6 ms·
France electricity is mostly (72%) from nuclear power. Aka the most under-appreciated clean energy that everybody is panicky about and wants to get rid of. Whic
by smsm42 9y ago
France electricity is mostly (72%) from nuclear power. Aka the most under-appreciated clean energy that everybody is panicky about and wants to get rid of. Which means, unless you have a luxury of having tons of hydropower or something, nuclear is probably the best way to lower carbon footprint. Of course, this is also the least discussed way.
- jakobegger 9y agoNuclear power is discussed a lot as a CO2 friendly option. The huge drawback is that we haven‘t found a way to deal with all the radioactive waste yet.
- valuearb 9y agoThat's an incredibly minor problem compared to global warming. I'd solve the more important one first.
- Eupolemos 9y agoIt's minor now. But if it turns out that we'll need an active (as in "needs manpower") care-taking of this waste for several thousands of years, we get into the compounded interests area. Also, there's the immediate (last 50 years) issues such as barrels of waste being treated in silly manners; e.g. thrown into the ocean near the coast and shot to pieces by air-planes if they surface... Politicians and corporations will do anything to save money, if they think they'll get away with it. That makes nuclear waste much more dangerous than it should be. It's not a problem, we'll have clean fusion in 20 years :D /s
- jaxbot 9y agoYou are literally just quoting the most recent John Oliver episode. There's an interesting rebuttal to his episode here that is worth reading: https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2017/08/24/please-john-oliver-please-talk-to-a-real-nuclear-scientist/#55607e9b18f5 https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2017/08/24/please-jo...
- PhasmaFelis 9y ago> But if it turns out that we'll need an active (as in "needs manpower") care-taking of this waste for several thousands of years We don't. Dig a shaft half a mile deep in bedrock in a tectonically stable area, and anything you put there will be safe for the next million years. But that's kind of expensive, so we keep dumping the shit in the ocean or in shallow graves in the backyard.
- smsm42 9y agoThe waste mismanagement is not unique to nuclear. Check out this one: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Love_Canal#Love_Canal_disaster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Love_Canal#Love_Canal_disaster Out of all wastes to be mismanaged, higher radiation would probably be the easiest to detect - simple detectors are widely available commercially. Yes, we need ways to store, or recycle - there are ways to do that too - nuclear waste, but that doesn't seem to be an intractable problem, and I don't think this is the main hindrance to the wider spread of the nuclear energetic. Irrational fears of "radiation" and political issues seem to be more prominent there.
- yongjik 9y ago(1) We have to keep something dangerous deep underground in some remote places, and if something goes wrong, it may leak out and contaminate dozens of kilometers around the spot. Dozens of kilometers. (2) Every coastal towns, cities, estuaries, and natural preserves will be wiped out within a thousand years. Across the globe. Including entire nations. (Well, to be fair, they will cease to be nations long before that.) There's really no comparison. For arguments regarding (2), see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long-term_effects_of_global_warming https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long-term_effects_of_global_wa... > A study in 2015 found that assuming cumulative fossil fuel emissions of 10 000 gigatonnes of carbon, the Antarctic Ice Sheet could melt completely over the following millennia, contributing 58 m to global sea-level rise, and 30 m within the first 1000 years.
- gaius 9y agoYes we have: stick it in a breeder reactor
- simonsarris 9y agoWe never found a way to deal with the radioactive waste that coal plants emit into the air (look it up) or the millions of deaths that coal and petrol/diesel are responsible for, but we still use those. Per Wiki: > According to the World Health Organization in 2011, urban outdoor air pollution, from the burning of fossil fuels and biomass is estimated to cause 1.3 million deaths worldwide per year and indoor air pollution from biomass and fossil fuel burning is estimated to cause approximately 2 million premature deaths.[14] In 2013 a team of researchers estimated the number of premature deaths caused by particulate matter in outdoor air pollution as 2.1 million, occurring annually.[4][5] And see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_accidents#Fatalities https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_accidents#Fatalities Nuclear is safer and better in every way even if you multiplied all the past disasters by ten. There really is no comparison. Where to store some icky stuff isn't really a huge drawback, its a political problem because humans have no sense of scale.
- aluhut 9y ago> We never found a way to deal with the radioactive waste that coal plants emit into the air Sure we did. We close them down where ever it's possible. Just like we should do and do with nuclear power plants. > Nuclear is safer and better in every way even if you multiplied all the past disasters by ten. There really is no comparison. What a brilliant argument you have there. Oh wait. No it's not. You actually did not bring anything up to counter the problem caused by nuclear plants: nuclear waste. Just some juicy whataboutism. > its a political problem because humans have no sense of scale. People have enough sense of scale to realize that the waste will be there forever and while some are safely away from it, others can watch your rusty barrels go to hell and pollute the environment. Funny because John Oliver had a piece about that just last week: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZwY2E0hjGuU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZwY2E0hjGuU What's good about that at all?!
