15 ms·
The U.S. is risking an academic brain drain
- monksy 9y agoWhat is the point of this article? They've claimed that the person in the article is going back home because he received no teaching offers. That's standard practice for foreign individuals on a visa in the US. You have to be doing something to stay here. We're not going to let you live here just because you felt like you wanted to. --- Other than the politicking going on in the article: "OMG TRUMP IS SO BAD AMIRITE?!" (Paris accord disagreement, etc) What I think up for debate is: Should foreign contribution in the economy on a national level be considered fair and healthy for our economy? My concern is due to depressed wages competing on non-equal levels causes more long term harm to the consumer and the businesses involved.
- wightnoise 9y agoTo me it's less about visas and more about jobs. Why aren't their more research jobs? Why isn't the govt doing more to bolster research and create opportunity for talented minds?
- oh_sigh 9y agoPerhaps the right value proposition hasn't been made. It the ones that have been made have been made with poor arguments. "Research" in itself is neither inherently good not bad...just asking for more of it doesn't make sense...just like asking for more water doesn't make sense unless you know the context is you're dying of thirst and not pumping out your flooded basement.
- ptero 9y agoGovernment funding for research is important, especially for the pure science, but government should not blindly increase funding because some people are not finding academic jobs. With the (IMO pretty broken) tenure system in the US, research-track academic jobs can be very lucrative and with many researchers un-fireable regardless of what they do academically makes research both more expensive (folks goofing off) and less valuable (sharp researchers cannot find positions) for the society that it can be. I think we need to tune the system before we talk about more funding as a solution
- ylem 9y agoI'm curious, what makes you think that people are goofing off? I suffer from selection bias, but most of the tenured faculty (in the sciences) that I know are extremely driven people who work nights and weekends...Have you seen any studies that would suggest otherwise? As for lucrative, I'm still biased, but I would say that academic jobs can be comfortable financially, especially given the stability of tenure, but outside of superstars, I wouldn't say that they are outside the range of say a software engineer...
- ptero 9y agoMostly my observations when I was doing my PhD at one of the pretty good schools (one that considers itself in the top 20, but may actually be in the top 50). I might be suffering from the selection bias as well (as I decided not to pursue an academic career), but I did see professors who had no Ph.D. students, did not publish or present and just took it easy with a minimum teaching load. I do not doubt their teaching skill, but they were doing the job of, say, a senior lecturer at 2-3 times the salary and half the workload. There were not many (maybe 10-15%), but not a single case either. My experience was on a "pure science" / paper and pencil side. Maybe it was the fact that one does not need grants for labs, etc. that takes pressure off as well. Among the grads (at least in physics) the split between experimentals and pure would be crystal clear any weekend: the first were in the lab, second played warcraft :).
- totalZero 9y agoFormer senator David Boren writes in his book, Letter to America, that not only does this happen, it's actually a good thing for the United States because many of these US-educated folks go on to become leaders back home. So if anything, their return to their home countries only solidifies American strength. For the time being, at least.
- Spooky23 9y agoThe academic brain drain starts in middle school. Why are we pushing US kids into bankruptcy and importing brains who come with dollars?
- Overtonwindow 9y agoPerhaps I'm too optimistic, but I think everything America needs to succeed and grow can be found right here in America. The problem is that it's sometimes cheaper to import foreign labor, or export domestic production.
- robotresearcher 9y agoEinstein, von Braun, Musk, Brin. Immigrants are more than cheap labor. edit just for a bit more diversity: Madeleine Albright, Schwarzenegger, Ang Lee, Tesla, Fermi, Audrey Hepburn, Sataya Nadella, Jerry Yang, Cary Grant... edit 2, correction: Ang Lee's Wikipedia page says he's a resident and not a US citizen. Another alien undercutting US labour like James Cameron and Ridley Scott.
- zo1 9y agoCiting examples doesn't really convince anyone intellectually curious, determined or with momentum in the opposite idea. What you need to do to definitely drive the point is to compare "rock star per group". Then just compare the two values, and see which group has a higher "rock star" ratio, or whatever you want to call them. Pretty obvious, right? Then you have go on and prove that for every one of those imported "rock stars", you wouldn't have gotten an equally great person from the local group. It's not immediately obvious that those things wouldn't have sprung up without that external "rock star" being brought in. We're often told that people aren't islands, so it may very well be that the local environment/culture is the one that helps create these "rock stars", and they just happen to be in the right place / right time. I use "rock-star" because I have no idea what else to call them. Leaders, high-achievers, smart-people, role models?
