3 ms·
Not to disagree with your main point that there's a lot of tight coupling ... but planes are regularly stretched[1][2] so it seems like it's still a lot simpler
by rwmj 9y ago
Not to disagree with your main point that there's a lot of tight coupling ... but planes are regularly stretched[1][2] so it seems like it's still a lot simpler than designing a whole new plane from scratch. Even new designs are really evolutions of old planes.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airbus_A340#Variants https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airbus_A340#Variants
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_747#Variants https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_747#Variants
- dunmalg 9y agoProbably a better example from the opposite end of the spectrum would be the design changes between the F/A-18C/D and the F/A-18E/F. The initial plans were to stretch the C/D model to add fuel and improve the abysmal range, but this increased weight which required larger wings which required all sorts of major design changes. In the end, the E/F ended up with only 40% parts commonality, and was now a medium weigh fighter like the F-15, rather than the cheap light fighter like the F-16 it began life as. Engineers I know who worked on the E/F design have told me it would arguably have been cheaper to design a new plane from scratch, but the Navy was so afraid of another failed project that they were only able to sell it to the Navy as an "upgrade" of a plane design they already had. Dubious in an engineering sense, but absolute genius in marketing.
- geezerjay 9y ago> but planes are regularly stretched[1][2] One of the main design requirements for those plane models was, right from the start, to support multiple variants by adopting a modular design. Yet, they are still very tightly coupled. In fact, IIRC the Airbus A340 project is widely known for having experienced a billion-euro delay due to production problems caused by CAD software issues. In short, if my memory doesn't fail me, some design teams used Catia V4 while others migrated to Catia V5, whose CAD engine was rewritten from scratch. Consequently, some slight differences in how the different versions handled geometry definitions resulted in some electric cables designed by some engineering teams to be incompatible with the structural layout designed by other engineering teams. We're talking about differences in centimeters in a plane with a wingspan with around 56m.