9 ms·
I dunno, I re-read the beginning and I didn't see anything about the points I raised. I think your point that overzealous people who as you put it: begin by sh
by AndrewKemendo 9y ago
I dunno, I re-read the beginning and I didn't see anything about the points I raised. I think your point that overzealous people who as you put it:
begin by shopping for ballistic vests and night vision goggles; they would be better served by grabbing a fire extinguisher, some bottled water, and then putting the rest of their money in a rainy-day fund.
is right on point, but IMO that just says - hey don't be insane.
Literally right now, my good friends are being rescued from a rooftop in Houston. No number of bottles of water in their basement or generators are going to help them. They are lucky in that they have some discretionary funds and Flood insurance, but more likely than not (if history repeats itself) they wont get fully paid out for what they lost.
What they should have done is learned when to move or when to stay by: 1. Not buying a house in Houston and then 2. Gotten out well before it was imminent.
Small scale common adversities like you are talking about can get critical really quickly. All those preparations, other than just having savings, is just making you slightly more comfortable and buy you a little bit of time so that you can make a bigger plan. Good, but insufficient and gives you a false sense of security. Again, these are things I've seen over and over.
Planning for the range of disasters from a month of unemployment and TEOTWAWKI is the same basic mental change, not just a full basement and bank account.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoIs there a middle ground? My kids went as part of a team to help people rebuild after Katrina and one of the folks they met was rebuilding their house but building it as a boat. They had re-done the foundation so that the house rested on it, and its sewer connection was just the house pipe inset into the city pipe (so it could easily lift out). That, 15' of chain to allow the house to float above the foundation and central concrete and iron pillar which was essentially the keel. I thought of them reading about Harvey and I am wondering if they will show up on the news at some point. I compared it a bit to my efforts to insure my house remains intact and upright in the event of an earthquake (the 'likely' disaster where I live).
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoThere certainly is a middle ground - however why stay in the same place and expect a different future? New Orleans isn't that much more prepared for another flood. Houston re-did the entire bayou system about 5 years ago and yet here we are. People's aversion to moving, especially after a major disaster, boggles my mind.
- fweespeech 9y ago> People's aversion to moving, especially after a major disaster, boggles my mind. Social connections, networks that enable employment, and a lack of serious financial reserves (which will always be true for ~50% of people) are the main reasons. And no area is immune to disaster and lacks challenges. The "low natural disaster" areas have a total lack of warning before disaster strikes, heavy snowfall that can cripple normal services, deserts with poisonous creatures, or some combination of those three. For the most part, to be perfectly honest, as long as you are capable of picking up and moving on short notice...hurricane country is actually safer due to the amount of warning you get.
- viraptor 9y agoCentral/eastern Europe is pretty good as far as disasters go. The most likely thing to happen is flooding from the local river and majority of them have designated flood areas. After that it's just heat waves and occasional freezing days. (Mostly affects elderly) No wildlife to worry about. Snow is common enough that a lot of people know to switch to winter tyres and roads are salted and cleared.
- kaybe 9y agoSome storms too that break trees and take down shingles. I think the most common death by nature might be getting hit by a tree during or after a storm.
- fweespeech 9y agoTo be honest, the legal environment in Central/Eastern Europe in regards to speech would be a greater threat to me than the environment.
- smhinsey 9y agoThere is a really interesting episode of the UK show Grand Designs that follows someone in a flood prone area who built a house that essentially rests within its own drydock structure. Worth a watch if you find this sort of thing interesting and the show is fascinating in general. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=16scx81p2w4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=16scx81p2w4
- arethuza 9y agoWe spent nearly 9 months house hunting in Scotland - I was genuinely shocked to find out that new houses were often in fairly high risk areas for flooding. Trying to find somewhere rural in the right area with low flooding risk and low risk from mining related problems and with decent internet access was non-trivial.
- et-al 9y agoDepending on where this is, you can think of it as generations of people have already picked out and settled in the naturally safe spots. What's left then are the less desirable, potentially riskier locations.
- cbr 9y agoits sewer connection was just the house pipe inset into the city pipe That connection isn't too bad, but I'm curious how they dealt with water supply and (if they have it) natural gas? Those are much harder to make flexible.
- qbrass 9y agoThey make flexible lines for both.
- Spooky23 9y agoIMO the middle ground is to move! I live in a place where other than a 3-4 days of average annual disruption due to snow, the only real natural disaster risks are associated by poorly engineered and maintained sewers backing up. I find it bizarre that I've spent millions over the years providing disaster recovery and resiliency for relatively unimportant things, but the combo of a devastating hurricane in Texas and major earthquake in Northern California could essentially trigger a economic calamity.
- jdcarter 9y agoAmsterdam has entire neighborhoods of floating houses. Not houseboats, but house-shaped houses that float. See: http://www.amusingplanet.com/2015/06/the-floating-houses-of-ijburg-amsterdam.html http://www.amusingplanet.com/2015/06/the-floating-houses-of-...
- nebabyte 9y ago> What they should have done is learned when to move or when to stay by: 1. Not buying a house in Houston and then 2. Gotten out well before it was imminent I'm not sure what degree of freedom you're supposing they have, but not everyone is able to uproot their life on some survivalist kick. Plenty of people have their roots and networks where they are, so "just don't live there" isn't a universally applicable "fix". I've been fortunate enough to be able to move to a place ideally suited to my needs (and as I don't need much I suppose I could move on relatively short notice if needed) but even I recognize that not everyone can afford to follow suit.
