14 ms·
Aetna accidentally exposed customer HIV statuses in clear envelope windows
- mabbo 9y agoOh neat, I just signed up for Aetna (first time working in America since ACA). Is this normal for them? Am I an idiot?
- jasonkostempski 9y agoI have them through work, they're pretty shitty, for example, I currently have to either turn of uBlock (not an option) or open dev tools to unhide a div in order to log in. Why there is anything on health insurance website that communicates with a third-party server baffles me. That said, I don't think there are any good options in the US. They all have weird quirks like this, they all require a fight to get the payouts you're entitled to and they'll fudge the numbers so you end up paying way more than you expect. Welcome to America. Edit: I do have APL gap insurance too. I have nothing but praise for them, easy to work with, paid quickly (checks usually made out to me directly because most places here don't deal with APL), and covered most of my out-of-pocket cost with Aetna which I maxed out last year.
- Fej 9y agoAetna uses JavaScript for everything on their website. Can't middle-click a link to open in a new tab because it's JS, not a proper link.
- jasonkostempski 9y agoI can accept that but whatever the reference to twitter ads is for, I'm appalled by.
- sqeaky 9y agoYou shouldn't be downvoted for normal and reasonable questions, or even for self doubt. Aetna is terrible. The lobby against healthcare reform at every turn. They didn't want obamacare/ACA they didn't want to compete accross state lines, they want to be able to exempt people from pre-existing conditions, they want to give people the run-around. They are not trustworthy and they are run by bad people. (don't beat up on their phone agents though, they are just trying to make ends meets).
- rcraft 9y agoAre there any other insurers that don't do/want many of these same things?
- sqeaky 9y agoI think BlueCross and United Health only do some of the evil things, but I wouldn't swear to it.
- chaosphere2112 9y agoFor those in one of the covered regions[1], Kaiser Permanente is largely not-evil. You have to go through your GP to get referrals to specialists, but it's a series of mostly consistent "I have X problem" "Try Y" "Didn't work" "Try Z" "Didn't Work" "OK, let's get you to a specialist" events. They have an interesting governance structure (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaiser_Permanente https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaiser_Permanente) that tries to align incentives correctly. [1]: Coverage areas as divided by corporate entities: Northern California Southern California Colorado Georgia Hawaii Mid-Atlantic (vicinity of Washington, D.C., including Maryland and Virginia) Northwest (Northwest Oregon and Southwest Washington) Washington (except Southwest Washington)
- Cerium 9y agoLots of people complain about Kaiser. I was a member when I was growing up, and have signed up again now that I have a job offering Kaiser coverage. For me Kaiser is a couple things. First of all it is peace of mind. They won't screw you. Essentially everything they offer is covered at a reasonable rate. Example: I was sent to the emergency room once and was able to pay on the spot with the cash in my wallet. Secondly, if you go to one of their medical centers everything is in that building. When I am sick, I don't want to go to a few stops across town to get everything (doctors office, lab, pharmacy, etc). Additionally they actively do things to keep people healthy. They host farmers markets at some of their centers, run advertisements focused on getting exercise and eating well. In general, they make you feel like they are on your side.
- yebyen 9y agoIf you know how to "don't take no for an answer" I'll say optimistically, you'll be alright. My experience with my wife's health care (Aetna) has been that she will call, try to get an issue resolved, be told "there is no resolution possible" enough times by enough different people that she is ready to give up. Then we call together, and suddenly the story changes. The particular issue we were dealing with, is not really important, but tl;dr I almost wound up with two health insurances because I tried to stay insured and cover my bases when I was changing jobs, and nobody needs two health insurances. They tried to tell us we couldn't cancel when I got a new job that came with better coverage for less. I thought that was a qualifying event! But, through some nonsense technicality we would not be allowed to cancel during the plan year, and even though I'd never made a claim and we were making quarterly payments, we'd be on the hook for the remainder of payments for the whole year. (This is illegal, I'm sure of it.) The best advice I can give you is, know your rights and how to assert them. Good luck with that though, health care in this country is byzantine and I had the benefit of people in my family that work in health care administration who could help me understand.
- arkades 9y ago1) know who to appeal to outside the company. This is the nuclear option. It's usually listed in fine print on every paper denial. 2) "My (partner) works in insurance. He does shit like this for a living. Please don't make me have to (goto 1)". 3) Feel free to cite the law where relevant, on paper, certified mail. The response is invariably "this is wrong, you misunderstand the law, but we will make an exception and (follow the fucking law this once.)" I was in health insurance, management level, before I went into medicine.
