5 ms·
Well, the cost of a raspberry Pi for a home server is actually quite high when compared to using the busted or obsolete phone gathering dust in your drawer. Si
by kbenson 9y ago
Well, the cost of a raspberry Pi for a home server is actually quite high when compared to using the busted or obsolete phone gathering dust in your drawer.
Since there are probably millions of these, why not recycle into cheap servers given the benefits of their low power use (and the possible ability to draw power to charge during cheap periods and run off battery during expensive ones).
- justin66 9y agoFor an individual, RPi is cheaper if your time is worth anything at all. On the other hand, if enough devices of the same type become available for this purpose it might make sense for a business to do this at scale.
- kbenson 9y ago> For an individual, RPi is cheaper if your time is worth anything at all. The only reason that's true is because groups have catered to the device and have ready-to-go instructions. Were the same effort put into making Samsung S2/S3/S4 etc phones easily converted, I'm not sure the time difference would be all that much at all.
- jacobush 9y agoIf only
- everheardofc 9y agoBut you don't have to support only S2/S3/S4 if that were the case then it'd be easy. The paper mentioned comparing 350 different devices. Groups can't gather if they are spread out across hundreds of devices. Not to mention that the userbase for user hostile devices isn't that big if there are user friendly alternatives.
- int_19h 9y agoBetter yet, why not develop a standard protocol of sorts to enable future devices to be used this way in a consistent manner? This could then be used as a basis for phone recycling programs: manufacturers could run the collection (and e.g. hand out gift cards for its own new products to encourage the users to turn them in while also profiting from it), and then sell the collected phones in bulk to datacenters.
- icebraining 9y agoAt least with a Pi you can install the latest security patches. Of those millions of phones, many are simply locked, and even the others very often don't have drivers compatible with the newer kernels. Becoming a node on a botnet to save $5 is not very attractive.
- kbenson 9y agoThat's true. There may be some help with the new Android HAL stuff, but the older phones are probably out of luck because the chipsets might be obsolete and thus not need new drivers to be released for them. That said, RPi still has one or two binary blob driver holdouts as well, but I agree there is a world of difference between them in this respect.
- fragmede 9y agoWhich security patches? The slides are light on details, but if I were doing this, the phones would not be running Android in any case, so while security is an important consideration, you can't just say "but security!" and toss out the baby and the bath water.
- icebraining 9y agoWhat would they be running? Which other OS supports all thousands of models of SoCs, with the necessary drivers to do everything described?