- afterburner 9y agoYou're missing his point. He's not saying he expects everyone to do this. He's just saying when to move or not move is often more important than any other considerations. Note that he included as an option leaving well before the storm hit. And there was plenty of warning on this storm.
- tcoppi 9y agoExactly, there is no reason anyone should be on the roof of their homes in Houston other than inability to heed warnings and read a weather report.
- Klinky 9y agoWhen a mass evacuation of Houston occurred due to Hurricane Rita, 107 people died from the conditions caused by the mass evacuation. The conditions on the roads were very very poor for those following your suggested advice of "heeding the warnings". The storm in the end was not as big of an event as it was made out to be. It's not as simple a decision as you're making it out to be. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hurricane_Rita#Evacuation_deaths https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hurricane_Rita#Evacuation_deat...
- chiph 9y agoThe governor told people to leave. The mayor told people to stay. One of them isn't going to be reelected next term... Probably what should have happened (I'm using my perfect hindsight here..) is they should have told people living in low-lying areas to either go live with relatives or friends who were on high ground, or leave town altogether. And everyone else to stay. This would have prevented the mass exodus that clogged roads during previous storms, but gotten more people to safety.
- yourapostasy 9y ago> Literally right now, my good friends are being rescued from a rooftop in Houston. No number of bottles of water in their basement or generators are going to help them. Some of this outcome is a direct result of conforming to commercially-fabricated social pressure. In this particular case, floodplain maps are publicly and freely available, so anyone can build structures that rise well above the highest-projected floods. Except that developers don't want to have to build on top of stilts or as tethered floating structures. It decreases the available pool of customers looking for a pre-packaged vision of what they "should" buy, and it's more expensive than "conventional" building designs. This illustrates that for some, a preparedness mindset can include thinking for oneself and outside social norms, with the aim of avoiding placing themselves in a situation that calls for preparedness to begin with. Teaching youngsters how to deconstruct the marketing that militates against this kind of mindset to externalize a future cost upon them in order to lift an immediate profit into the commercial entities standing behind those forces, can passively preempt many preparedness scenarios.
- quickthrower2 9y agoThe classic Queenslander house is built up high so it can stay cool and probably also good for a flooding scenario.
- dragonsky67 9y agoIt all depends upon how they are built. I remember a number of Queenslanders ended up floating away because the waters went above floor level. http://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-04-02/floodwaters-sweep-away-house-minutes-after-family-rescued/8409188 http://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-04-02/floodwaters-sweep-away.... They tend to not do very well in cyclones unless the builder has been very careful about tying the stumps to the floor to the walls to the roof.
- yourapostasy 9y agoThat's fascinating, thanks for the info; the Texas coast has some houses with a similar design [1]. While some use wood stilts, some are going into full fortified designs [2]. Even further afield, using principles established with invisibility cloaking research might offer even more protection in the future [3]. If plasma gasification-produced slag-based pozzolanic concrete can be proven safe and efficacious, then the pillars could literally be partially built out of garbage, co-generating energy and rock wool at the same time. [1] http://pictures.escapia.com/PTARES/1866960517.jpg http://pictures.escapia.com/PTARES/1866960517.jpg [2] http://www.texasgulfcoastonline.com/News/tabid/86/ctl/ArticleView/mid/466/articleId/56/Default.aspx http://www.texasgulfcoastonline.com/News/tabid/86/ctl/Articl... [3] https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn14829-invisibility-cloaks-could-take-sting-out-of-tsunamis/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn14829-invisibility-cl...
- tzs 9y ago> What they should have done is learned when to move or when to stay by: 1. Not buying a house in Houston and then 2. Gotten out well before it was imminent. The reports I've seen are describing the Houston situation as a 1 in a 1000 year flood. Does it really make sense to avoid a place based on the possibility of such rare events?
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoI mean the same areas that flooded now flooded in Ike, Rita and Allison, so yea it does make sense. My family lived through each and I'm not sure why they stick where they are.
- inborn 9y agofrom what I can tell, it's healthier to live near the water, especially the ocean. so would you see also having an inland retreat as an appropriate set up?
- Sukotto 9y agoKatrina was a "once a hundred year" storm. Likewise Sandy. Now Harvey is a "once in 500". All within 12 years. I think we should stop measuring against data from a different global climate.
- cbr 9y agoA "hundred year storm" doesn't mean we expect one per hundred years globally, but one per hundred years locally.
- JshWright 9y agoEven that is a little misleading (given how bad our intuition about statistics is). A '100 year flood' is flood that has a 1% chance of occurring in any given year (it's independent of what happened 1, 5, or 50 years ago). Calling it a '100 year flood' makes people think 'oh, good, now we shouldn't have one of those for another ~100 years'. In reality, the odds of a flood of the same magnitude occurring next year are exactly the same as they were this year. Grady (of the Practical Engineering YouTube channel) has a great video on this topic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EACkiMRT0pc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EACkiMRT0pc (Grady is in the Austin area, so hopefully he hasn't too much 'practical' experience from this storm...)
- im3w1l 9y ago> No number of bottles of water in their basement Some bottles of water on the rooftop could allow them to stay a little more comfortable until help arrives.
- bluGill 9y agowater on the roof will not last as long though.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- emodendroket 9y agoDepending on how long the rescue, takes having food and clean water could be important.