6 ms·
"Let me flash back to November 15th 1969, Washington DC and the Moratorium for Peace in Vietnam. This was probably the single biggest anti-war demonstration of
by pmoriarty 9y ago
"Let me flash back to November 15th 1969, Washington DC and the Moratorium for Peace in Vietnam. This was probably the single biggest anti-war demonstration of the era, estimated at half a million by some and twice that by others...
"My scepticism about the demonstration’s effect seemed warranted when five months later, at the end of April, 1970, the US extended the war into Cambodia. In the protests that followed six students, four at Kent State in Ohio and two at Jackson State in Mississippi, were shot dead. The upshot was the biggest student strike in US history: more than 4 million students walking out of classes in universities, colleges and high schools across the country. Yet still the war did not end. Two and a half more years would pass before the peace treaty was signed in Paris in January 1973. By this time there were millions upon millions dead, disabled, bereaved, traumatised. Nonetheless, the movement against the Vietnam war is widely considered the most "successful" anti-war movement of modern times, against which more recent movements have measured their "failure".
"Many years later, I learned that the Moratorium demonstration was, in fact, anything but ineffectual. In July 1969, Nixon and Kissinger had delivered an ultimatum to the Vietnamese: if they did not accept US terms for a ceasefire by November 1st, "we will be compelled – with great reluctance – to take measures of the greatest consequences." The US government was threatening and indeed actively planning a nuclear strike against North Vietnam. In his Memoirs, Nixon admitted that the key factor in the decision not to proceed with the nuclear option was that "after all the protests and the Moratorium, American public opinion would be seriously divided by any military escalation of the war." What would have been the world’s second nuclear war was averted by our action, though we couldn’t have known it at the time..."
http://www.socialsciencecollective.org/success-failure-political-myths/ http://www.socialsciencecollective.org/success-failure-polit...
- goialoq 9y agoSo protestors caused USA to lose the war, as Nixon complained?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dguaraglia 9y agoSo, let me get this straight: you'd rather have nuclear weapons become a normal weapon of war, as opposed to a deterrent, than have people complain about a war? Wow.
- MichaelGG 9y agoCertainly a nuclear strike would have been a quicker ending with less casualties, no?
- eeZah7Ux 9y agoThis "quicker ending" narrative justifies unlimited escalation of violence.
- guildwriter 9y agoIf China and the USSR didn't have a vested interest in the outcome of the Vietnam War? Perhaps. If it didn't cause the NVA to completely dissipate into full on guerrilla warfare? Sure.
- georgebarnett 9y agoPerhaps initially, however their use would be normalised and so ultimately casualties would likely be higher as more were used. Also radiation pollution would be the gift that keeps killing.
- ChristianGeek 9y agoHe's saying exactly the same thing that was, and still is, used in defense of Hiroshima and Nagasaki; that the human loss in ending the war quickly was far less than it would have been in continuing it. He is not saying anything about using them as normal weapons of war. Whether or not you consider this a reasonable argument is up to you.
- will_brown 9y ago>that the human loss in ending the war quickly was far less than it would have been in continuing it. Exactly, Firebombings in Japan resulted in about twice as many human casualties than with Little Man and Fat Boy combined. Before the 1st bomb the United States called for the unconditional surrender or "face prompt and utter destruction". Japan's response was their intent to fight on to the bitter end. After the first bomb Truman called for Japan's surrender, or "expect a rain of ruin from the air, the like of which has never been seen on this earth." To no avail, and after the second bomb was detonated Emperor Hirohito called for accepting the terms of the allies, but even the surrender, in hindsight, was probably lucky as there was a failed coup, which if successful would have lead to the continued and ongoing armed conflict.
