10 ms·
German students win hyperloop competition, reaching 200 mph
- sillysaurus3 9y agoHoly moly that's fast. https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/902039243601485824 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/902039243601485824 Can you imagine traveling that way? Sorry for the fluff comment, but wow!
- mason55 9y ago> Can you imagine traveling that way? Plenty of people can imagine it because they travel that way every day. Trains all over Asia and Europe reach those speeds and faster.
- yorwba 9y agoMaybe I have been taking the wrong trains (in Germany), but 200 mph (321 km/h) seems plenty fast to me. That's higher than the maximum speed of most of Deutsche Bahn's high-speed trains: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intercity-Express https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intercity-Express Even those that can go faster than 300 km/h tend to do so only on very short legs, because they need long straight stretches to stay on track and have to accelerate/decelerate at the ends as well.
- adrianN 9y agoHyperloops would also have those constraints on track layout.
- stevep98 9y agoI think this is another reason why musk is getting into tunneling. Reducing the cost of tunnels lets you place the hyperloop track in a more optimal location.
- convolvatron 9y agowould you still use a steel containment pipe? poured cement seems like it would be cheaper, but every example I've seen develops cracks and starts letting in water.
- _Codemonkeyism 9y agoReal high speed in Germany does not make sense, too many stops due to political reasons ("Wolfsburg" comes to mind and "Kassel"). That's the reason new ICE trains are slower than their predecessors. Other countries have far fewer stops on high speed routes and can therefor have faster trains (e.g. Japan and France).
- xU1ppskunDmy6oz 9y agoDistances in China are enormous compared to those within Germany. Japan is in the convenient situation of being rather long and slim so that its railway network is almost 1D rather than 2D. So their settings are quite different. Note how the ICE 3 operates at 320km/h and the ICE 4 only goes up to 230km/h. I would assume they’re optimising for efficiency now.
- qntty 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siemens_Velaro https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siemens_Velaro
- alacombe 9y agoNot in a 10ft wide, hundreds of miles long tunnel; this is making a big difference.
- Robotbeat 9y agoThere are ~5ft diameter natural gas pipelines operating at high pressure (>1000psi) that are thousands of miles long: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yamal-Europe_pipeline https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yamal-Europe_pipeline You could fit a hyperloop pod in one of those, just seat single-file. Larger diameter is optimal since you can get by with a lower pressure, but we're in the ballpark here already.
- stevep98 9y agoIn a gas pipeline, the high pressures help to stiffen the structure. In a hyperloop, you have very low pressure inside the pipe which changes the pipe design completely. https://youtu.be/T9bpUfWy8Wg?t=161 https://youtu.be/T9bpUfWy8Wg?t=161
- Robotbeat 9y agoCertainly and good point, but vacuum is just -15psi while these gas pipelines are 1200psi, almost a factor of 100 greater. Simply the required thickness of metal for 1200psi may provide sufficient stiffness to withstand vacuum. In fact, let's do the math. For a typical carbon steel tensile strength of 370MPa, internal pressure of 1200psi with a factor of safety of 2, and a radius of 2.5ft, you'd need 3.4cm thick walls: 2.5ft/(370MPa/(2 * 1200psi)) in cm https://www.google.com/search?q=2.5ft/(370MPa/(2*1200psi) https://www.google.com/search?q=2.5ft/(370MPa/(2*1200psi)) According to this design guide for carbon steels, and using 30psi pressure differential for vacuum (i.e. a factor of safety of 2), we get: http://lss.fnal.gov/archive/test-tm/1000/fermilab-tm-1378.pdf http://lss.fnal.gov/archive/test-tm/1000/fermilab-tm-1378.pd... 1.2cm thick walls, which is much thinner than the gas pipeline. 5ft * ((1-.28^2) * 30psi/(2 * 30 * 10^6psi))^(1/3) in cm https://www.google.com/search?q=5ft*((1-.28^2)*30psi/(2*30*10^6psi))^(1/3) https://www.google.com/search?q=5ft*((1-.28^2)*30psi/(2*30*1... So those gas pipelines should already be plenty thick enough for vacuum service. My point stands.
