3 ms·
By the way, the only reason commercial air travel can go at transonic speeds (670mph) efficiently is because it's at near vacuum, i.e. at high altitude, just li
by Robotbeat 9y ago
By the way, the only reason commercial air travel can go at transonic speeds (670mph) efficiently is because it's at near vacuum, i.e. at high altitude, just like Hyperloop.
That's also why conventional or maglev non-vacuum trains won't ever travel as fast as passenger air travel cruise speed. It takes a stupendous amount of energy to travel that fast near sea level. Even a lot of supersonic fighter jets can only reach supersonic speeds at high altitude.
The whole advantage of hyperloop (and vacuum-trains) is you're bringing that high altitude air down to near sea level. The other things are implementation details.
This is why hyperloops will fairly quickly eclipse other train speed records, currently 375mph for maglev.
Just a FYI, the Hyperloop One pod recently reached 192mph, so this student pod bested them (although the student pod is much smaller and the student competition hyperloop track is much longer, so the Hyperloop One pod must've been higher performance).
- jacquesm 9y agoAir pressure at 10 km altitude is about 30% or so of sea level, it is much less but definitely not near vacuum. If it were a near vacuum any airplane would stall...
- Robotbeat 9y ago747 max altitude is 45,100ft, or 16% sea level. At Concorde's cruise altitude of 18000m, it's just 8% of sea level. Of course, Concorde had to fly very fast to keep from stalling. U2 spy plane has the same problem at 21,000ft, 5% sea level pressure. It's nearly stalled while cruising. I wouldn't call that "definitely not near vacuum." Still higher planes, one at 100,000 ft, have flown (NASA's Helios), 1% atm. Near Mars pressures, definitely near vacuum. (as much as this term is subjective) Hyperloop One plans an altitude equivalent of about 200,000 ft, or about 0.16% sea level pressure.
- jacquesm 9y agoSeen any Concordes lately? The last time I saw one it was sitting on a static display looking very good but going nowhere. Concorde is not a representative sample of passenger air travel, neither is a U2 spy plane nor is Helios. What Hyperloop One plans is not relevant, what they will manage to achieve is and there is no way that they will manage to run that network at 0.16% of sea level pressure. The whole hyperloop discussion would benefit from an injection of some solid engineering principles, the linked article is a nice example of what can be done and even if they won a competition has nothing to do with the hyperloop concept as presented originally, the vast majority of the original engineering challenges still stands.
- Robotbeat 9y ago"Seen any Concordes lately?" Nevertheless, that was the genesis of the Hyperloop idea. Musk mentioned Concordes as an example. And you can't (realistically) have supersonic passenger travel without traveling at similar altitudes (or altitude equivalent pressure) because it uses too much energy. I think you're missing this key point: transonic (670mph) or supersonic speed travel requires low or near-vacuum pressures to work efficiently. Other aspects of hyperloop (or related ideas) are implementation details. Power losses scale with drag which scales with air density. And to the degree that Concorde failed because it was too inefficient, having an even lower operating pressure should address that as well. "Concorde is not a representative sample of passenger air travel" It is, along with the Soviet jet, the /only/ sample of supersonic passenger air travel. I don't see any solid engineering analysis in your comment, by the way, just assertions that this or that cannot be done.
- jacquesm 9y agoThe general idea here is not that something can not be done in principle or not but that it will be hard to do it economically. Little details like radius-of-turn, g-forces imparted on passengers, cost of maintaining infrastructure and so on are important. Elon Musk so far has done spectacularly well at re-doing stuff that was already done in principle - other than the re-use of rockets, which is very impressive and a serious source of headache for SpaceX competitors. To create a whole new class of transportation from scratch is a different kind of challenge. I wish him well, it is just that these mere matters of engineering are hard and long distance travel is mercilessly dictated by economics. Hence my reference to Concorde, which worked well but was not competitive in the longer haul. So if you are looking for engineering reasons you will not get those from me. For now Hyperloop does not exist, we will see if it gets done in the next decade. Or two. And once it has been done whether or not it can be operated profitably.
- Robotbeat 9y agoBy this standard only way to satisfy your question of whether it can be done economically is if it already is being done, and being done en masse. There's no point in discussing any future technology if this is the standard, as there's no way this can be satisfied except in hindsight. This sort of absurd standard of discussion is super common on the Internet and highly boring as it leaves zero room for actual insight or analysis, as everything that isn't already far in the rearview mirror is dismissed as "unconvincing."