4 ms·
There's a lot wrong with the British housing market. In fact, almost every aspect of it from provision, social housing, prices, renting, taxation, to the actua
by rwmj 9y ago
There's a lot wrong with the British housing market. In fact, almost every aspect of it from provision, social housing, prices, renting, taxation, to the actual process of buying and selling — is demonstrably broken.
But ... the Grenfell Tower fire was a specific failure of building and fire regulations, and it could still have happened even if the housing market was working and councils had been building housing for the poor. The cladding was installed for environmental reasons — it reduces heat loss so you need less energy to heat the building. Now we learn that this sort of cladding is much more dangerous than was generally understood, we replace the stuff on other buildings, and move on. This is mostly orthogonal to fixing the housing market or "neoliberalism".
- fennecfoxen 9y agoYeah, it's a pretty terrible article that just plays up blaming "NEOLIBERALISM UNCHAINED" and Capitalism for wrecking what they feel would be the just and righteous state of the UK housing market. This may or may not be all well and good, but there is only the most tenuous of connections to the actual policies that are connected to the fire, specifically: The richest borough spent money fighting global warming through insulation, reducing their energy bills, and making the poor people's housing look good in the process (but without paying sufficient attention to its fire safety rating). THE MONSTERS. CAPITALISM KILLS. (Play up the "making it look good!!" and the "not paying sufficient attention to safety" angles, whilst totally ignoring the use of this material in other places, and general UK-wide building standards which just shrug off the idea of sprinklers.)
- gadders 9y agoNot to mention the fact that although Kensington and Chelsea council has been Conservative since forever, the same cladding was also found on blocks in Labour council areas. Sadly, a lot of the narrative around the disaster and the resultant protests have been pushed by people like the Socialist Workers Party and their ilk.
- notahacker 9y agoYup. Reading the article, one would think the idea of using lower cost materials on a construction project was a cunning idea conceived by Margaret Thatcher in 1979. It isn't, people substitute cheaper materials on their own very expensive properties all the time, and if councils are really preoccupied with saving money over all else they wouldn't have spent £9m on refurbishing Grenfell in the first place. (If you've ever lived in a comparable building, you'll understand why fitting insulating cladding was thought to be a good idea...) There are serious questions to be asked about an architectural design which apparently involved flammable lining products in close proximity, a chimney of air and no firegapping between stories should or could have been identified as a fire hazard, there are questions about how it was installed, and questions about whether the council's poor communications with the residents over fire safety contributed to fewer evacuations (one of their big concerns was apparently concerns over a gas pipe in the stairwell which appears to be one of the few things that didn't go seriously wrong). And there are wider questions about whether standard instructions to stay put are appropriate for the building are appropriate and whether regulations ought to be changed to require mineral wool insulation and/or sprinklers on tall buildings in future. It's also not a bad time to raise questions about cutting firemen numbers in London even though it isn't thought that lack of manpower to tackle the blaze was a problem. But crudely reducing it to a "bad neoliberals hate poor people" to score opportunistic political points actually works against learning those lessons. Poor implementation Grenfell's refurbishment programme is no more a scathing indictment of "neoliberalism" than Ronan Point's collapse was a scathing indictment of the desire of the government to take the lead in housebuilding following WWII. The construction industry did learn from that one. (Ironically, to the extent that "neoliberalism", or Thatcherite housing policy, was particularly relevant to this tower block, it was in having the effect of passing some of the leases into the hands of relatively wealthy private owners who had every interest in the building surviving to make a fortune on selling the flats in a few years' time)
- DanBC 9y agoThe neoliberalism is point refers to all the people in the Conservative party talking about a "bonfire of red tape" and getting rid of regulation. https://twitter.com/sghage01/status/901148211322269696 https://twitter.com/sghage01/status/901148211322269696 They liberalised -weakened- fire regulation; they defunded social housing; they defunded local councils, and people died as a result.
- chx 9y ago> The now infamous cladding, white and grey polyethylene panels which were already banned in the Germany and America, were chosen instead of the fire-resistant alternative
- rwmj 9y agoIn two countries, but presumably not in the whole of the rest of the world. Actually the situation is more complex than that because the EU had introduced uniform regulations but because Germany had its regulations before that, they were allowed to keep their stricter rules [source in this article: http://eureferendum.com/blogview.aspx?blogno=86512 http://eureferendum.com/blogview.aspx?blogno=86512].
