3 ms·
> What they should have done is learned when to move or when to stay by: 1. Not buying a house in Houston and then 2. Gotten out well before it was imminent. T
by tzs 9y ago
> What they should have done is learned when to move or when to stay by: 1. Not buying a house in Houston and then 2. Gotten out well before it was imminent.
The reports I've seen are describing the Houston situation as a 1 in a 1000 year flood. Does it really make sense to avoid a place based on the possibility of such rare events?
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoI mean the same areas that flooded now flooded in Ike, Rita and Allison, so yea it does make sense. My family lived through each and I'm not sure why they stick where they are.
- inborn 9y agofrom what I can tell, it's healthier to live near the water, especially the ocean. so would you see also having an inland retreat as an appropriate set up?
- Sukotto 9y agoKatrina was a "once a hundred year" storm. Likewise Sandy. Now Harvey is a "once in 500". All within 12 years. I think we should stop measuring against data from a different global climate.
- cbr 9y agoA "hundred year storm" doesn't mean we expect one per hundred years globally, but one per hundred years locally.
- JshWright 9y agoEven that is a little misleading (given how bad our intuition about statistics is). A '100 year flood' is flood that has a 1% chance of occurring in any given year (it's independent of what happened 1, 5, or 50 years ago). Calling it a '100 year flood' makes people think 'oh, good, now we shouldn't have one of those for another ~100 years'. In reality, the odds of a flood of the same magnitude occurring next year are exactly the same as they were this year. Grady (of the Practical Engineering YouTube channel) has a great video on this topic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EACkiMRT0pc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EACkiMRT0pc (Grady is in the Austin area, so hopefully he hasn't too much 'practical' experience from this storm...)
- bluGill 9y agoThe other thing to remember is a 5 year flood and a 100 year flood are often not very different in size.
- brlewis 9y agoWhen you buy a house in a town there's some chance you may spend the rest of your life there. Even if the risk really is 1/1000 per year, it's still N/1000 per house. And the risk may be higher than 1/1000 per year given how much motivation is out there to understate the risk and say that nobody could have seen this coming.
- honestoHeminway 9y agoIt makes sense to rationalize a disaster as somebodys own fault, to get out of the guilt anyone should feel who is so anti-social he can abandon his community on a whime.