7 ms·
Is there a middle ground? My kids went as part of a team to help people rebuild after Katrina and one of the folks they met was rebuilding their house but build
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
Is there a middle ground? My kids went as part of a team to help people rebuild after Katrina and one of the folks they met was rebuilding their house but building it as a boat. They had re-done the foundation so that the house rested on it, and its sewer connection was just the house pipe inset into the city pipe (so it could easily lift out). That, 15' of chain to allow the house to float above the foundation and central concrete and iron pillar which was essentially the keel.
I thought of them reading about Harvey and I am wondering if they will show up on the news at some point.
I compared it a bit to my efforts to insure my house remains intact and upright in the event of an earthquake (the 'likely' disaster where I live).
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoThere certainly is a middle ground - however why stay in the same place and expect a different future? New Orleans isn't that much more prepared for another flood. Houston re-did the entire bayou system about 5 years ago and yet here we are. People's aversion to moving, especially after a major disaster, boggles my mind.
- fweespeech 9y ago> People's aversion to moving, especially after a major disaster, boggles my mind. Social connections, networks that enable employment, and a lack of serious financial reserves (which will always be true for ~50% of people) are the main reasons. And no area is immune to disaster and lacks challenges. The "low natural disaster" areas have a total lack of warning before disaster strikes, heavy snowfall that can cripple normal services, deserts with poisonous creatures, or some combination of those three. For the most part, to be perfectly honest, as long as you are capable of picking up and moving on short notice...hurricane country is actually safer due to the amount of warning you get.
- viraptor 9y agoCentral/eastern Europe is pretty good as far as disasters go. The most likely thing to happen is flooding from the local river and majority of them have designated flood areas. After that it's just heat waves and occasional freezing days. (Mostly affects elderly) No wildlife to worry about. Snow is common enough that a lot of people know to switch to winter tyres and roads are salted and cleared.
- kaybe 9y agoSome storms too that break trees and take down shingles. I think the most common death by nature might be getting hit by a tree during or after a storm.
- fweespeech 9y agoTo be honest, the legal environment in Central/Eastern Europe in regards to speech would be a greater threat to me than the environment.
- nl 9y agoCentral/eastern Europe is pretty good as far as disasters go. Natural disasters, perhaps. That region doesn't have a great record in terms of political stability, and often has the bad luck of being in the middle of a warzone though.
- oblio 9y agoThis a humongous generalization. There's about 1/10th of the region that was in a war zone in the last 70 years (Yugoslavia, Eastern Ukraine), and those wars didn't really concern neighboring countries. Regarding political stability, I'd argue that a huge part of the region was very stable for 40 years, under the Communist yoke :p
- nl 9y agoThere's about 1/10th of the region that was in a war zone in the last 70 years (Yugoslavia, Eastern Ukraine), and those wars didn't really concern neighboring countries. That 70 years (which is debatable!) maybe the longest period of peace in the area in recorded history. Possibly the peace of 1871 to 1914 is the only other alternative. Here's a list of conflicts in Europe since 1945[1]. Even before the fall of the Soviet Union there were some conflicts. For example, the Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia was in 1968 and was a reasonable major conflict. (Note that I'm not claiming that Eastern/Central Europe is unique in this! Mostly densely populated areas are similar, and Western Europe scores only slightly better if you don't count revolutionary movements within the counties). Regarding political stability, I'd argue that a huge part of the region was very stable for 40 years, under the Communist yoke Yes, indeed this is true. As I note above the 1945-1990 period was very stable except for Czechoslovakia invasion of course. They were pretty lucky in Poland in the 1980s too. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pax_Europaea https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pax_Europaea
- rodgerd 9y ago> People's aversion to moving, especially after a major disaster, boggles my mind. There was a period where the banking regulator for New Zealand was going to force all the major banks to move their IT shops from Wellington to Christchurch because Wellington was at too high a risk of a natural disaster. A couple of years later, an earthquake on a hitherto-unknown fault flattened Christchurch.
- icebraining 9y agoThat's why I walk on the middle of the road - people have been killed on the sidewalks!
- stale2002 9y agoThe vast majority of emergency situations that a person is going to face isn't going to require something so drastic as moving. Most people are not going to have to worry about a hurricane or a flood. Most people have more mundane problems, that are still potentially life altering.
- altotrees 9y agoTo take it a step further, the area in which I come from has been hit hard with economic and social disasters. Even though factories are closing down and heroin deaths are rising each day, people choose to stay here. Family and other social networks are a big part of it I think, as someone said downthread. I bolted as soon as I could to gain employment and the resources of a bigger city. It still boggles my mind that more people my age don't, as things seem to be getting worse rather than better. But it's home, it's familiar, it's comforting, no matter what issues may loom. I had cousins refuse to leave post-Katrina New Orleans for similar reasons. Sorry, just a comparison to your line of thinking from a different angle, slightly related.