- deleted 9y ago
- vostok 9y agoI don't see a brain drain happening. American academic pay is better than European/Canadian/Australian academic pay by too wide of a margin. As far as politics goes, I don't think America is that much worse (if at all worse) than other high paying countries.
- robotresearcher 9y agoCanada is getting some great talent right now. Americans, Brits, and people who would have gone to the US or UK are coming here. If we can keep them here, this will be a big boost for Canada long term.
- stephenmm 9y agoAgreed. My neighbor (a Mexican national in the U.S.) who has successfully started many companies is looking for a place in Canada this week. His moving will be a great loss to the U.S. economy and innovation.
- 9t3h4r3o5w1a4w2 9y agoCanada doesn't pay half as well as US when it comes to research in STEM. Every country has great talent right now, except US has the money.
- SubiculumCode 9y agoIf there was money then why are there not enough research positions open?
- vostok 9y agoI don't think this is a productive game to play. If there's not enough money then why is academic pay better in the US than almost anywhere in the developed world?
- robotresearcher 9y agoNot enough for what?
- CorvusCrypto 9y agoWhile I don't feel that there is risk of brain drain because of the reasons listed in the article, I do believe there is that risk. To be honest, even though many European countries don't pay as much as the US for the same job, I found much more comfort around the ideas pushed in those countries. The culture I found in Sweden for instance is one that is much better for the employees than the fast-paced top-gun style of programming expected in the US. Sure my peak will probably be 60k, but that 60k will also come with a much better social quality of life. That's the problem with the US that would risk brain drain in my opinion. Money attracts people, but treating them well will keep them and the US is starting to fall away from treating its workers well. Edit: just think about this. Most Americans talk about how they have so much work to do they don't get vacation. Well in Europe you usually get your 2 weeks and in many countries you get 4 contiguous weeks without question. Couple that with better healthcare options, and yeah the US is not looking so great.
- rtx 9y agoWho will buy products from such companies. They will have to compensate for the productivity from somewhere else.
- ianai 9y agoYes, all of the above. Plus, those same sorts of policies keep the US employment rolls lower. More people would be employed if the full time work week was 30 hours (time and a half above that), for instance.
- derping69 9y agoEurope is able to do this because the US subsidizes their existence. 1. Pharma companies develop drugs with US subsidies and make their profits off US citizens while European countries put price ceilings on their drugs. 2. US essentially defends the world, allowing other countries to spend money elsewhere. http://www.ibtimes.com/how-us-subsidizes-cheap-drugs-europe-2112662 http://www.ibtimes.com/how-us-subsidizes-cheap-drugs-europe-...
- bauerd 9y ago
- ayh 9y agoAcademic positions are different than getting a job. The US will always be the beacon of innovation in the world. These are just doom and gloom clickbait articles.
- holydude 9y agoNot always but it is destined to be at this spot for a very long time.
- SubiculumCode 9y agoIf I can't get a research position in the States, but can in Europe, that is a problem.
- stevenwoo 9y agoHow does the job market for research positions and potential employee pool in the States versus Europe compare?
- SubiculumCode 9y agoI don't know the job market there. I was stating a hypothetical; I should have made that clearer. Given the post-doc situation, if another country were to dramtically increase funding for positions, America would see a brain drain.
- ylem 9y agoMy impression is that it's rather difficulty in a number of European countries as well. Chatting with friends, it seems that there are a number of term positions in countries like Germany, but permanent positions are hard to come by.
- socalnate1 9y ago"The US will always be the beacon of innovation in the world." This is nonsense. Just ask Rome, China and every other country that had it's turn at the top of the heap. We can argue about how and when this will change, but the only thing we know for certain is that it will.
- 3nki 9y agorisking? it's been happening for years.
- 3nki 9y agorisking? it's been happing for years already. both in the "drain" sense, those leaving the US, and with fewer "brains" coming to the US from other places. also, with the decline in US academics, fewer are being created in the US to begin with. altogether, three different factors making a "brain drain".
- SubiculumCode 9y agoThere are fewer permanent positions being created,not fewer academics. Hence the post-doc crisis. The risk is that a paying country might win a big portion of US born post docs ifthe situatio doesn't change.
- 3nki 9y agoi would argue there are fewer qualified academics being created in the U.S., because our educational system is declining and has been for some time, relative to other countries.
- 9t3h4r3o5w1a4w2 9y agoTo where? US is basically where most of the capital is when it comes to research in the western world.
- dajohnson89 9y agoIs this exodus even remotely close to the net influx of talent coming from other countries? If not, it really can't be called a brain drain.