- moogly 9y agoBear in mind the camera is close to the ground (not to mention in a very narrow tunnel) which exaggerates the feeling of speed.
- Robotbeat 9y agoIt should be noted the California bullet train is planned to run at 220mph for its fastest leg, so this is within spitting distance already. If you pump the (vast majority of the) air out, no reason you couldn't get supersonic. That's much faster than any non-rocket-propelled train has ever gone. The fastest train in service is around 270mph, more experimental maglevs have reached 375mph. Supersonic is 767mph, so over twice the fastest maglev.
- nether 9y ago"supersonic" relative to the sound speed at normal density I assume. With no air, there would be no sound! Edit: corrected pressure to density
- Robotbeat 9y agohttps://mobile.twitter.com/elonmusk/status/901975117797851137 https://mobile.twitter.com/elonmusk/status/90197511779785113... @elonmusk: "No such thing as true vacuum" BTW, speed of sound doesn't change (to first order) with changing pressure (edit: nor does it change (to first order) with density, assuming temperature is the same). Mostly effected by temperature. Hyperloop uses a partial vacuum, of course. No true vacuum exists.
- _Codemonkeyism 9y ago"No true vacuum exist." How high is density of atoms in space? Could there be a 1mm x 1mm space without atoms?
- vlahmot 9y agoMy understanding is that there would still be quantum fluctuatons causing particles to pop in and out of existence.
- _Codemonkeyism 9y agoWould this be protons? Can vacuum contain photons and still be a vacuum? Not sure :-)
- Robotbeat 9y agoMusk made comments about traveling at up to 800mph in this 0.8 mile tube. At constant acceleration, you'd have to have about 10 gees (each way) to reach this speed in that short tunnel: sqrt(2 * acceleration * distance) = speed sqrt(2 * 100m/s^2 * 0.4mi)=358m/s = 800mph https://www.google.com/search?q=sqrt(2*100m/s^2*0.4mi) https://www.google.com/search?q=sqrt(2*100m/s^2*0.4mi) To accelerate at 100m/s^2 at the end when you're at 358m/s requires about 35.8kW/kg, which is /insane/. You'd need some sort of active cooling to get that to work. (Water flashed to vapor? Liquid nitrogen?) So you'd probably have a really high acceleration at first (as fast as the sled could handle, maybe 100g?) and really hard deceleration at the end in order to reduce required electric motor specific power. Might be tough to do all that with a single motor, so you probably need either gearing or a two-stage design, with a larger low-speed, extreme acceleration stage pushing a lighter high speed moderate acceleration stage. I don't know if two stage designs are allowed, but it'd certainly help in this competition.
- tveita 9y agoDetails on the winning pod: http://hyperloop.warr.de/pod-ii/ http://hyperloop.warr.de/pod-ii/ IIUC it accelerates using a wheel pressed towards the track, powered by an electric engine... no fancy magnets or fans and air cushions. It's cool, but it doesn't look a lot like the original Hyperloop white paper. e: from the competition rules at http://www.spacex.com/sites/spacex/files/2016_0831_hyperloop_competition_ii_rules.pdf http://www.spacex.com/sites/spacex/files/2016_0831_hyperloop..., it looks like they were at least using an evacuated tube.
- giarc 9y ago>It's cool, but it doesn't look a lot like the original Hyperloop white paper. That's the first thing I noticed. This seems like a competition for fast electric train.
- lucideer 9y agoFrom my understanding, it seems the main concept behind Hyperloop is a "fast electric train" in an evacuated tube. Other design details from the original spec. don't seem as central to the definition.
- InclinedPlane 9y agoAnd? The Wright Flyer had a terrible mechanism for flight controls, it's good that was moved away from. Innovation is about iteratively pursuing progressively better designs, even if they differ from your original concept.