- anon1385 9y ago> the Grenfell Tower fire was a specific failure of building and fire regulations >This is independent of fixing the housing market or "neoliberalism". Removing/relaxing building and fire regulations is neoliberalism.
- rwmj 9y agoIt was caused by stricter environmental rules introduced across the EU. Germany's fire regulations pre-dated these so they were allowed to keep their stricter fire regulations. So there's a problem here, but it's not "neoliberalism" (whatever that word even means). See this article which goes into the full details (and it's very complex): http://eureferendum.com/blogview.aspx?blogno=86512 http://eureferendum.com/blogview.aspx?blogno=86512
- lozenge 9y agoThere are options that meet the environmental requirements and are fire resistant. They just cost a little more.
- anon1385 9y agoIf you don't know what neoliberalism is then how were you so confidently able to claim that it wasn't to blame?
- StephenMelon 9y agoHave you examined your cognitive biases recently? It seems like you may stuck in a bit of a “deregulated free-market capitalism good, EU bad” loop that is preventing new information reaching you. The author’s point seems to be if you assess the cost of everything and the value of nothing, the market will price poor, unskilled workers who don’t have the finance to sue as disposable in the grand scheme of things. No-one actually verbalised “if we get this wrong, it won’t matter, because they’re poor” but that’s the dynamic that has been set up nationally and globally. The EU energy efficiency regulations are aimed at protecting the global environment, not individuals. The health and safety legislation is supposed to protect individuals. Are you suggesting that the buildings would not have been renovated if not for EU regulations? That seems extremely disingenuous.
- mjw1007 9y agoThere are regulations about specific materials and installation practices, but there is no rule that if builders follow those regulations they have discharged their responsibility. They have an independent responsibilty to make sure the building is safe. In this case, as I understand it using the flammable cladding wasn't explicitly prohibited; it was effectively on a "use only if you have independently proved the way you're using it is safe" list. So in this case I don't think there was a specific failure of regulations. I think it was a failure on the part of the builders, along with something of a general understanding that "red tape" is something to be ignored.
- anon1385 9y ago>They have an independent responsibilty to make sure the building is safe. As far as I understand it that's only true since 2005: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_Reform_(Fire_Safety)_Order_2005 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_Reform_(Fire_Safety...
- TheOtherHobbes 9y agoIt's depressing to see commenters with no understanding of what actually happened at Grenfell. Here is what actually happened: the cladding used does not meet UK safety standards, and there were warnings from experts and residents that the cladding was not safe to use. The council decided to ignore the warnings, because cheap and dangerous cladding saved around £300,000 on a £9m refurb that residents argued wasn't needed in the first place and which they didn't particularly benefit from. It certainly wasn't an energy saving measure. The right-wing Tory council is not poor[1]. It has cash reserves of £200m, and gave council tax payers a £100 refund around the time of the refurb. So yes - this is absolutely about right-wing greed, and right-wing disdain for the relatively poor. [1] Although it's going to be a lot poorer once this is settled.
- rwmj 9y ago> It certainly wasn't an energy saving measure. This is factually wrong. If you read the original planning application[1] you'll see a whole section about climate change and energy efficiency (page 10 for the hard of reading). There's a second document[2] which goes into the energy efficiency in a lot more detail. Section 2.1 of the second document says that cladding was specifically added for energy efficiency reasons. [1] https://www.scribd.com/document/351448748/Grenfell-Tower-Planning-Application https://www.scribd.com/document/351448748/Grenfell-Tower-Pla... [2] https://www.scribd.com/document/351448758/Grenfell-Tower-Sustainability-and-Energy-Statement https://www.scribd.com/document/351448758/Grenfell-Tower-Sus...
- Stranger43 9y agoIt's always a specific failure if the current broken system depends on it if you ask those that thinks they benefit from the broken system. The real trick here is to go a bit deeper and find out if this was just an "act of god" of if there was some kind of systematic policy that led to successive councils ignoring clear evidence of potential problems with one of their properties. And when it comes to social housing there is very systematic problem of willfull blindness when it comes to problems that might require investment to infrastructure used by people that are not paying a lot in taxes. The problems might be worse in the UK but are not all that unique as even Scandinavia and Germany have unsolved problems with some of their public housing estates. In a lot of ways the problem is that a lot of those building aren’t actually worth maintaining but cannot be replaced due to a preference for not allowing new social housing to be build.