- rothbardrand 9y agoNot yet, but the trends are not good. Closing borders will cut off the influx and increased regulations are going to increase the exodus. Biotech or anything related to "Stem cells" or "Cloning" are the past ones, future ones may be AI. And cryptocurrencies and that entire area of research is quickly becoming untenable in the USA.
- rdtsc 9y ago> The U.S. is risking an academic brain drain He got a good offer from his home country. Isn't that a good thing that he gets to go home to his country and contribute there? he fact they can spare $250k for him to buy a house and $1M in grant money says a lot about China. Having been in academia for a bit, it seemed there was an oversupply of PhD in some fields. There are just not going to be enough university teaching positions and not enough Googles or Teslas or other companies needing that many employees with such advanced degrees. He mentions it's Trump's fault. Let's criticize Trump but not sure if attaching it to this particular case makes it productive. I think they meant this H1-B overhaul http://www.npr.org/2017/04/18/524569185/trumps-latest-executive-order-targets-high-skilled-worker-visa-program http://www.npr.org/2017/04/18/524569185/trumps-latest-execut... Another Axios reporter seems to think the update to H1-B overhaul is mainly targeted at abuse by India-based staffing companies like Tata, Wipro and HCL https://www.axios.com/changing-h-1b-rules-computer-programmers-2344818625.html https://www.axios.com/changing-h-1b-rules-computer-programme...
- dv_dt 9y agoAn oversupply of PhDs or our capitalist system not aligning in a way to advance us in ways that don't model a ROI in three years or less?
- corporateslave3 9y agoNo just an oversupply of people that really arent smart enough to push their fields forwards, they are just highly "educated". PHDs at average schools can be done by most people willing to put in long hours, we need to stop conflating these "highly educated" people with actual ingenuity. Capitalism rightly casts them off to the side.
- dv_dt 9y agoI maintain that the biggest inefficiency of how we practice capitalism today is that it is casting aside the ability for people to contribute to society to their full potential. And as we advance economically, it seems that inefficiency is expanding to more and more people.
- eighthnate 9y agoThat's funny. Everyone I know in academia, from CS to Philosophy to Biology, is complaining there is a glut of "academics". They had PhDs but they can't positions in labs or get assistant professors to get on track for tenure because there are so many PhDs in academia. Maybe a brain drain is something the US needs. An oversupply of "brains" isn't a good thing. We need a balance.
- flamedoge 9y agoFrom outsider pov, US has been draining talent from foreign countries for ages. Perhaps those talent going back might be a net positive.
- forapurpose 9y agoAnother way the U.S. is risking a brain drain: I've read that in more than one state college enrollment is going down. Education seems to be going backward. People assume the U.S. is a first-world country, but there's no reason it can't be like Russia or other nations with poor government, corruption, and a culture that doesn't value education.
- asclepi 9y agoThat's not necessarily true if it means that more Americans are pursuing skills-based training instead of college. Many of our vacant jobs do not have a college program to prepare for them [1]. Valuing education doesn't mean you need to chase ever-increasing college enrollment numbers, especially if you are unable to provide every college graduate with a matching job. [1] https://venturebeat.com/2017/06/22/help-wanted-americans-dont-need-more-degrees-they-need-training/ https://venturebeat.com/2017/06/22/help-wanted-americans-don... (featured on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14651019 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14651019)
- forapurpose 9y agoThat assumes that the only purpose of college is job skills, a recent phenomenon. College is to teach people about the world and how to reason - the ability that separates humans from beasts, civilization from barbarism, the Enlightenment from the Medieval, fact from fiction (a skill desperately needed these days) - by studying the great reason and 'reasoners' of the world, current and past, in all different fields from science to literature to math to political science. If you think you can reason as well without that, with only coding school, I think you're kidding yourself. Also, the lifetime wages of college degree holders shows demand is pretty high for them. Finally, when people say college isn't necessary, they meant 'not necessary for lower class kids'. I assure you that every Senator who proposes cutting education funding is sending their own kids to college, as is almost everyone reading this on HN.
- notyourday 9y ago> U.S. universities take about half of research grants as fixed overhead, sapping up funding before it reaches a scientist's hands. In China, overhead is closer to 10%, allowing more staff hiring and equipment purchases, Li said US university administrators are fat. Start cutting.
