4 ms·
> However, it turns out that neither chemistry nor physics are "tech" and the gender ratios in the physical sciences are fairly even (even for chemistry, slight
by pron 9y ago
> However, it turns out that neither chemistry nor physics are "tech" and the gender ratios in the physical sciences are fairly even (even for chemistry, slight male skew for physics last I checked).
I don't understand what it is that you're arguing.
> And when the underrepresentation is stronger
Again, I don't think you understand what the topic is, so I don't see the relevance of your citations. What kind of bias do you think we're talking about?
Even though I hate doing this (b/c if you haven't bothered clicking through the links I posted, then you're not interested in the subject), but just to break the monotony of repeatedly pointing out the absurdity of debating a subject you know little about and wish to learn of even less, let me give the elevator-pitch summary:
It is not about participation in arbitrary professions; it is not about bias in tests; it is not about biological differences; it is about the easily verified fact that women have been marginalized from positions of power[1] at least for centuries. Test scores have little to do with power; Participation in being psychology lab assistants has little to do with power; bias in promotion in certain power-conferring occupation has a lot to do with power.
Studies in the field may, therefore, focus on two things: either on the status or process of said power imbalance, or on the mechanism of its creation. The paper which is the focus of this article (the last one), is of the second kind.
Next you're going to show me research showing bias in favor of women when it comes to smiling. That may be nice, but is not relevant to the discussion.
If you show me research showing how socitey confers more power on women than men, then that would be something to consider.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_(social_and_political) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_(social_and_political)
- mpweiher 9y agoLet me simplify this for you: Which part of "bias is for the underrepresented group" do you not understand? So the cause of underrepresentation is not bias. Bias counteracts underrepresentation in a largely gender-non-specific way. (Well, the bias for women when they are underrepresented is larger than the bias for men when they are). Your entire ridiculous edifice has no basis, and yes, I have looked up the few and decidedly non-topical links you have provided. Now you can keep making ever grander claims, but the evidence does not support them. Same with gender differences being socially caused. Again, the evidence simply contradicts that idea, the arrow points the other way: when you remove social barriers, the genders differentiate more, not less. Which again, completely guts your claims. But no worries, you have already made clear that evidence is of no interest you, as whenever the evidence you claim as proof for your theories turns out to actually contradict them, that same evidence that was golden turns out to be insignificant. Magically, instantaneously. And we're back to broad claims with absolutely zero evidence whatsoever. So please carry on believing what you so fervently want to believe.
- pron 9y ago> Which part of "bias is for the underrepresented group" do you not understand? The part where it's not power-conferring bias, and therefore irrelevant to the hypothesis. People may smile more to women; that doesn't mean there's no power imbalance. You need to understand the hypothesis in order to contradict it. The hypothesis is: society marginalizes women from positions of power. > decidedly non-topical links you have provided. Really? Why don't you do a Google Scholar search and see how typical or non-typical they are? > Same with gender differences being socially caused. Who said that? You said that you've read Pinker, but he's arguing against opinions that simply no longer exist (in any considerable strength, at least). That Pinker says that feminists don't believe that there are biological differences between the sexes doesn't mean that we really don't. It's just something that he wants you to believe to ridicule our true position. He argues with a strawman. > Which again, completely guts your claims. What claims? Pretty much everybody knows differences are a combination of biology and society. But if you think we know exactly the relative size and strength of each, then you are sorely mistaken about the current state of the science. > But no worries, you have already made clear that evidence is of no interest you Evidence of what? What are you even arguing? That there are biological differences between the sexes? You will have to try very hard to find feminists who disagree with you on that. Why do you think this has anything to do with sexism?
- mpweiher 9y ago>> decidedly non-topical links you have provided. > Really? Why don't you do a Google Scholar search and see how typical or non-typical they are? Topical. Reading skillz. They help. > everybody knows differences are a combination of biology and society. Excellent, so you've finally come around to Damore's point of view. So where did all the opposition and vitriol come from? > The hypothesis is: society marginalizes women from positions of power. No, that is not the hypothesis here. Do pay attention.
- pron 9y ago> Topical Sorry, I misread that word. > Excellent, so you've finally come around to Damore's point of view. So where did all the opposition and vitriol come from? Huh? Like virtually everyone (including feminists!), I've never doubted that there are biological cognitive differences between the sexes (why would I?). But that is not Damore's point of view, though; that is virtually everyone's point of view. Damore, using a kind of reasoning clear only to him, somehow uses that irrelevant premise to conclude that diversity programs at Google are useless. That is his point of view. Also, his point of view is that women are inherently inferior and/or less interested when it comes to technology, which is also not the conclusion of the sources he cites. Rather he takes some flights of fancy to deduce that. To the best of my knowledge, not a single expert claims to know the relative strengths of biological differences compared to social dynamics, and the overwhelming consensus is that this is simply not known. Therefore, to get from his premise to his conclusion, he either needs to manufacture knowledge we don't have (the relative strength of causes; some definite results about the fitness of women to technology), contradict evidence we do have (the prevalence of sexism), or use some strange logic (to reach his conclusion from an irrelevant premise). > No, that is not the hypothesis here. What is the hypothesis?
- belorn 9y agoIt is very convenient and easy to define the problem as historical as you don't need to prove anything. Linking to an Wikipedia article that do not says the statement you want to quote is also a nice touch for an article about science. There is a correlation between hight and power, where people of less hight has been marginalized from positions of power[1] at least for as the written history. So in a satirical statement, I will now make a scientific claim that bias in promotion of people with less hight is the problem and thus people should be given special shoes during the hiring process in order to solve the problem. No need to bring data other than the historical proof. Science is done here. If you show me research showing how socitey confers more power to people of smaller hight, then that would be something to consider. Only that data is worthy of consideration, and as you can't do that, we can just conclude that I am right and you are wrong. [1]: http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/health-and-families/health-news/tall-people-more-likely-to-be-successful-in-life-study-find-a6919431.html http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/health-and-families/...
- pron 9y ago> Linking to an Wikipedia article that do not says the statement you want to quote is also a nice touch for an article about science. Oh, I linked to other articles, too, in my discussion with mpweiher on another thread. > where people of less hight has been marginalized from positions of power[1] at least for as the written history. That may well be, and perhaps that problem needs addressing, but there is a question of extent. Women have been marginalized to a far greater extent than short people. You find many more short men in positions of power than you find women. > If you show me research showing how socitey confers more power to people of smaller hight, then that would be something to consider. Only that data is worthy of consideration, and as you can't do that, we can just conclude that I am right and you are wrong. There are literally mountains of evidence for the marginalization of women. A 1-minute Google-scholar search will confirm that. Just a few highlights: until recently, women weren't allowed to vote; they weren't allowed to join many professions; they weren't allowed to study or encouraged not to; they couldn't even control property unless in special circumstances. That has been going on for centuries. Like with blacks after slavery, the removal of legal barriers did not change the power imbalance over night. It took decades of political action to get a higher representation of women in politics, management and academia, and the struggle has been largely successful. For example, you can find research from 20-30 years ago showing that boys do better at math than girls (hinting at a biological difference), yet that difference has now largely disappeared. Let me just link a few introductory Wikipedia articles: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suffragette https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suffragette https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Female_education https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Female_education https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women_in_medicine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women_in_medicine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women_in_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women_in_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women_in_government https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women_in_government