36 ms·
The major thing overlooked here is mindset. After 14 years in the military and experience with several armed conflicts and humanitarian disasters, I have seen t
by AndrewKemendo 9y ago
The major thing overlooked here is mindset. After 14 years in the military and experience with several armed conflicts and humanitarian disasters, I have seen that pretty much all your plans and preparation will go out the window, so you need to learn to move adapt and improvise.
If you're going to survive any contingency scenario you need to be resilient, excruciatingly innovative and mentally tough. Think more like MacGyver and less like Dr Strangelove.
Be minimal, learn how to forage and scavenge, learn how to blend in and get along and take nothing for granted.
The most successful trait I've seen in survivors it's to know when to stay put and when to move. Whether it's hiding from a mob or a bear, or finding a different county or state to go to.
Take risk when necessary but not unnecessarily.
Again, having the right mindset, through intentional training is the key. There are all kinds of survival schools and the best ones will teach you this. I suggest adventure traveling as a start. That means you go someplace with no plans and the most minimal of supplies.
Edit to add: The key problem with most prepper folks and this article is that they take an approach of "alone and unafraid." Things like stocking up for months and having all kinds of weapons. In practice this is just a great way to get your cache raided by a group of scavengers. In reality you need to find or create a small community of survival minded people that can work together successfully over a long period with a variety of skills. As humans we need groups for survival, so the best bet in a crisis is to build a resilient flexible community until things settle down.
- stutterSpeaker 9y agoSurely being economically prepared as well would be useful. Having the gear both for bug out scenarios and bug in scenarios. I know it's fun to rag on preppers, but in what way is keeping a year of food stocked and rotated through a bad idea? How is having solar panels a bad idea?
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoIt's not a bad idea per se, it's just probably overkill. I mean I keep a bug out bag and a tub of supplies, so I don't disagree wholly, but it gets out of hand quickly if you aren't thinking critically about it.
- voltagex_ 9y agoWhat's in your bug out bag?
- nebabyte 9y agoProbably because the most prudent thing for someone with means to do in circumstances which would drive them to live under their house for a year would not be to live under their house for a year. It's "not a bad idea, just a pointless one" when times are good, and a distraction from better options if something does happen. But w/e
- rodgerd 9y agoFood for a week? Good sense, although plenty of people in supposedly rich first-world nations struggle to have enough food for now, never mind a week spare. Food for a month? Maybe if you live in a region that could easily be cut off in the event of disasters. Food for a year? Listen, if things turn so badly to shit you need a year of food, food is going to be the least of your worries.
- rev_bird 9y ago>if things turn so badly to shit you need a year of food, food is going to be the least of your worries. I don't see why this is the case -- saying "doing X is going to be the least of your worries" seems to imply that there are going to be other priorities and "X" will be ignored -- i.e. "charging your phone is going to be the least of your worries." But food... you _need_ food, even if there are other crazy things happening all around you. If that's the case, I can't help thinking it would be better to do the things you CAN do to prepare. One less thing, etc.
- rodgerd 9y agoIt's a reflection of the idea that if civilisation collapses to the point you can't obtain food except by pulling it out of your emergency store a year later, you're probably going to have died of disease, injury, thirst, violence or a number of more pressing concerns. Seriously, if the ability to get food to people has been down for a full year, you won't have medicine. You almost certainly won't have fuel, electricity, public order, sanitation, or clean water.
- aethertap 9y agoOne thing that I think is frequently overlooked is that a person with a year's worth of food stored up also has enough to feed the whole neighborhood for a week if necessary, which might make a really big difference for a lot of people. Having the goods gives you a lot of flexibility and might take some of the pressure off of emergency relief services. I try to keep far more of the basic things on hand (first aid, food, and water purification stuff) than I think I'll need just because I know most people don't, and I live in a place with a moderate risk of catastrophic earthquakes and tornadoes.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- bupku5 9y agobut "foraging" for water in an urban environment probably means stealing it
- irrational 9y agoDepends on where you live. I live in the NW where it rains for 9 months of the year and the other three months there are tons of rivers and lakes. All I really need to forage for water is a bucket and a purification system. But I feel bad for people in places like Las Vegas and much of Nevada, New Mexico, Arizona, etc. where foraging for water means death.