- rothbardrand 9y agoI have spent many years living and working in countries other than the USA-- and while I found all of them had one advantage or another over the USA, the cultural differences were enough to make me come back to the USA. Alas, at the way things are going with regulations, particularly in tech, and the increased... polarization and radicalization of politics here, I'm starting to think that it's time to leave again. And here's the thing-- I bought a car on a 5 year note and it's not even paid off yet. Pretty soon, any kind of innovative work in the crypto space (Eg: trust-less atomic swaps between blockchains for example) is effectively illegal, UNLESS you can raise $100M to hire enough lawyers to prove you never have custody of the coins. Much cheaper to move to a friendly jurisdiction, raise the same $100M and put it into engineering salaries.
- anotherbrownguy 9y agoAre the people who applied for research positions and got the job staying? I guess so. So, those who didn't get the job weren't the "brains" that the US needed? And apparently, China is paying big compensations for him because these are the "brains" that China desperately needs. It seems like everyone is happy. What is the point of this article?
- clairity 9y agothe real issue, unanswered by the article, is why didn't linsen li get job offers here? because the premise that we want to keep all the smart people here to generate more economic value for "us" rather than "them" is hard to disfavor. 1. was he deficient in some way that makes him unsuitable for the job? 2. did the university not provide the needed skills for the teaching positions he was applying for? 3. is the supply of qualified applicants so high that many receive no offers? 4. is there just not enough funding to employ every qualified academic? 5. is the regulatory environment such that we force many qualified jobseekers to look elsewhere? ...and so on. these seem to be the more pertinent questions in this case, not the political "trump is xenophobic and his policy sucks" slant of the article (whether you agree with that sentiment or not), because the uncertainty around imiigration policy doesn't seem to have had direct bearing in this situation. li didn't get a job in the US, so he's going to china, where he did get a job. pretty straightforward. with that said, i believe we should allow much more immigration, not less (contrary to trump's position), but the light and disjoint reasoning in this article was a head scratcher.
- ylem 9y agoLet's say you apply for a faculty position at a good public university. In physics, it would not be uncommon for there to be around 200 applicants. Imagine that only say 50 of them are great...Teaching positions are also competitive. That's one level. Now, the US is in an enviable position of being able to skim top people from around the world who come here to study--so we end up with a huge competition for a small pool of positions. The notion being that all other things being equal, having a large candidate pool is more likely to result in stronger candidates. That's what we risk giving up by limiting immigration--especially after we (I am from the US) train people here to do research.
- nitwit005 9y agoFor better or worse, a number of countries are going to be churning out far more people with PhDs than can fill their academic or research positions. That will probably include China, given the trend of education there.
- hosh 9y agoMy father was a postdoc in the 90s, having gotten his master's and Ph.D. here in the states. Mother has a Ph.D. as well. My family and Taiwanese, and I knew about this issue growing up. This doesn't just affect our family, it also affects the other Taiwanese families I am aware of. The difference was that, back then, if we were to go back to Taiwan, there wasn't a guarantee that a US-trained Ph.D. would get any sort of employment. It is similar, yet different with China: in the past 5 years, I have seen China, flushed with cash (from, you know, Americans) aggressively investing. Infrastructure investment is the most obvious -- for example, ambitious rail plans that not only stretch across China, but also into Europe and Africa. There is also an aggressive investment in cultural influence as well. (For example, trying to get Wushu recognized as an official Olympic sport). And then there is advanced research. There are two teams in the world that researches quantum tunneling communication, and one of them is a Chinese team who was a protege of the PI of the only other team trying to pull it off. There is massive investment into AI/ML, into space, into military (both a carrier program as well as asymmetric military technologies such as drone carriers). A postdoc in America doesn't really get much respect, not in the way the Chinese and Taiwanese do. You could struggle here in America, writing research grants, and your family doesn't know or doesn't even care. Or you could be offered being a director of a lab with a lot of funding. Family members and neighbors might not know the science behind what you do, yet they admire and respect you. I remember this documentary about the creation of the Three Gorges Dam and the displacement of some families along that river. They showed a girl in a family who was sent off to work on the cruise ships for tourists who wanted to see the Three Gorges before it got flooded. The family needed money so they sent their daughter off -- a very Chinese things to do. The girl didn't want to work and the mother is telling her, sorry, this is for the family. You know what dream the girl was giving up? It wasn't an entertainer, or an entrepreneur. She wanted to become a scientist. She saw scientists as the heroes. That's something I never hear in America. I think a lot of people in the West forget that (despite the Cultural Revolution), the Ming dynasty Chinese at its ascendent had more reach, technological prowess, and industry of any other society ... and they deliberately turned inward: completed the Great Wall of China, recalled the exploration fleets, shut down their massive network of steel foundries, just before the time the Europeans were starting to explore and to colonize. China has had many cycles of empire expansions, consolidations, and fragmentations. And I see America making the same mistakes ...
