2 ms·
You left out the quantifiers. ∃ x : X . x can y ⇐ ∃ z : Z . z can y ∧ ∀ z : Z . z : X In English: There are X that can y because there are Z that can y and al
by yorwba 9y ago
You left out the quantifiers.
∃ x : X . x can y ⇐ ∃ z : Z . z can y ∧ ∀ z : Z . z : X
In English: There are X that can y because there are Z that can y and all Z are X. Nothing contradictory there.
While it is not always clear what the intended quantifiers are, it is usually best to choose the interpretation that doesn't make a statement trivially false.