12 ms·
It depends on how you protest and who does the protesting. The lame-ass protests you see happening in most of the United States are ineffectual because they don
by paganel 9y ago
It depends on how you protest and who does the protesting. The lame-ass protests you see happening in most of the United States are ineffectual because they don't threaten those in power, because they're either holiday-looking marches or they're staged by students/young people, who are easy to ignore.
The only way you can change something by protesting is by projecting power. You do that either by the way you do the protesting, i.e. by actively engaging the police forces in trying to reach the seats of power (Parliament, Government's buildings) or by taking up in the streets the people who have the most power come election day, i.e. lots and lots of middle class people.
Movements like BLM are ineffectual when protesting because they do neither of the 2 things I mentioned above: they don't actively engage the powers in Washington and they are not joined by lots and lots of middle class people. As such, they'll remain ineffectual as long as nothing changes.
Source: me, a guy living in Eastern Europe who has grown-up by watching protests toppling Governments and who has actively joined those kind of protests once I grew up.
- puranjay 9y agoProtests are only effective if they affect economic structures. One of the most effective protests in Indian history was the Gandhi-led boycott of British-made goods. This directly impacted British economic structures. A handful of people blocking a highway for a few hours isn't going to impact anything much.
- rdiddly 9y agoYeah ironically it only tends to impact people who are just as powerless as the protesters.
- ismail-s 9y agoBLM entered the social conscience of plenty of people, and managed to influence discussions in the media, even in some countries outside the US. That in itself is a pretty strong form of power.
- jononor 9y agoAwareness and media attention has potential for power, but unless one is able to follow through and use this to gain something tangible it is not worth much. There is also a huge difference between media being willing to cover the conflict, and media willingly amplifying your message. In the former the power stays in the hands of the media (and the people it usually serves), only in the latter I would say that one has something that can be an effective power. More a general comment, I don't know how BLM does wrt to media coverage.
- maxerickson 9y agoBlack Lives Matter gets little media coverage, with a lot of what they do get being demonization from right wing outfits. I saw a comment here not long ago that managed to peel off the vehicle murderer in Charlottesville from the white supremacist organizers that praised him and at the same time directly blamed BLM for police killings that many leaders in the movement have condemned. I imagine media coverage contributes to such mental acrobatics.
- darepublic 9y agoIn Toronto BLM hijacked the gay pride parade and prevented police participation in the parade. The founder of BLM in Toronto has called whites subhuman.. but BLM still has apologetic articles written in its defense by the left wing media. Defending such a useless harmful and racist organization is a far worse mental acrobatic
- _delirium 9y agoIt's hardly only BLM who doesn't want police in pride parades. The phenomenon of gay-pride marches started on June 28, 1970, to commemorate the one-year anniversary of an NYPD raid on a gay bar in New York, and the movement has as a result been very anti-cop since the beginning. It's only in recent years, as corporate Democrats and other politicians of that kind have found it fashionable to join the movement, that anyone would dream of inviting cops to a pride parade in the first place. Unsurprisingly, not everyone is on board with the change.
- abhi3 9y ago> The only way you can change something by protesting is by projecting power. You do that either by the way you do the protesting, i.e. by actively engaging the police forces in trying to reach the seats of power (Parliament, Government's buildings) >Movements like BLM are ineffectual when protesting because they do neither Can you imagine the tone of public discourse if it even appeared that BLM was trying to overwhelm the seat of governance? I mean people scream 'thug' and call in the National Guard at the sight of African-Americans breaking a supermarket window what do you think they'll do if it appears they might overthrow a government (even a local one)?
- belorn 9y agoI am currently giving a other interpretation of paganel comment that "projecting power" don't mean violence, but rather to carry voter support. Riots and revolutions have shown historically to be very effective at: getting people killed, at decreasing voter support, giving the opposing side more power, and be successful at toppling power. In more instable regions where such events happen in regular waves, the ability of violence to cause lasting change is minimal to none unless you are willing to commit genocide.
- cisanti 9y agoThat's the point, looting doesn't solve anything. If for an example, BLM would convince all the nurses to halt their job, all the firemen -- that would make a difference. But by the look of it, BLM does not have the support of the average working class person. Maybe I'm wrong, I'm not from the United States. The police killings are rare, especially when it comes to killing black people and the topic is only political.
- evolve2017 9y agoI find this very curious - why do you think this movement came to attention if the killings are rare? Also, your comment implies that there's an acceptable number of police killings of unarmed/fleeing suspects - what would you say that number is in your country?