- kevinalexbrown 9y agoBecause the article just offers a single example, and seems to center on the lack of available tenure track positions, I'm going to take a more holistic view that gets at the major issue: is current research funding at the appropriate level? What would happen if we increased research funding by X percent? How did we settle on the current funding levels? I would be curious to see a reasonable source for this. A cursory google search mostly returned opinion pieces that we should increase funding for science. I agree, but hard(er) numbers would be better. It would be great to see a back-of-the-envelope ROI for X percent funding increase in T time. Obviously funding can be applied in many ways, and the ROI is difficult to measure, but someone must have studied it. For the immediate future, the US remains the best place for research. But dominance can begin to change before the effects become obvious, like a large company that's still profitable long after it's become irrelevant.
- HillaryBriss 9y agothe article notes that US universities take 50% of a professor's research grant as operating overhead! (in China it's 10%.) maybe US universities are just not efficient enough. maybe US universities are basically bloated, government subsidized fat-cats that cannot compete in the global marketplace.
- deong 9y agoThe university system was the envy of the world when it was run like a government program. It was only when we started running them like businesses that the system has gone pear-shaped.
- HillaryBriss 9y agoi was going to say "maybe US universities are basically bloated, greedy corporate fat-cats that cannot compete in the global marketplace." but it raised a question i couldn't answer: how do such unproductive blobs of corporate greed survive at all? i mean, if it's not government subsidies. is it some sort of protectionist regulatory regime (e.g. sort of like the TBTF Wall Street banks enjoy)? some kind of collusion? a secret cartel?
- sangd 9y agoBesides job offer salaries, we usually don't quantify other aspects such as social quality, family, housing conditions, etc... It is actually very hard or impossible in some cases to measure. US has definitely been winning with the salary advantage, but it is lacking the rest compared to many places. This would be the main reason that talents would eventually go away. There's no war, life conditions have been improved in many parts of the world, why not those places.
- rb808 9y ago> Canada, France and China have been most open and aggressive about seeking out foreign talent studying in the United States. Financially, China's offers appear to be the most attractive. This was an amazing thing for me how China can pay more than Europe (and America). How the world has changed in just a few decades.
- WithHighProb 9y agoNot so surprising to me. The 1000s people plan and its version for younger people ("young 1000s") have been there for years actually. The reward is much more than what's listed in the surface. You can earn super high social status and chances to get tons of privileges.
- forgotAgain 9y agoSeems more like the tub is overflowing rather than draining.
- noetic_techy 9y ago250K for a house. How exactly do you expect any country, let alone the US, to compete with that kind of offer. Sure you can expand research grant money, as the article mentions, but what more than that? A guaranteed job? A blank check? The author should have spelled out some realistic reforms. I'd hardly call 140+ out of 3000+ applicant returnees a brain drain. Sounds like they don't offer this to foreigners either. Someone forgot to tell them how politically incorrect that is. Plenty of smart people from other countries would love to take their place. And so what if they go to Canada, our friendly northern neighbor, ally, partner in this hemisphere, and subscriber to our intellectual property laws. I don't necessarily consider that a "drain", more like just living in "alternative version USA". Not like they can't easily return to the US if a better opportunity came up and or the political climate shifted more to their liking.
- otherbrownguy2 9y agoSeems like a great way to grow the Chinese economy.
- 2OEH8eoCRo 9y agoNothing that another World War won't fix. Knock China down a peg or two /s
- QML 9y agoAre scientists only valued when the United States is against a country of equal education? I haven't had much time to read into this, but it feels like the advantage the United States has over other countries in terms of academic institutions has stagnated. Where are the Bell Labs, PARC, Los Alamos Labs of the 21st century? Where are the Neumanns, Heisenbergs, or Einsteins of this era? Probably not here. The agitation of identity politics and growing wave of anti-intellectualism is keeping our best minds apart.
- 0xfaded 9y agoI'm leaving after 3 years working for SV start ups. It's time for me to do my own thing, and there's just no viable way for me to stay here during the "figuring it out phase". Spain, France and the Netherlands have attractive entrepreneur visas, or I could easily go home to Australia, to New Zealand or Canada. I will miss living near Stanford and the people around here, but there are other top universities to go camp out next to. There was similar discussion on proberts AMA, there's simply no easy way to hang out here to work on cool side projects. The closest thing is the E2 visa, which would require all of my savings.
- cumbuckets 9y agoInteresting