5 ms·
The interesting question here is: why undocumented. It was created on request, but nobody was told. Who pushed so hard ME to be on for everything but them? And
by dmitrygr 9y ago
The interesting question here is: why undocumented. It was created on request, but nobody was told. Who pushed so hard ME to be on for everything but them? And why? We know the answer :)
- lima 9y agoAs soon as it's documented, you have to support it.
- tux3 9y agoNot wanting to support it is a strange argument for not documenting it. I am not surprised that they're not documenting it, but not for this reason. Their client — the Unites States Government — demanded this feature be made specifically for their internal use, so I would hope it is a pretty well supported configuration already. Furthermore as it only seems to be disabling features rather than enabling new ones, there should be little support needed in the first place. Anyone with the knowledge and equipment to go enable the HAP bit is unlikely to need any more support than the documentation itself.
- ajross 9y ago> Not wanting to support it is a strange argument for not documenting it. Seriously, no. That happens all the time in all kinds of software environments. Someone adds a crazy hack in a product with an API. Do you add it to the API, even though bits of it may leak visibly into the stuff seen by the customer? Hell no. That's what happened here.
- codezero 9y agoIntel's response to the authors kind of explains it: they added this feature hastily to meet specific requirements of the HAP program and didn't fully validate it – so it's not supported.
- dmitrygr 9y agoYou missed the point. It was added for people with big money. I promise you - it is supported. Just not for you. You need to be backdoorable. They don't
- etatoby 9y agoME itself was added for people with big money. I'm not an engineer experienced in this kind of work, but I fail to see how a company whose core business is manufacturing chips would develop an entire computer (comprising an x86 CPU, its own RAM, MINIX OS, and access to all kinds of I/O) hidden inside each one of their chips and made largely inaccessible to regular users and developers. Unless they are paid very well to do so. In retrospect they were kind of naive not to make it much harder to enable this HAP mode, considering the lengths they went to make ME tamper proof. They left the flag wide open and even commented it in an XML file.
- verall 9y agoThis sort of microcontroller for bringup and/or power in a large processor/SoC is not surprising at all. Intel ME is used for large scale setup and provisioning of new machines and is probably worth every penny to their OEM customers. I'm not saying that the NSA isn't possibly using it as a backdoor, but to say that the whole ME subsystem was created because they were paid off by the NSA is a bit far fetched.
- the8472 9y ago> comprising an x86 CPU The ME runs an Argonaut RISC Core instruction set and leverages a lot of the existing infrastructure in the system since it sits directly in the chipset and can ask the main CPU to do some things on its behalf too.
- 4ad 9y agoNo, the new ME chip is an x86 running Minix. It's in the article, did you read it?
- 9y ago
- leggomylibro 9y agoHonestly? Chips are full of undocumented commands. It's really, really annoying. I've been working on getting small TFTs working, for example. Many of them use a common driver chip that supports your basic 8080 parallel interface. The driver manufacturer provides a datasheet documenting the various commands which it will accept. So of course, to start the chip up, you need to send it a series of magic commands and data values which are not documented in the datasheet. Adafruit was kind enough to explain the reasoning behind these values to someone who was presumably walking through the same steps as me to bring one of these screens up: https://forums.adafruit.com/viewtopic.php?f=47&t=63229 https://forums.adafruit.com/viewtopic.php?f=47&t=63229 I guess that maybe it prevents people from buying secondhand stock and getting it working from just the datasheet, without involving the original manufacturer? Anyways, caveat emptor. Even when there's only one seller to emptor from.