3 ms·
The list of complaints seems to have been removed from the vote issue [1] on his removal 'at the request of several core collaborators who felt that listing the
by tekacs 9y ago
The list of complaints seems to have been removed from the vote issue [1] on his removal 'at the request of several core collaborators who felt that listing the issues was not fair to Rod'.
He lists the issues himself in his response post [2] (see 'Response to the list of complaints'), where he also states 'Please note that I did not ask for this text to be redacted.' (although it's unclear whether he refers to the redaction of certain links in the list as copied in his post, or the whole list on nodejs/TSC#310).
So [1] seems to be the authoritative source on the Node side, [2] the authoritative source on the opposite side.
Disclaimer again, I'm not taking sides, I haven't read everything yet, I'm just gathering links for people to draw their own conclusions.
[1]: https://github.com/nodejs/TSC/issues/310 https://github.com/nodejs/TSC/issues/310
[2]: https://medium.com/@rvagg/the-truth-about-rod-vagg-f063f6a53557 https://medium.com/@rvagg/the-truth-about-rod-vagg-f063f6a53...
- StavrosK 9y agoThanks, I read those after I wrote the comment, and the things he did seem very minor. Of course, I'm only seeing his side of the argument, so I can't form a well-rounded opinion, but I can't see how the original list of complaints is enough justification to vote someone out of a council.