrable on the open market at floating prices. You aren't locked in for 5 years with your money stuck, and if you think the project will fail you can sell your tokens, unlike with kick-starter where you hope and pray they deliver.
- JetSpiegel 9y agoEither a) the token is redeemable, and in that case why buy securities you don't intended to use (speculation is the only reason) b) or the company folds before delivering and the token is worthless, so by selling it you are just pushing the loss to a greater fool Either way, this is objectively worse than Kickstarter.
- seibelj 9y agoLet's say you give $50 to a kickstarter project, and in return you get some special benefit, say early access. If this was tokenized, as you follow the project, you could sell early access. If you thought it was less likely to happen, maybe you sell it for $40. If it was super exciting, and the founders capped how much early access there could ever be, maybe you sell at $60. This is the benefit that tokenization gives you. You don't get any say in the company, any stock, etc. - you get access to a product, and through the blockchain you can easily trade it securely and provably. People who buy diamonds, physical diamonds, may be speculating on them. Others may actually like the diamond. For whatever reason, they bought the diamond, and now own it, and can resell it. It isn't illegal to buy something in the hope it goes up in value. People do that all the time with videogames, cars, whatever. Now, let's say ownership of a diamond was moved to the the blockchain. Not only could you buy and transfer it easily, provably, securely - you could even buy 0.000000001 diamonds, or 100000 diamonds, just as easily. In my opinion, all of this is objectively better than kickstarter.
- hueving 9y ago>In my opinion, all of this is objectively better than kickstarter. Sure, because you don't even have the little bit of oversight that kickstarter offers. In your case you can just keep pumping coins into the market while they have any meaningful amount of value. Then when they are worthless you just claim your project failed and take the money from selling the coins.
- will_brown 9y agoSo do a kickstarter and offer a digital token in addition to whatever you claim to be offering, then the funder have a token to sell when they aren't happy or think you will fail to deliver. And I am not sure that is a selling point, "hey you have an immediately transferable token you can sell at floating prices on a secondary market, if or when you feel we won't deliver." And what justifies these tokens you are offering having such a variable price? They aren't tied to the company equity or actual success of the company, but for your inability to launch when they would become completely valueless, in fact you claim they are a utility transferable for data but why would the price of the product/data being offered fluctuate other than speculation of a blockchain based crypto coin separate having nothing to so with the alleged utility.
- jstanley 9y ago> in fact you claim they are a utility transferable for data but why would the price of the product/data being offered fluctuate The same reason the price of anything fluctuates. Do you think the price of mobile data should be different?
- will_brown 9y agoDo I think the price of mobile data should fluctuate before the company releases a data product on the market...no. You can claim it's the same reason anything fluctuates, but point me to other products/goods/services with prelaunch fluctuating pricing.
- jstanley 9y agoFor example the price of crude oil fluctuates. Corn, gas, electricity. Every commodity. If mobile data becomes more of a commodity, it, too, will have a free-floating price.
- will_brown 9y agoThis guy is claiming his coin isn't regulated because it is a utility to exchange for a product (that doesn't even exist, and may never exist). The rest of that stuff you mention may fluctuate in price, but its a direct price to the end consumer for the product, not a fluctuating price of a "token" to exchange for those products before they exist, but if that is what you are talking about, buying/selling "things" you can exchange for corn before the corn exists that sounds an awful lot like buying/selling futures contracts which is heavily regulated. Either way you would need to find an example that actually fits the facts.
- DennisP 9y agoIt's easily tradable, so as a buyer you don't have to predict your personal usage.
- mhluongo 9y agoWell, the funders can sell the tokens immediately if they're unhappy with the team's progress. Try that on Kickstarter or your favorite JOBS act crowdfunding service.
- will_brown 9y agoBut the tokens are not equity. Its not like "Kickstarter or your favorite JOBS act crowdfunding service" can't give you a little digital token (on blockchain or off blockchain) next to the equity or next to whatever you get on Kickstarter and then the business can claim you have a token to sell as protection if your not happy with the team's progress.
- jstanley 9y agoThey don't have to be equity, and even if they were equity it wouldn't make a difference to his point. If you think the tokens (equity or not) are likely to become worthless, you can sell them to somebody else, as long as there is anybody willing to buy. It doesn't matter that it's not equity. Even if it was equity, at the point where it was a dead cert that the tokens would be worthless, they'd still be worthless, regardless of how hard the SEC ensures that you own a slice of that worthlessness.
