4 ms·
It's not "wasted". The miners wouldn't spend the energy if they weren't getting a good return on their investment. Just because you don't like bitcoin doesn't
by jstanley 9y ago
It's not "wasted". The miners wouldn't spend the energy if they weren't getting a good return on their investment.
Just because you don't like bitcoin doesn't make it a "waste" of energy, any more than mining gold is a "waste" of energy if you don't like gold.
- rainbowmverse 9y agoYou're thinking of waste too narrowly. That power wasn't available for other things, so more had to be produced to cover Bitcoin and the other things, which meant more of all the negatives that come with energy production. Does Bitcoin provide something valuable enough to human civilization to account for that? Could that value have come from a more efficient source? Failing to account for externalities is how we get rapid ecosystem destruction (before even bringing in climate change). Those Bitcoins aren't innocent little bits on drives. They have a cost to the planet they're produced on and the life that inhabits it.
- jstanley 9y agoIf you think you can replace bitcoin with something more efficient, please do so. The millions of people who use bitcoin every day would gladly switch to a cheaper version if it was truly just as good.
- rainbowmverse 9y agoI don't take it as a given that Bitcoin is a good solution to the problem those people solve with it. The best of the bad solutions is still bad, and Bitcoin isn't looking too good by its power consumption. It's okay to stop, really think about a problem, and find a good solution instead of charging ahead with a bad one oblivious to the brick wall ahead.
- jstanley 9y agoWhat do you think is the best way to store+exchange value across borders in a way that can't be censored or reversed by any third party and doesn't require trusting or asking permission from any third party? Personally, I think the answer is bitcoin.
- JuicyJay 9y agoMade an account just to upvote your comment. This is an incredibly powerful point that appears to be completely missed by the majority of threads I'm seeing. Maybe PoS will turn out to be effective and reduce energy costs for cryptocurrencies, but there is absolutely nothing like them. The anonymity of money is valuable for any free and open society, and Bitcoin is currently providing that to anyone willing to create a wallet.
- Nursie 9y agoWho told you bitcoin was anonymous?
- Digiconomist 9y ago"Wasting" energy is required to make PoW work, but if we could achieve the same with PoS (and that seems to be the case since ETH is switching too) then it would really be a waste.
- alkonaut 9y agoIf gold could be found without excessive energy use then it would be a waste to spend a lot of energy digging for it. If there was a good low energy alternative to PoW then it's a waste of energy to use that method of validation. Like incandescent bulbs are a wasteful way of making light when there are more efficient ways.