- trapperkeeper74 9y agoVirtue signaling often isn't about changing the world, it's a competing brand of mob populism seeking oppression olympics brownie points. Instead, folks gotta call, email and snail mail their reps and protest to their staffers focused, loudly and often... unless they choose to get involved and attempt to offer a viable alternative to incompetence and/or corruption as a career. Blocking an intersection for 30 seconds to be arrested or protesting in the middle of nowhere does f-all.
- will_brown 9y agoWell the article mentions one of my favorite protests, the Montgomery bus protests/boycott, that was ultimately started by Rosa Parks, history may remember her as some grand civil rights leader, but that wasn't her intent she was just a tired black woman going home from work who refused to give up her seat to a white person. That was a successful protest/boycott without a bunch of middle class people or engaging Washington. The majority of the article is about the Vietnam War, but do a search and you won't find either Muhammad Ali or even the word "draft". Muhammad Ali was an outspoken, black, Muslim who refused the draft, again history might pretend he had the love and support of the people, but he didn't at least at the time. The War still had the full support of the American people, and Ali was persecuted, striped of his championship title/livelihood, labeled Anti-American in the media, he was also prosecuted by the Government, and convicted of draft dodging and sentenced to 5 years of prison. But he continued to fight, the Country began shifting its attitude about the War and the draft, and Ali prevailed in the Courts. Obviously Ali wasn't alone, just look at some of the most famous 1st Amendment cases at the time. The Government prosecuting a guy for wearing a jacket that read "Fuck the Draft" in a Courtroom trying to chill his speech, eventually the Supreme Court agreed that was protected speech. Or the Government prosecuting protesters for burning their draft cards, ultimately they lost and the Supreme Court ruled burning draft cards is not protected speech. All these anti-war protests were done majorly by students, granted to your point their message and goal was much clearer than protests of today. Never mind the individual wins and loses, they were done by students, not middle class, and still they won overall because there hasn't been a draft in the US since, because its become politically untenable. Students, racial minorities, religious minorities...not the middle class.
- dTal 9y ago>history may remember her as some grand civil rights leader, but that wasn't her intent she was just a tired black woman going home from work who refused to give up her seat to a white person. Such is the popular image, but it is incorrect. She was the secretary of her local NAACP chapter, and she certainly was making a stand for civil rights. From her autobiography: "People always say that I didn't give up my seat because I was tired, but that isn't true. I was not tired physically, or no more tired than I usually was at the end of a working day. I was not old, although some people have an image of me as being old then. I was forty-two. No, the only tired I was, was tired of giving in."
- blubb-fish 9y ago> The lame-ass protests Please, give me an example when ever in history a or a series of not-lame-ass protests did change something. G20 in Hamburg was a good example of several not-lame-ass protests which didn't lead to anything beyond violence and destruction. Absolutely nothing changed or started to change because of them.
- Cozumel 9y agoA protest by its very definition is 'lame ass'. When you protest you're accepting the status quo, that's why they're allowed even in places like Turkey and China. They're a steam valve for people to feel they're doing something then they go back to their television and Big Macs. For a protest to achieve something it has to have a goal, and the goal is always 'protesting', that doesn't change anything. If you want to overthrow the Government then go shoot your local senator[0], taking the kids and waving hand made protest signs at the local park isn't going to do sh*t. [0] It's an example. I'm in no way advocating anyone actually do this!
- rdiddly 9y agoYou're getting downvoted but you've hit on something: Most of these protest movements are or aim to be nonviolent, whereas the power of the state is always ultimately projected via violence. For a protest or movement to have real impact, it has to either use violence itself (projecting political power directly), or it has to prepare for a sustained nonviolent absorption/withstanding of state violence (to get political power on its side). Either way you need a lot more determination, organization, sustained effort, and friends than it takes to organize a flash mob.
- sunir 9y agoIt is about who is protesting. I will give MLK and Gandhi.
- darepublic 9y agoMany of these protests don't effect change because their cause is not worthy. They have no coherent message nor righteous cause as in mlk and gandhi.
- vixen99 9y agoSo how many people should be engaged in protest to topple a government recently elected by democratic vote? Presumably you think that at a certain state a protest trumps a democratic election?
- thrownblown 9y agoEnough to convince the military to execute a coup de tat.