- Spivak 9y agoSure, but that's really no different than just selling transferable vouchers.
- hudon 9y ago> never did I say nor would I suggest that we are selling securities of any kind Probably the most relevant part of the SEC's report on the DAO [0] for you is this sentence: "These offers and sales have been referred to, among other things, as “Initial Coin Offerings” or “Token Sales.” Accordingly, the Commission deems it appropriate and in the public interest to issue this Report in order to stress that the U.S. federal securities law may apply to various activities, including distributed ledger technology, depending on the particular facts and circumstances, without regard to the form of the organization or technology used to effectuate a particular offer or sale." To put it simply: it doesn't matter what you call it. If it passes the Howey test, they'll deem it a security. If I fold my company's share into a paper airplane and call it a "utility share" (or "AirShare" ;) ) because I now have a use for the piece of paper, it's still a security. [0] https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2017-131 https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2017-131
- seibelj 9y agoYes, as with every company that ICO's, we are acutely aware of the Howie test and have paid lawyers a lot of money to review our business model and white paper. But the lack of clarity from the SEC means we and every other company are somewhat in the dark.
- hudon 9y agoOK, but you realize that the blockchain in your case is only used because regulation exists right? As in, if the SEC did not exist, you could just sell shares on an open market without registering. But you're using the blockchain so you don't have to do this. Is this correct? I understand your token thingie can be used like a digital coin to redeem for data, but surely that doesn't require a blockchain... you can just do internal accounting of the digital coins in MySQL? Then you wouldn't have to pay the Ethereum network for every state change or transaction so you could cut costs. EDIT: I just had a realization. This means you intentionally chose inefficient tech (Ethereum as a database for your coin) JUST so you can pay for a regulatory circumvention mechanism. Oh god...
- 9y ago
- darawk 9y agoYou don't think individuals should have the choice to invest their own money where they please?
- StavrosK 9y agoSince when do individuals know what's good for them? That's why we have regulation.
- darawk 9y agoThey don't. But they ought to have the right to decide what's good for them, even if they're wrong.
- cocktailpeanuts 9y agoBut it's government's job to make sure its citizens don't get conned. People have the right to decide to join a suicide cult, but also the government needs to stop the cult because otherwise all these innocent yet naive people will die.
- darawk 9y agoWhy is it the government's job to ensure people don't get conned?
- wheelerwj 9y agobecause thats we as a society agreed was the governments job.
- darawk 9y agoYou are arguing what is. I'm arguing what ought be. I believe it is a violation of fundamental human rights to prevent people from doing with their own property what they like, provided that so doing does not impinge upon the rights of others. My right to be taken in by any scam I choose ought to be absolute. If, ex-post, I can show that I was conned, I ought to receive compensation for that, and maybe the perpetrators ought to go to jail. But the government shouldn't stop me from doing it.
- mrb 9y agoBefore bashing the ICO model, consider that an ICO really is just (1) crowdfunding (with a blockchain to keep track of the tokens) combined with (2) markets to trade said tokens. So are you against (1) crowdfunding, Kickstarter, etc? Or are you against (2) token trading markets?
- klipt 9y agoI'm against crowdfunding that masquerades as investment. People should know there's a high chance of 0 return and complete loss of principle with something like Kickstarter; it's better to think of it as patronage of artists you like with a small chance of something back.
- wheelerwj 9y agoi think you mean to say that you're against token trading that masquerades as crowdunding. i agree, its a problem. but its solveable.
- amluto 9y agoWhen you buy a doohickey on Kickstarter, it's just like buying from a normal vendor except that you accept the risk that it might never arrive. When you buy a magic token on the average ICO, you're usually buying an interest in some future business that you hope to resell at a profit. One of these is a doohickey. The other sounds awfully like a security...
- SkyMarshal 9y agoDon't forget "instant liquidity", eg selling your securi... er tokens before you've actually built a product, much less gotten users/customers. The ICO craze has clarified, if it wasn't obvious before, why the incubator/seed -> Series A -> Series BCD etc is what it is. The scale of each successive stage of fundraising is indexed to the execution and progress of the product & business development, keeping the startup team motivated and the investors' risk exposure mitigated. ICO's that take in huge amounts of money frontload most of the investors' risk, leaving their only assurance as some kind of ideology-driven social contract where the ICO is now an "endowment" and must manage itself and reinvest its capital in such a way that builds it product as well as the rest of the ecosystem. But that all depends on the founders maintaining their motivation instead of heading off to a private island for the rest of their lives.