- Robotbeat 9y agoBy the way, the only reason commercial air travel can go at transonic speeds (670mph) efficiently is because it's at near vacuum, i.e. at high altitude, just like Hyperloop. That's also why conventional or maglev non-vacuum trains won't ever travel as fast as passenger air travel cruise speed. It takes a stupendous amount of energy to travel that fast near sea level. Even a lot of supersonic fighter jets can only reach supersonic speeds at high altitude. The whole advantage of hyperloop (and vacuum-trains) is you're bringing that high altitude air down to near sea level. The other things are implementation details. This is why hyperloops will fairly quickly eclipse other train speed records, currently 375mph for maglev. Just a FYI, the Hyperloop One pod recently reached 192mph, so this student pod bested them (although the student pod is much smaller and the student competition hyperloop track is much longer, so the Hyperloop One pod must've been higher performance).
- jacquesm 9y agoAir pressure at 10 km altitude is about 30% or so of sea level, it is much less but definitely not near vacuum. If it were a near vacuum any airplane would stall...
- Robotbeat 9y ago747 max altitude is 45,100ft, or 16% sea level. At Concorde's cruise altitude of 18000m, it's just 8% of sea level. Of course, Concorde had to fly very fast to keep from stalling. U2 spy plane has the same problem at 21,000ft, 5% sea level pressure. It's nearly stalled while cruising. I wouldn't call that "definitely not near vacuum." Still higher planes, one at 100,000 ft, have flown (NASA's Helios), 1% atm. Near Mars pressures, definitely near vacuum. (as much as this term is subjective) Hyperloop One plans an altitude equivalent of about 200,000 ft, or about 0.16% sea level pressure.
- jacquesm 9y agoSeen any Concordes lately? The last time I saw one it was sitting on a static display looking very good but going nowhere. Concorde is not a representative sample of passenger air travel, neither is a U2 spy plane nor is Helios. What Hyperloop One plans is not relevant, what they will manage to achieve is and there is no way that they will manage to run that network at 0.16% of sea level pressure. The whole hyperloop discussion would benefit from an injection of some solid engineering principles, the linked article is a nice example of what can be done and even if they won a competition has nothing to do with the hyperloop concept as presented originally, the vast majority of the original engineering challenges still stands.
- atroyn 9y agoImportant to note, the WARR team doesn't receive any funding or direct support from the university - not even professors or Ph.D's. This is a 100% student created and run initiative
- Radim 9y agoMakes winning so much sweeter: no need to concede bullshit "acknowledgements" to absent profs and grant agencies and supervisors who sit the entire project out, only to inject themselves into the final credits and collect the post-victory interviews. Standard academic practice. Great job, students!
- cma 9y agoWhy wouldn't a grant agency get acknowledgements if they provided funding? If you look at the winning pod, it is covered with logos of sponsors as acknowledgement.
- jldugger 9y agoIt's one thing to have a line in a paper saying 'this research was funded in part by the NSF' and another thing entirely to have people talking to the media about said work.
- mc32 9y agoIt's not all that different from accelerators partially funding startups and associating themselves with the successes as long,as they want. I think it's arguable earned.
- _Codemonkeyism 9y agoIs WARR the cart in the image? Why does it have all those logos?
- dna_polymerase 9y ago
- Animats 9y agoThe WARR sled runs on, and is propelled by, wheels.[1] It's not flying on an air cushion, which was the original Hyperloop concept. Nor is it a maglev, like Hyperloop One.[2] (That's a vactrain.) [1] http://hyperloop.warr.de/pod-ii/ http://hyperloop.warr.de/pod-ii/ [2] https://hyperloop-one.com/blog/how-and-why-were-levitating https://hyperloop-one.com/blog/how-and-why-were-levitating
- kaffeemitsahne 9y agoSo originally they wanted to have an air cushion, inside a vacuum enclosure?
- nbanks 9y agoYes. The Hyperloop concept Musk published in 2013 [1] was based on a partial vacuum with air cushions like a plane flying at 40,000 feet rather than a satellite zooming through space. [1] http://www.spacex.com/sites/spacex/files/hyperloop_alpha-20130812.pdf http://www.spacex.com/sites/spacex/files/hyperloop_alpha-201...
- Animats 9y agoRead the original Hyperloop paper.[1] [1] http://www.spacex.com/sites/spacex/files/hyperloop_alpha-20130812.pdf http://www.spacex.com/sites/spacex/files/hyperloop_alpha-201...
- ambar123 9y agoOnly 2. Race got best when it comes to engineering... Germans and japanese... No surprising result here...