4 ms·
So how does Facebook really know if something is fake? You can't trust user reports. They will say a story is fake when they don't like it. You can't trust so
by pier25 9y ago
So how does Facebook really know if something is fake?
You can't trust user reports. They will say a story is fake when they don't like it.
You can't trust some worker in Bangladesh to determine this either just as easily as you can determine if something is NSFW.
You still can't trust AI.
So how? It hires specialists in each field to determine what is real and what is not?
- jdc0589 9y agoThis is the real issue. Sure, there's the whole thing about it being a slippery slope to straight up shadow banning or otherwise censoring users deemed as "purveyors of fake news", but that's further down the road. How the hell are they going to measure this?
- YCode 9y agoWhich is strange, because didn't they just get a lot of flak for having "editors" that they subsequently had to let go?
- ceejayoz 9y agoThey got a lot of flak for getting rid of the editors, too.
- ksk 9y agoIf I had to guess, they will probably deploy a human assisted AI that barely works, and rely on public outrage to handle any outliers that turn into a PR problem. It's worked so far for other internet companies.
- cbtacy 9y agoHuman expertise, in this context often called "subject matter experts"
- samlevine 9y agoJournalists aren't even SMEs in most cases. If they're good, they get enough depth to explain what SMEs are talking about and to understand the difference between a huckster and an expert. And, amazingly enough, the SMEs themselves will disagree on fine points and big issues. There is too much specialized information and knowledge for social media companies to be reliable arbiters of truth for any controversial topic.
- whack 9y ago"The company has already been working with outside fact-checkers like Snopes and the AP to flag inaccurate news stories. (These aren’t supposed to be stories that are disputed for reasons of opinion or partisanship, but rather outright hoaxes and lies.) It also says that when a story is marked as disputed, the link can can no longer be promoted through Facebook ads." If Snopes/AP tells me something is false, I'm perfectly willing to give them the benefit of the doubt. Perhaps this will change in the coming decade, but for now, this seems like a perfectly reasonable heuristic.
- Applejinx 9y agoSo: buy Snopes, and the AP. These are not wealthy or powerful entities.
- marknutter 9y agoHonestly, the fact that you think snopes is unbiased is pretty shocking to me, and gives me little hope that Facebook would ever be able to properly determine what is "fake news".