- Kon5ole 9y agoI am one of the "panicky" ones and I want to explain my point of view. When I was a kid, living in the equivalent of Kentucky, a nuclear accident in the equivalent of the Bahamas made it so we couldn't eat wild berries from the woods anymore. Now a middle aged man over 30 years later, sheep from my home area still measure levels of radioactivity too high for human consumption. That's why I feel most options are better than nuclear power, for any purpose except perhaps space probes.
- _ph_ 9y agoHere in Bavaria, every single wild boar shot still has to be checked for radioactivity, quite a few have to be destroyed for too high radiation values. Equally, it is recommended not to eat too many mushrooms from the forest. All of this due to the Chernobyl accident more than 30 years ago.
- smsm42 9y agoI have very hard time believing anything harmful can get from Chernobyl to Bavaria and still be dangerous by now. I think it's just overreacting. There are millions of people living between Chernobyl and Bavaria, including cities such as Kyiv (3 mln people, less than 100km from Chernobyl), and there seems to be no sign of mass morbidity and mortality from any of radiation related causes. Makes it kinda hard to believe there is still danger in 1400km away.
- _ph_ 9y agoNo believing involved, this is just science and using geiger counters. Here is the relevant link: https://www.bfs.de/DE/themen/ion/umwelt/lebensmittel/pilze-wildbret/pilze-wildbret.html https://www.bfs.de/DE/themen/ion/umwelt/lebensmittel/pilze-w... The thing is that there are long living isotopes in the upper soil of the forests. As they are long living, they have not decayed yet enough and are not going to in the next decades. Something does not need to kill 80% of the population to be a significant health risk. With the isotopes relevant in Bavaria, they are only dangerous when eaten. So there is nothing dangerous about living in those regions. However mushrooms tend to aggregate the radioactive particles and so do the wild boar eating from the mushrooms. Not every animal is contaminated, but every single one has to be scanned for radiation, before they can be eaten, and quite a few have to be destroyed every year.
- greglindahl 9y agoLeast discussed? It comes up all of the time on HN! Roughly the same things get said every time, too.
- smsm42 9y agoLeast discussed in places where it matters?
- greglindahl 9y agoWell, these days when I see nuclear power discussed in the popular press, it's usually talking about how it's extremely expensive and also almost caused Toshiba's bankruptcy. Probably not what you had in mind.
- aluhut 9y agoSo you came up with a solution for the waste now? I must have missed that. Please explain.
- secult 9y agoDo you prefer spreading the pollution over the vast area around the thermal power plants? Because that's the current alternative in most of the countries. Nuclear waste is treated securely enough for now in Europe, and future may bring us scientific development to resolve this problem in future.
- aluhut 9y agoYou make it look like coal is the only alternative. Where is this coming from? Trump campaign train? > Nuclear waste is treated securely enough for now in Europe, and future may bring us scientific development to resolve this problem in future. No it's not. We have quite big problems with storage in Germany[1]. Other waste is stored next to the nuclear facilities who created it or on the road to and from La Hague where radioactivity is leaking into water and air[2,3]. [1] https://www.ndr.de/nachrichten/niedersachsen/braunschweig_harz_goettingen/Erhoehte-Radioaktivitaet-Bohrung-in-Asse-gestoppt,asse1446.html https://www.ndr.de/nachrichten/niedersachsen/braunschweig_ha... [2]http://www.taz.de/!5154538/ http://www.taz.de/!5154538/ [3]https://www.greenpeace.de/node/11699 https://www.greenpeace.de/node/11699 Or hey, don't forget Sellafield where 2014 the employees have been asked to stay at home but everything is totally OK. Unfortunately nobody told that to the birds who were drinking contaminated water from open SFPs.
- adrianN 9y agoBreeder reactors use today's waste as fuel, burning up 90% or more and leaving behind short lived isotopes.
- aluhut 9y agoSo they will get rid of all the waste that is currently lying in rusty containers all over the world? Or do we have enough to clean all of the waste that is being generated? Please provide sources since I know some countries who are struggling to find a hole deep enough to make it disappear.
- secult 9y agoNuclear power plants are vaporizing WATER, which is a much stronger greenhouse gas! :)