4 ms·
I think this is a good start at looking at some of the human factors issues with menus but it doesn't even seem to get out of the "known issues" on to something
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
I think this is a good start at looking at some of the human factors issues with menus but it doesn't even seem to get out of the "known issues" on to something more.
Menus have been an issue for a long time, ever since XDE[1] at least. The original Mac "global menu bar across the top" was one shot at it, Xerox (and XFCE it seems) had the menu popup when ever you hit the right button. Windows of course had the 'start' button which did a 'menu reveal'. But there are other interesting ideas in menus as well. One of my favorites in terms of ingenuity were the pie menus[2]. I saw a demo which I believe was Don Hopkins work and it demonstrated how quickly and accurately you could select things. That speed and accuracy derived from converting menu disambiguation using a bunch of possibly overlapping rectangles, to using only vectors from the current point.
One of the challenges that has added to the problem has been ginormous screens. When menu metaphors are attached to the physical screen boundaries the amount of mouse movement needed is quite large. Of course with touch screens it is compensated for by just moving your finger, but as we've seen on iPads and Surface Pros that can limit menu density due to fat fingers :-)
[1] The Xerox Development Environment - https://web.archive.org/web/20041204132344/http://www.apearson.f2s.com/xde.html https://web.archive.org/web/20041204132344/http://www.apears... (no doubt kens can fire it up on the Alto :-)
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pie_menu#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pie_menu#History
- aidenn0 9y agoPie menus are great for selecting from a small number of options quickly; I'm not sure that they are any better when chained than rectangular menus though.
- pram 9y agoI used a radial menu extension in the early versions of Firefox that I thought was fantastic. I assume they don't have more widespread use because it typically depends on symbol memorization, and people are already used to long lists of things?
- digi_owl 9y agoI suspect i tested the same one, and best i recall it didn't mix well with other extensions that added stuff to the right click menu. Best i can tell, radial works as long as you have a small, fixed set of action that you want to do repeatedly. But once you have a situation where the user can add arbitrary new actions it breaks down because it relies on the actions being sorted and fixed in location. The result, as best i recall, in the Firefox extension case, was that extension added menu entries would dangle of in some "misc" entry at the bottom right of the radial. Effectively turning it into a traditional menu dangling off a radial one...
- int_19h 9y agoIt may be a rather weird test case, but one instance where I've seen radial context menus used really well was Neverwinter Nights (the 2002 Bioware RPG). It uses context menus to provide a variety of actions when applied to objects in inventory and in the world (including the character itself) - e.g. inspect/open/bash/lockpick the chest. Once it gets to spells and magic abilities, you often have to go through many nested levels to pick the right spell and parameters. The beauty of their design was that the same action always had the same position in the radial, regardless of how many actions were there overall, and how many were not available in that context. Thus, picking the right item in a series of cascade radials always took the same path. Eventually, your muscle memory picked it up, and a frequently used action became a mouse gesture, performed without even looking at the menu itself. But for those things that are rare, you still retained the advantage of discoverability that menus offer. Here's an example, with someone showing off the gestures that they remember (it stacks the actions up, so the character continues to perform them even after the player stops providing further input): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uFevVjeawaY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uFevVjeawaY One interesting thing that you might notice is that the subradials actually replace the main radial, instead of the more usual expanding mode. I suppose this is to allow essentially arbitrary nesting level without worrying about screen estate. Every subradial had a "Back" command in the center.
- sfRattan 9y agoIt's interesting to look at how BioWare---back when it was BioWare---used radial menus to great effect in multiple games. In addition to Neverwinter Nights, the radial conversation menus in the original Mass Effect trilogy come to mind. By assigning "Paragon" and "Renegade" dialogue options to standard directions on the wheel, the system made it possible to pick a conversation choice so quickly that the scene would run at a dramatic pace without the awkward pauses in many other games as you scrolled through dialogue choices.