- guildwriter 9y agoIn a sense yes actually. Take the Tet Offensive for example. From a purely military perspective it was a total disaster for the NVA. Casualties were incredibly in the favor of the SV and US forces for a fairly small amount of territory gained. What the NVA realized correctly though was the effect that the Tet Offensive would have on an already questioning American public. The media impact of the Tet Offensive along with the request for another 200k recruits did a major blow to the American public who really began to lose faith with the war. The NVA understood that they didn't have to beat the US Army, they just had to make the American public unwilling to fight. Note that this isn't an argument that the War was worth fighting or not. Simply that protesters can and do have an effect on how the enemy fights and can assist the enemy intentionally or unintentionally. War in the modern era is no longer just calculated in how it affects the battlefield at hand, but also the media landscape. That was one of the major lessons of the Vietnam War.
- bb611 9y agoThe general consensus is that the US could not win the war in Vietnam, because the vast majority of South Vietnamese were not on board: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/08/22/opinion/vietnam-was-unwinnable.html?mcubz=0 https://www.nytimes.com/2017/08/22/opinion/vietnam-was-unwin... I would agree that the major lesson the US military learned was "manage public opinion", but that wasn't the actual lesson on offer, which was that you can't win a country without winning over its people, and that was learned all over again in Iraq between 2003-2008.
- guildwriter 9y agoYour article doesn't support your claim: > "Despite its ally’s fundamental weakness, the United States might possibly still have won, of course, had it been willing to fully mobilize its own national power. But that would have required raising taxes, calling up the Reserves and other sacrifices that President Lyndon Johnson shrank from asking the American people to make." ... "But Johnson was the most astute politician to sit in the White House during the 20th century, and he knew that he faced a paradox. As long as the war in Vietnam didn’t demand too much of them and they believed that victory was just around the corner, most Americans would support it. But if Johnson admitted publicly that South Vietnam could not survive without a full commitment by the United States, he knew that support would crumble." Yes the SV government was autocratic, corrupt, incompetent, and this made it harder for the SV to get on board. But saying that's the majority reason is frankly incorrect. The full power of the US military would have been enough to guarantee victory or stalemate. Further counterpoint. See the Korean War. Deeply unpopular at home. Most people didn't even know where Korea even was or fully understand why we were fighting. It was one of the major reasons why Truman's approval numbers were so low. S. Korean government at the time under Rhee was corrupt as all hell and undemocratic. In fact most of S Korea's history is undemocratic. S Korean Army units a total disaster for the most part. Yet S Korea still stands independent largely because we never faltered in giving them the military support they needed. Also Iraq in 2003-2008 was less about winning over the people of Iraq and a lot more to do with other issues such as the refusal to utilize former Ba'ath party members and generals in the formation of the new government. Arguably the worst screw up was the unilateral exit of the US from Iraq under Obama which lead to the chaos we have to deal with now.
- refurb 9y agoNuclear weapons were never seriously considered for use in Vietnam either during the French War or American war. Saying your actions prevented something isn't that compelling if it was never likely in the first place.