- cylinder 9y agoWhy forage when you can easily store thousands of dense nonperishable calories at home? Heading out to the woods to pick a bucket of low calorie leafy greens seems like the last thing you want to be doing in a disaster.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoThe last thing you want to forage for in a survival scenario are greens - no competent authority would suggest that. Cattails, tubers and the like are basically worst case scenario.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoPossibly, but if that's what you need to do to survive you will. Finding and maintaining access to (aka defending) a water source is one of the most challenging parts of survival. Primarily because it locks you into a location if you let it and a quality source is a huge draw for populations - obviously. In scenarios where you're out of municipal water a few days like is happening right now in Houston (Myself and my family have been through Allison, Rita, Ike and now Harvey) then having a water cache for a week is reasonable, though really hard to do, but that's really not what we're talking about.
- 9y ago
- dotancohen 9y ago> After 14 years in the military and experience with several armed conflicts and humanitarian disasters, I have seen that pretty much all your plans and preparation will go out the window, so you need to learn to move adapt and improvise. Eisenhower said it best: Plans are worthless, but planning is priceless.
- module0000 9y agoThis is great advice. My entire military career has instilled one important value: don't panic, everything can always get worse.
- graeme 9y agoStutterSpeaker, your comment is dead. I don't think it ought to be, might want to check with the mods.
- maxerickson 9y agoIf you click on the timestamp and go to the comment page you can "vouch" for such comments, undeading them.
- graeme 9y agoOh, thank you! I will try that next time.
- rdiddly 9y agoWhat'd it say? (just a synopsis?)
- maxerickson 9y agoI vouched for it and it undead: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15111919 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15111919
- f- 9y ago[Author here] The mindset is actually a large component of this guide, and it intentionally delays any discussion of "prepper gear" until it gets through a long laundry list of lifestyle tips and discussing the need to plan ahead, figure out what is likely, what can go wrong, what the decisions points may be, etc. In contrast to most other prepping docs, weapons are literally the last thing discussed, and only in a perfunctory way. That said, I think that your view of emergency preparedness is far more narrow than what I aimed for in the guide. A significant focus of the doc is dealing with small-scale but common adversities, such as recessions / unemployment, house fires, backed-up sewage, and other "boring" but life-altering contingencies. Basically, the stuff that almost everybody will need to face at some point in their lives. I'd wager that for 90%+ of the events that a typical person in the US is likely to experience, heading into the woods to forage on berries and hunt wildebeest is not the way to go.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoI dunno, I re-read the beginning and I didn't see anything about the points I raised. I think your point that overzealous people who as you put it: begin by shopping for ballistic vests and night vision goggles; they would be better served by grabbing a fire extinguisher, some bottled water, and then putting the rest of their money in a rainy-day fund. is right on point, but IMO that just says - hey don't be insane. Literally right now, my good friends are being rescued from a rooftop in Houston. No number of bottles of water in their basement or generators are going to help them. They are lucky in that they have some discretionary funds and Flood insurance, but more likely than not (if history repeats itself) they wont get fully paid out for what they lost. What they should have done is learned when to move or when to stay by: 1. Not buying a house in Houston and then 2. Gotten out well before it was imminent. Small scale common adversities like you are talking about can get critical really quickly. All those preparations, other than just having savings, is just making you slightly more comfortable and buy you a little bit of time so that you can make a bigger plan. Good, but insufficient and gives you a false sense of security. Again, these are things I've seen over and over. Planning for the range of disasters from a month of unemployment and TEOTWAWKI is the same basic mental change, not just a full basement and bank account.
- jfdi 9y ago> The most successful trait I've seen in survivors it's to know when to stay put and when to move. @andrewkemendo, can you say more about this? Is there a framework for making that decision based on situation on the ground, etc?
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoI haven't studied it beyond recognizing that people who I have seen in a bad situation, and then subsequently saw them as one of a few remaining survivors, were either the first out of some place before a shit storm, or found a way to bunker down and wait for help while everyone else got lost/killed/starved.
- agarden 9y agoIsn't that just survivor bias? Those people who survived when most people died were the ones who didn't do what most people did. But most of the time in life, most of the people survive and it is the few who don't.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoHa I think this is one of the few cases where survivorship bias might not be a bias.
- the_prepared 9y agoThere are frameworks for common situations. Too many to list here, but a very common one is being lost while hiking / in the wilderness. People, especially men, will die not because they got lost, but because they moved afterwards when they should've sheltered in place and created signals for rescue. Then on the other hand, if you're in a civil unrest situation outside of your home, moving is better than not.
