4 ms·
John Oliver's point--which I will note had absolutely nothing to do with the safety of nuclear sites despite this article going off the path to defend them--is
by saurik 9y ago
John Oliver's point--which I will note had absolutely nothing to do with the safety of nuclear sites despite this article going off the path to defend them--is that while we have a strategy to store nuclear waste (with a designated national site for doing so), we haven't actually executed on that plan after many decades. His piece was not "anti-nuclear", and if someone wants to show that his arguments are wrong they also would be flying in the face of the scientists who put together the national plan.
Regardless, this author claims "please talk to a real nuclear scientist" and then provides not a single statement from a nuclear scientist on any topic at all, much less on the topic of "should we execute the national nuclear waste storage plan and how bad is it that we aren't making progress?"... this is essentially "trust this random reporter", and I personally do not think reporters are to be trusted sources with respect to science: that's how we have gotten into so much trouble to begin with :/. To put this another way: this article is, in my mind, even less scientific than John Oliver's skit, so I am flagging it for not being appropriate on this website.
- jsjohnst 9y agoFirst off, I emphatically agree with the top paragraph, but I'm not sure I would so quickly write off this guy's credentials. Not saying his background is unquestionable, but it does seem to deserve some credit. > Dr. James Conca is an expert on energy, nuclear and dirty bombs, a planetary geologist, and a professional speaker.
- jolux 9y agoHe also works for a company in the nuclear industry and frankly that byline is not all that impressive to me. "Professional speaker" is not a qualification, and "expert" is suitably wishy-washy at this point that it's nearly meaningless, especially when one uses it to describe oneself.