4 ms·
Good points. > derive algorithms mathematically Of course, most of what computers do is not algorithms (or even "computing"). > can be awful for projects req
by mpweiher 9y ago
Good points.
> derive algorithms mathematically
Of course, most of what computers do is not algorithms (or even "computing").
> can be awful for projects requiring maintenance
Or wonderful, see Smalltalk. Not that it is perfect and can't be improved, but it sure has been successfully maintained over a long period of time.
- mbrock 9y agoCan you expand on what is meant by algorithms and computing, and what you mean that computers mostly do instead?
- vanderZwan 9y agoThe skill of programming is really about translating tasks that are semantically meaningful to humans (ie making a user friendly online booking site for a hotel) into "meaningless" instructions that can be computed by a turing complete machine. That's very different from, say, deriving a faster partition algorithm by using half-swaps instead of full swaps (as demonstrated by Andrei Alexandrescu last year).
- Karrot_Kream 9y agoBut aren't all forms of engineering about translating semantically meaningful tasks into {problem-domain}? What makes software different?
- mcguire 9y ago"...into "meaningless" instructions that can be computed by a turing complete machine." Pssst! Hey, buddy, that's what an algorithm is.
- mpweiher 9y agoComputers today mostly (a) communicate and (b) store/retrieve data. Both at the macro level, what they are used for, but also at the micro level. Actual computation tends to be incidental.
- mbrock 9y agoYet you can't just tell the computer to communicate or do I/O -- it's all controlled by decisions, and making those decisions is basically what I call computation.
- mpweiher 9y agoYep...incidental computation. Also: "primarily"/"mostly". Not all/none.
- mbrock 9y agoHmm, maybe a lot of computation is outsourced to server farms, but "clients" still do a lot of it: image processing, codecs, scheduling, layout, speech recognition, etc etc.
- mpweiher 9y agoSo what are codecs for? Communication, storage. What is speech recognition for? Communication. etc. I think you keep arguing against something I never said, which is that computers do no computing whatsoever.