- grecy 9y agoFor more on the mindset of survival, I highly, highly recommend the book "Deep Survival: Who Lives, Who Dies, and Why" [1] The author explores a bunch of real-life disaster/survival stories and gets into the mindset qualities displayed by the individuals who survive vs. those that don't. Towards the end he lists the 10 major mental attitudes that will greatly contribute to a successful outcome. It is one of my all-time favorite books, I have read it 10+ times. [1] http://amzn.to/2vjgGen http://amzn.to/2vjgGen
- aslkdjaslkdj 9y ago"In preparing for battle I have always found that plans are useless, but planning is indispensable." - Eisenhower The idea being that the process of planning makes you more easily able to react when everything goes to shit. Eg don't treat a plan like a recipe for success.
- JoshMnem 9y agoHere is one place to obtain some mental toughness and survival skills at the same time: https://www.boss-inc.com/ https://www.boss-inc.com/
- naravara 9y agoI can't imagine that a large metro area after a natural disaster like a flood will have much there to scavenge? It would be hard enough to find things that aren't soaked in toxic sludge-water, but the number of other people also trying to scavenge are bound to outstrip whatever meager resources are available.
- bluGill 9y agoA large metro after the flood will have emergency help coming from all over. You just have to live a couple weeks. As all the scavengers outstrip the local supplies aid will come in.
- trapperkeeper74 9y agoRelentlessly resourceful. It's a false dichotomy though to say mindset is the only thing that's important, it's the most important but not a panacea. Also, it's going to suck if there's a massive/gradual increase in prices of food over 10-50 years plus for people whom haven't stockpiled calories, lipids and protein when it was cheap. That's something that can't be fixed without a little preparation: not going crazy with a bunker and a bunch of crap, just getting the major things right. Finally, when the food runs out, if you don't have an AR and a defensible homestead, you're gonna be preyed upon by strangers and/or neighbors because that's just human nature.
- 52-6F-62 9y agoI live in Toronto and I've always said if shit hits the fan, my first stop is probably Robarts Library at U of T. edit: photo -- http://www.blogto.com/upload/2015/04/20150415-Robarts-Side.jpg http://www.blogto.com/upload/2015/04/20150415-Robarts-Side.j... The place is a massive, brutalist compound. And the knowledge it contains would be invaluable! Especially for people like me with limited biological or medical knowledge. The practical resources they knowledge would open up would make a massive difference. That said, I'd probably still carry a proverbial stick. Anyway, top rate insights.
- maxerickson 9y agoJust get a copy of something like https://www.amazon.com/Mayo-Clinic-Family-Health-Book/dp/1603200770 https://www.amazon.com/Mayo-Clinic-Family-Health-Book/dp/160... 1400 pages of small print, plenty enough information relative to the time you would have to reference it in an urgent situation.
- 52-6F-62 9y agoAwesome. Come to think of it, I think my parents may have had a copy. Beyond that, there would be a ton of information on mechanics and ecology that I couldn't possibly keep in my head. Books on mycology, and other resources that would help in foraging would allow long walks through the countryside to be feasible. As long as one had some way to transport a small library of such materials!
- nathancahill 9y agoAlso get a copy of https://www.amazon.com/Where-There-No-Doctor-Handbook/dp/0942364155 https://www.amazon.com/Where-There-No-Doctor-Handbook/dp/094... Slightly more focused on pediatrics, but super useful resource when other literature says "At this point, head to the emergency room or call 911".
- matthewaveryusa 9y agoIt's said that the US military is so good at war because even at times of peace it runs on chaos.
- criddell 9y ago> In reality you need to find or create a small community of survival minded people that can work together successfully over a long period with a variety of skills. Neil Strauss (the Rolling Stone writer) wrote Emergency where he documents his tour through prepper-dom. Slight spoiler here, but he ends up coming to the same conclusion you do in your last sentence. He took CERT (community emergency response team) training and that is what he ultimately found to be most satisfying.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoYes CERT is great, my immediate family are all CERT members and I'd suggest it for anyone.
- fenwick67 9y agoDo you have any more info on 'adventure traveling'? It's hard to find anything online with the thousands of travel agencies and trip booking sites.