4 ms·
It should be noted the California bullet train is planned to run at 220mph for its fastest leg, so this is within spitting distance already. If you pump the (v
by Robotbeat 9y ago
It should be noted the California bullet train is planned to run at 220mph for its fastest leg, so this is within spitting distance already.
If you pump the (vast majority of the) air out, no reason you couldn't get supersonic. That's much faster than any non-rocket-propelled train has ever gone.
The fastest train in service is around 270mph, more experimental maglevs have reached 375mph. Supersonic is 767mph, so over twice the fastest maglev.
- nether 9y ago"supersonic" relative to the sound speed at normal density I assume. With no air, there would be no sound! Edit: corrected pressure to density
- Robotbeat 9y agohttps://mobile.twitter.com/elonmusk/status/901975117797851137 https://mobile.twitter.com/elonmusk/status/90197511779785113... @elonmusk: "No such thing as true vacuum" BTW, speed of sound doesn't change (to first order) with changing pressure (edit: nor does it change (to first order) with density, assuming temperature is the same). Mostly effected by temperature. Hyperloop uses a partial vacuum, of course. No true vacuum exists.
- _Codemonkeyism 9y ago"No true vacuum exist." How high is density of atoms in space? Could there be a 1mm x 1mm space without atoms?
- vlahmot 9y agoMy understanding is that there would still be quantum fluctuatons causing particles to pop in and out of existence.
- _Codemonkeyism 9y agoWould this be protons? Can vacuum contain photons and still be a vacuum? Not sure :-)
- xhrpost 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_fluctuation#cite_note-1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_fluctuation#cite_note-...
- mikeash 9y agoAccording to Wikipedia: "Plasma with a number density of less than one hydrogen atom per cubic metre and a temperature of millions of kelvins in the space between galaxies accounts for most of the baryonic (ordinary) matter in outer space; local concentrations have condensed into stars and galaxies." - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Outer_space https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Outer_space I knew that intergalactic space could see densities of one atom per some human-relevant volume of space, but I had no idea that actually accounted for most of what there is!
- adrianN 9y agoIf you want to go very fast you can basically only go in a straight line and you need a long time for accelerating and braking. G-Forces on passengers are fairly limited, typically to around 1m/s^2.
- Robotbeat 9y agoMuch more than that (~4m/s^2) is experienced nominally by jet liner passengers. Roller coasters do 50-60m/s^2. I don't think this is a major problem. Just accelerate slower.
- tigershark 9y agoSource? From what I know 6g is the realm of anti-g suit, it seems quite strange to me that it is deemed normal in an attraction used also by children.
- Robotbeat 9y agoHumans are pretty tough, it turns out. And people often are overly conservative in these kinds of discussions. http://rollercoaster.wikia.com/wiki/Highest_G-Force_on_a_Roller_Coaster http://rollercoaster.wikia.com/wiki/Highest_G-Force_on_a_Rol...
- adrianN 9y agoMaybe you don't want to have a transportation system that is as uncomfortable to ride as a rollercoaster. You might want to be able to transport frail elderly people and small children as well.
- Robotbeat 9y agoThis is a test track and a competition. Nobody is claiming to build a passenger hyperloop with these accelerations except for fun.
- wlesieutre 9y ago
- melling 9y agoChina seems like the place to build the first hyperloop. It would cost a lot less and they’ve already embraced HSR. They’re increasing their trains to 248 mph. https://www.nbcnews.com/mach/science/china-reclaim-title-world-s-fastest-train-ncna794931 https://www.nbcnews.com/mach/science/china-reclaim-title-wor... Long routes like Beijing/Shanghai would greatly benefit from a hyperloop. They transport almost 1.5 billion people yearly on 12,000 miles of HSR, and they’re building another 10,000 miles.
- eplanit 9y agoI agree -- in fact I'd wager that California is likely to be a laggard in this race. Highway expansion is very slow, causing clogged freeways, and local commutes in populated areas like LA and San Fran are among the worst in the nation. BART is embarrassingly old and dilapidated. The new Bay Bridge was way over schedule and budget (and with serious quality issues)...Given the track record with "traditional" infrastructure, I just don't see California being a leader in this area. Maybe some of the tech will be conceived here, but implementation would be different.
- Robotbeat 9y agoExcept this is the whole reason Musk developed the Hyperloop concept. He was annoyed at sitting through California traffic. Ironically, it is California's crappy traditional infrastructure that birthed Hyperloop.
- melling 9y agoThe idea is to build the first one sooner rather than later. Then everyone who wants it can build it. Sort of like Bill Gates working with China to get the next generation of nuclear energy developed in China. https://qz.com/627113/bill-gates-says-china-is-the-best-place-to-pursue-next-generation-nuclear-power/ https://qz.com/627113/bill-gates-says-china-is-the-best-plac...
- beamatronic 9y ago
- alacombe 9y ago> The fastest train in service is around 270mph [...] French TGV has broken the 350mph limit in non-commercial run.
- nbanks 9y agoCould "normal" wheeled train could go this fast reliably in a vacuum chamber? I suspect heat in the wheels and bearings would cause problems, especially without air cooling, but it would take much less energy to drive the train.
- kuschku 9y agoThe fastest train in service by the way: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shanghai_Maglev_Train https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shanghai_Maglev_Train (Which is a version of the SIEMENS Transrapid Maglev system)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- bluejekyll 9y ago> If you pump the (vast majority of the) air out, no reason you couldn't get supersonic. Doesn't this sound like a maintenance nightmare? I'm not clear on a couple of things. What happens when the vacuum fails? What happens to passengers if the seal fails on the vehicle, and then all the air is sucked into the vacuum? Maintaining long tunnels is by itself hard, but it seems like maintaining long tunnels that also need to maintain a vacuum would be that much more complex. I don't see much discussion on this aspect of the hyperloop.
- ATsch 9y agoThe maintainance of a vacuum tube this long and the consequences of a failure are a main theme in most hyperloop "debunking" videos on YouTube.
- jldugger 9y agoI'm guessing that any leak is likely to be small, and thus slow. And depending on how many vehicles are 'in flight' at once, and how easy it is to detect, they could be slowed down before hitting atmospheric pressure to avoid shocks or vehicle damage.
- russdill 9y agoWe already run vehicles in 0.14 atm environments. The issue of running these vehicles in an environment hostile to human life has been mitigated pretty well.
- Strom 9y agoIn regards to there being more than expected air in the tunnel - the vehicle would be slower, but not much else right? Less air than expected inside the vehicle could be life-threatening for breathers. For humans we could solve this with an emergency oxygen hose at every seat like in planes. Pets and other oxygen dependant lifeforms wouldn't be protected by this system though. An alternative could be to have an electronic hatch at regular distances in the tunnel. So when a vehicle detects a massive oxygen leak inside the cabin, it could signal the nearby tunnel hatch to open. The whole tunnel, and thus also the vehicle [1] would fill with air pretty fast. -- [1] The vehicle would have a large hole in order for oxygen levels to suddenly go from life-sustaining to not. Thus that same hole would serve to refill the vehicle with oxygen coming from the tunnel hatch. However there could be an additional hatch for the vehicle to guarantee airflow. This could maybe even mount directly to a tunnel hatch, so that outside air would come to the vehicle and skip the tunnel.