- quickthrower2 9y agoMakes sense not to move if you own a home. Property will be hardest to sell right after disaster. Let alone moving means you need to convince your Family and their other family and their other family's family to move etc. Or go it alone but ties like that are strong. Is everyone on HN moving to their optimal place regardless of friends or family considerations?
- bluGill 9y agoYour current house is a sunk cost. I have sold a house at a loss and moved to a different city. I didn't like it, but moving was the right thing so I did.
- quickthrower2 9y agoThat is true it's a sunk cost. But still gains made on the capital can be high after the disaster. It's like holding stocks after the GFC.
- bitwize 9y agoYou uh... don't know too many people from New Orleans do you? Ask them to move and they will look at you as if you'd grown another head. Maybe moving elsewhere is easy for you, upper-middle-class person with marketable skills and no loyalties. But to them it's like saying "Hey, why don't you just walk away from everyone and everything, the people and sights and smells and sounds, you cherish? You won't? What are you, insane?"
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoYou won't find argument from me that people are irrational friend.
- ZenoArrow 9y agoIt's more than just irrationality. I've never been there, but from what I've seen New Orleans has a unique culture that you can't find anywhere else. It's not irrational to want to be part of that culture, even if there's the occasional risk of flooding.
- giardini 9y agoWell, they really didn't "redo the entire bayou system". They considered alternatives and chose the most politically correct one for the parties involved. They knew it wasn't enough for something like Harvey but they didn't think there would be a Harvey( a supposed "500-year event") anytime soon. Black Swan anyone? AndrewKemendo says: "People's aversion to moving, especially after a major disaster, boggles my mind." But where do you go to be safe from disasters? California - earthquakes, mudslides, wildfires, torrential rains, rip currents, and even volcanoes Gulf Coast - hurricanes Midwest - tornadoes etc. Slate Magazine set out to find where you could live free of potential disasters. See: "Where To Hide From Mother Nature" http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/the_gist/2005/09/where_to_hide_from_mother_nature.html http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/the_gist/200... Their conclusion: "Slate's "America's Best Place to Avoid Death Due to Natural Disaster": the area in and around Storrs, Conn., home to the University of Connecticut..." Read the article to see if you're ready to make the move.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoDayton tops the list for least natural disaster prone. Similar with Southern Maryland. Denver is pretty high on the list and Seattle seems pretty safe too. There are plenty of places to go. For some reason we seem to love to build massive cities on disaster areas. I'm looking at you SF, LA and NYC. But hey fuck it, lets just continue being bad at statistics and assume that because a natural disaster happened recently it won't happen again for a long time (the idea of a "500 year" storm is insane). [1]https://www.cbsnews.com/media/top-10-safest-us-cities-from-natural-disasters/ https://www.cbsnews.com/media/top-10-safest-us-cities-from-n...
- smhinsey 9y agoThere is a really interesting episode of the UK show Grand Designs that follows someone in a flood prone area who built a house that essentially rests within its own drydock structure. Worth a watch if you find this sort of thing interesting and the show is fascinating in general. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=16scx81p2w4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=16scx81p2w4
- arethuza 9y agoWe spent nearly 9 months house hunting in Scotland - I was genuinely shocked to find out that new houses were often in fairly high risk areas for flooding. Trying to find somewhere rural in the right area with low flooding risk and low risk from mining related problems and with decent internet access was non-trivial.
- et-al 9y agoDepending on where this is, you can think of it as generations of people have already picked out and settled in the naturally safe spots. What's left then are the less desirable, potentially riskier locations.
- cbr 9y agoits sewer connection was just the house pipe inset into the city pipe That connection isn't too bad, but I'm curious how they dealt with water supply and (if they have it) natural gas? Those are much harder to make flexible.
- qbrass 9y agoThey make flexible lines for both.
- Spooky23 9y agoIMO the middle ground is to move! I live in a place where other than a 3-4 days of average annual disruption due to snow, the only real natural disaster risks are associated by poorly engineered and maintained sewers backing up. I find it bizarre that I've spent millions over the years providing disaster recovery and resiliency for relatively unimportant things, but the combo of a devastating hurricane in Texas and major earthquake in Northern California could essentially trigger a economic calamity.
- jdcarter 9y agoAmsterdam has entire neighborhoods of floating houses. Not houseboats, but house-shaped houses that float. See: http://www.amusingplanet.com/2015/06/the-floating-houses-of-ijburg-amsterdam.html http://www.amusingplanet.com/2015/06/the-floating-houses-of-...