2 ms·
The relational model is a comprehensive, complete way of representing any form of data. Just because the abstractions in front of the relational model make it s
by gfodor 16y ago
The relational model is a comprehensive, complete way of representing any form of data. Just because the abstractions in front of the relational model make it somewhat klunky to access, say, keys and value based data models, has nothing to do with the mathematical soundness of the model. The limited "models" most of these NoSQL stores provide are simply subsets or re-projections of the relational model where the implementation basically bleeds all the way up to the modelling abstraction of the system: they are one in the same.
The database I described is not a panacea, you'd still have to do both good modelling and describe the ways to optimize the materialization of your data. It doesn't make the core challenges of data architecture any simpler, you still need a brain. It does, however, provide a clean abstraction and would in theory maintain most of the good things that RDBMSes have brought us without throwing all the hard work of our elders in the trash can.
- mathias_10gen 16y agoIf you (and everyone else who've made the same argument) substitute "Syntactic Sugar" for "Abstraction" and "Turing Complete" for "Relational Model" I think you've just made the claim that every application can or should be written in Brainf*ck or one of the other Turing tarpits. Just because a model is mathematically proven comprehensive, (I'm not 100% sure if relational is but that doesn't matter) doesn't mean it's the most natural way to express/solve your problem. And really, that is the only thing that matters. At least when comparing models and not implementations.
- gnaritas 16y ago> The relational model is a comprehensive, complete way of representing any form of data. Yea, but it's not the best or the easiest to represent all forms of data. Just because a problem can be solved with the relational model doesn't mean it should be; there are many ways to skin a cat and sometimes non relational solutions work better for the problem at hand.