- aaron-lebo 9y agoIt sounds absurd because Nixon was paranoid but he wasn't completely stupid. There would be no benefit to nuking North Vietnam. You'd enrage already pissed off citizenry, turn the world against you, maybe bring the Soviet Union into the war, and all for what, nuking Hanoi when the real problem was guerrilla warfare? It makes no sense. we will be compelled – with great reluctance – to take measures of the greatest consequences It seems like the author is interpreting this as "nuclear weapons", but it could very easily be political posturing, or an increase in conventional conflict. Disappointing if it's exaggerated to make the author look better, and to see that statement made and accepted so uncritically. Just googling, can't find any good sources suggesting nukes were seriously considered (as you said). Is there something more concrete than a favorable interpretation of that quote? edit: this seems to be Duck Hook https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duck_Hook https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duck_Hook
- xerophyte12932 9y agoIs this real? In his Memoirs, Nixon admitted that the key factor in the decision not to proceed with the nuclear option was that "after all the protests and the Moratorium, American public opinion would be seriously divided by any military escalation of the war." Then that is concrete proof of nuclear considerations
- aaron-lebo 9y agoWhat do you mean is it real? Of course skepticism is real as it should be for all claims about history. The author tells us what Nixon is admitting and to do so uses an out of context quote which at best suggests escalation. That's a low standard for concrete proof. Actually having pulled up that section of the memoirs, "escalation" is used repeatedly. The nuclear option is never even mentioned (though whether Nixon avoids mentioning this is something else entirely). Furthermore, the author doesn't just assert that Nixon considered nuclear weapons, they assert they are directly responsible for avoiding a nuclear war. Maybe a bit too self-congratulatory and subjective: What would have been the world’s second nuclear war was averted by our action, though we couldn’t have known it at the time... more: http://ic.galegroup.com/ic/uhic/ReferenceDetailsPage/ReferenceDetailsWindow?failOverType=&query=&prodId=UHIC&windowstate=normal&contentModules=&display-query=&mode=view&displayGroupName=Reference&limiter=&currPage=&disableHighlighting=true&displayGroups=&sortBy=&search_within_results=&p=UHIC%3AWHIC&action=e&catId=&activityType=&scanId=&documentId=GALE%7CCX2876200009&source=Bookmark&u=imgacademy&jsid=8c630efd03d3770a8d764ead5d27fcc3 http://ic.galegroup.com/ic/uhic/ReferenceDetailsPage/Referen... In addition, away from the public eye, Nixon’s negotiation strategy in 1969 consisted primarily of a threat to North Vietnam that if they did not become more conciliatory at the peace table, he would unleash the full fury of American power as they had never seen it. Their deadline was 1 November 1969. Consistent with this, Nixon considered escalating the war in various ways in a proposed assault known as Operation Duck Hook. According to historian Marilyn Young, Duck Hook “explored a new range of options [intended to end the war], including a land invasion of the North, the systematic bombing of dikes so as to destroy the food supply, and the saturation bombing of Hanoi and Haiphong.” Huh, that does sound like non-nuclear escalation.
- cerebrum 9y agoNonsense. Nixon wanted to be portrayed as a madman but it doesn't mean that he actually had any plans to use nukes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Madman_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Madman_theory
- pmoriarty 9y ago"During a spring offensive by the North Vietnamese in 1972, Nixon told Kissinger: ''We're going to do it. I'm going to destroy the goddamn country, believe me, I mean destroy it if necessary. And let me say, even the nuclear weapons if necessary. It isn't necessary. But, you know, what I mean is, what shows you the extent to which I'm willing to go. By a nuclear weapon, I mean that we will bomb the living bejeezus out of North Vietnam and then if anybody interferes we will threaten the nuclear weapons.'' A week later, he continued to a somewhat horrified Kissinger: Nixon: I'd rather use the nuclear bomb. Have you got that ready? Kissinger: That, I think, would just be too much. Nixon: A nuclear bomb, does that bother you?... I just want you to think big, Henry, for Christ's sake! The only place where you and I disagree is with regard to the bombing. You’re so goddamned concerned about civilians, and I don’t give a damn. I don’t care. Kissinger: I’m concerned about the civilians because I don’t want the world to be mobilized against you as a butcher.[1] ... "In a 1985 interview, Mr. Nixon acknowledged that he had considered ''the nuclear option.'' He told Time magazine then: ''I rejected the bombing of the dikes, which would have drowned one million people, for the same reason that I rejected the nuclear option. Because the targets presented were not military targets.''"[2] [1] - http://blog.nuclearsecrecy.com/2013/10/25/nixon-and-the-bomb/ http://blog.nuclearsecrecy.com/2013/10/25/nixon-and-the-bomb... [2] - http://www.nytimes.com/2002/03/01/world/nixon-proposed-using-a-bomb-in-vietnam-war.html http://www.nytimes.com/2002/03/01/world/nixon-proposed-using...