3 ms·
I don't think a Fury, even a hypothetical one that's been modified with modern sensors and weapons, would ever prevail against an F-22. Let's say you put ident
by mikeash 9y ago
I don't think a Fury, even a hypothetical one that's been modified with modern sensors and weapons, would ever prevail against an F-22.
Let's say you put identical missiles on both. Once in range, both fire. The F-22 can then turn around and get back out of range before it's hit. The Fury is essentially motionless, and will be shot down. Repeat ad infinitum.
- ceejayoz 9y agoSure, but you can afford to field 2,700 Furies against that F-22, which will quickly run out of ammo and return to base, while the remaining 2,690 Furies are running around machine gunning your ground troops. (Sure, this is a bit contrived... but even 100-to-1 probably still makes sense. Iran's already taking this sort of low-cost approach with small speedboats intended to go up against US aircraft carriers.)
- dunmalg 9y ago>you can afford to field 2,700 Furies against that F-22 You can't just divide the cost of a Fury into the cost of an F-22 and assume that's even remotely reasonable as a fieldable proportion. The limiting factor isn't the cost of building the planes, it's the logistics of coming up with with enough fuel, pilots, maintenance, and ground facilities to keep them flying. There's nobody who couldn't afford something better that could afford to field maybe 3:1 vs the F-22. The salesman for Burt Rutan's little gun-armed midget ARES fighter/attack plane liked to tell people to "imagine how the Falklands War would have been different" if the British Harriers had been faced with waves of hundreds of ARES planes.... completely failing to address the fact that Argentina couldn't possibly train enough qualified pilots to sit in those hundreds of cockpits.
- ceejayoz 9y agoHence my statement that it's a bit of a contrived example. Fuel's relatively cheap for a prop plane, one pilot would manage more than one drone aircraft at once, maintenance is dramatically easier and cheaper on a prop plane, etc.
- mikeash 9y agoThe F-22 can go out, shoot a bunch down, return, go out again, shoot a bunch more down, and keep on going. With a more realistic ratio, it looks pretty bad for the Furies.
- geezerjay 9y ago> The F-22 can then turn around and get back out of range before it's hit. The Fury Why are you assuming that a hypothetical 1-on-1 scenario is the only feasible scenario? If an operator can man half a dozen of fury squadrons for the same cost that an operator is able to afford a single F22, why would you assume that they would put up a single fury to counter a F22? And let's assume that a wave of furys managed to down a F22. Now what? Will the operator of the F22 spend an additional $180M to churn out a single unit? Because for the same cost, the opponent can churn out 100-fold units. Is this sustainable?
- mikeash 9y agoI don't think it really assumes 1-on-1. "And let's assume that a wave of furys managed to down a F22." Let's not. I don't see how that could happen. No quantity of Furies would be able to shoot one down. The F-22 will just keep picking them off until it runs out of ammo or targets. If the former, it'll return to base, rearm, and keep going.