3 ms·
This bothers me: >> Giovanni Santostasi, a study coauthor, developed an algorithm that delivers the sound during the rising portion of slow wave oscillations.
by phkahler 9y ago
This bothers me:
>> Giovanni Santostasi, a study coauthor, developed an algorithm that delivers the sound during the rising portion of slow wave oscillations. This stimulation enhances synchronization of the neurons’ activity.
They did not actually measure "synchronization of the neurons". This is just speculation. In psychology they insist that you need to propose a mechanism for change. In this case it may be true, but they state it as fact without any actual evidence.
- vanderZwan 9y agoI suspect this is sloppy editing replacing a "may enhance" where Santostasi said "enhances". That kind of stuff happens all the time when scientists are interviewed.
- phkahler 9y agoMy point is that no mechanism is even required if an effect can be documented. I let go of an object and it falls toward the ground - easy to replicate. I do more tests and find a constant acceleration - easy to replicate for dense objects (not feathers). And so on. For basic stuff I think showing an effect that can be replicated is way way more important than offering any explanation. IMHO even offering a tentative explanation gives people the impression that things are more understood than they really are.