- soVeryTired 9y agoThat's a little extreme, don't you think? How about a nice, quiet impeachment first?
- thrownblown 9y agoNot if you're Venezuelan.
- Shivetya 9y agomovements like BLM and OWS were ineffective because they were manufactured by political action groups not to improve the lives of people but to demonize but to distract from the fact that government itself was the problem. So instead on allowing the focus to be about mismanagement at levels from city, state, to federal, the politically adept turned the focus to divide people based on economic, gender, or racial lines. It is classic American politics, hence why the groups never gained traction because they weren't from the ground up. It took over a decade for the Republican party to stomp on and co-opt the tea party and the outrage at the time when it surfaced was because it was not under control of either party. American's protest problem is simple, life is too easy to have anything generate enough interest for people to assemble about other than bad government and the political parties have figured out how to effectively redirect that ire.
- featherverse 9y ago> because they don't threaten those in power, Yeah okay you try threatening people in power and see how far that gets you. They will show up at your house with machine guns, murder your entire family, and then they'll lie about what happened to the neighbors. "Drug bust gone wrong" or something. If you're a person who exercises your 2nd amendment rights they'll say you had a "cache of weapons". Remember WACO? That's what they do to people who threaten those in power. The neighbors will believe whatever they're told, for 2 reasons. They don't want to believe that life is a nightmare, or they are already terrified for their lives and want to go on clinging to whatever table scraps they're currently feeding on. This stuff has been going on for many many years. "They will give you ALL the tools you need to destroy yourself." - Afeni Shakur
- krapp 9y ago> If you're a person who exercises your 2nd amendment rights they'll say you had a "cache of weapons". Remember WACO? That's what they do to people who threaten those in power. But... the Branch Davidians did have a cache of weapons.
- featherverse 9y ago> But... the Branch Davidians did have a cache of weapons. Which is a constitutionally protected inalienable right given to all citizens of The United States. There is no limitation to how many firearms a U.S. citizen can own. There are many people who own hundreds of rifles and handguns. Any other commodity and we'd call it a "collection" but when it's firearms suddenly it's a "cache of weapons". What matters, what you seemed to miss, is the way they describe the situation. They call it a "cache of weapons" on TV because that sounds like terrorism. When it's only American citizens exercising their rights. They do that to manipulate ignorant people. They don't want you to ask questions when they murder a house full of people. Which they do a whole lot. WACO was unusual, being a big media circus, but they're actually really efficient at this murder business and it happens pretty frequently.
- pdimitar 9y agoAs another Eastern European, you beat me to it. Here in my country we even had politicians caught on tape laughing and joking: "What are they gonna do, kill us? They can't do shit, they can only distract themselves from their miserable life...<pause and laughter>...and that's the only reason we don't bomb the protests with tear gas, so these peasants can feel better about themselves that they are actually changing something". Then the whole table full of politicians proceeds to laugh even more. ...You know what? They are 100% correct. Protests amount to nothing. If you don't hit the politicians where it hurts -- their funding and their political power -- then they'll never change anything. That's just how human beings in power always worked, and whoever disagrees with that is blissfully deluded.
- mamon 9y agoIsn't the issue here that whatever government does there still will be someone protesting against it? You know, watching the news and seeing 100k people protesting looks impressive, until you realize that you live in a country of 350M citizens and that 100k protesters is just 0.029% of total population. Add social media to the equation and it is entirely possible to organize flash mob of 100k of Game of Thrones fans demanding "EPIC BOATSEX". So, as a politician you learn very early in your career to ignore all protests, simply because someone is always protesting against something. You wouldn't get much done if you spent most of your time talking to protesters.
- virgilp 9y agoComing from another guy living in Easter Europe (Romania)... one of the things that seemed to me very wrong about some of the recent US protests was the imbalance between participation and motivation/demands. You get millions on streets to protest on the day Trump took office, to ask for.... WHAT? The guy is democratically-elected. He made no huge mistake at that point. Apparently they were "supporting women" or "anti-discrimination" or something. I get it, you don't like him - but this was just wasted effort. No, it was worse than wasted effort - it discredited the idea that millions on the people on the streets would mean something. It would be one thing if millions came out after the announcement of the muslim ban, to protest against THAT. You don't protest against a person, that is ineffective - you protest against policy changes. If you tell someone "I will never vote YOU"... well, ok, what can he do? Nothing. if you say, "I will never vote those who support this policy!", then politicians actually have a choice to back off