- LanceH 9y agoThe number one rule is don't pay anything until it is resolved. The second you've made payment, nobody else cares to make any effort.
- arkades 9y agoThis is not something I'd recommend. Any lapse in payment will be used to suspend your policy in the future in the event you get flagged as a high-expense patient, backdated to the period you didn't pay your premiums on time. Pay on time, keep documentation you paid on time. Hell, turn on autopay and keep documentation on -that-. Don't ever think you can hold your premiums hostage. You'll only be screwing yourself. Edit: if you're referring to clinic bills, be sure you're in active communication with the practice manager so you don't get sent to collections. If it's a hospital, you'll be sent to collections anyway - they automate that process, once you're sufficiently late.
- Arubis 9y agoAetna has long had a poor reputation, even amongst insurance companies. The phrase "Aetna, Aetna, so sorry we met ya" was commonplace in the healthcare industry ~15y ago.
- emodendroket 9y agoThey're all like this.
- cgb223 9y agoI had COBRA healthcare through them and even though HR did all the paperwork and submitted it to Aetna, Aetna forgot to actually setup the policy. I found this out the hard way in the ER mid near fatal allergic reaction So yeah, you'll be fine...
- blackguardx 9y agoWas this in California around 2008? There was a big scandal about this and now there are big fines for doing it. A few insurers were accepting people (and accepting payment) without actually setting them up in the system. When many of these people went to use the insurance, they were told that not only did they not have insurance, they would be denied any insurance for having pre-existing conditions.
- yebyen 9y agoMy favorite is the HR person who says "we can correct any errors that were made with your insurance retroactively, don't worry" I am worried, though! Because I've got this deduction coming out of my paycheck for insurance, and your insurance provider just told me that they've never heard of me! Escalate!
- cgb223 9y agoNo this was two months ago Maybe they're still doing it
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- occultist_throw 9y agoReading further in, it was a screw-up on the paper envelope that had too big of a window and referred to HIV treatment connected to the person's name. This is really bad, but it was 12k localized instances of crummy physical mailing. Its pretty bad, but it's not like this was "300k people leaked by hackers for ransom".
- yebyen 9y agoIt's pretty bad. HIV clinics have "no-contact" lists and if you hypothetically worked for a survey company that made a phone call to one of those numbers, and said you were calling from "XYZ clinic for PQR person who isn't here right now", and the person who takes your call connects the dots, and realizes XYZ clinic is an HIV clinic... you could make two people very upset, and one person homeless. Hypothetically speaking... it could be real bad news. Let's just say after that, we asked every medical office we ever worked with from then on, if they had any "no-contact" lists to please ensure they remove those people from the contact list before we started making calls. We had a mail/phone operation and I'm just imagining our production manager not looking closely enough at even one of 12,000 pieces of mail in windowed envelopes that says "HIV medication" in plain view, before loading them into his car and mailing them at the post office. He'd be canned instantly. Someone definitely got fired over this.
- emodendroket 9y agoPhew, they only needlessly and carelessly divulged 12,000 people's HIV status.
- occultist_throw 9y agoI never said it was a good thing. Even though the badness of the situation, I'm saying it would have been terribly worse with mass leaks of the DB this came from. It's not like we in the tech community have seen leaks like that... Regardless, I see this as a bad screw-up with with no ill intent behind it. It was literally a "too large window" on an envelope...
- 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dqv 9y agoWow, this is actually something I consider when sending letters to my clients. I don't ever want to "leak" their info, even if it's not really considered sensitive. I always assume the top third to be "compromised", only putting the private contents in the lower two thirds or on the back. I wonder why they don't have the mailing rule of the top third as a written policy.
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoA cost/benefit analysis of "put all HIPAA-relevant information inside an opaque envelope" probably comes out ahead if it prevents one issue like this. Hell, make the envelope a specific color to make it really obvious that you've done things correctly.
- maxerickson 9y agoWould the differently colored envelope itself be a HIPPA violation?
- chimeracoder 9y ago> A cost/benefit analysis of "put all HIPAA-relevant information inside an opaque envelope" probably comes out ahead if it prevents one issue like this. To be pedantic, the patient's name and address are both considered PHI under HIPAA. The way that most insurers deal with this is by mailing an envelope that has no obvious information on the outside about the sender (it has a return address that's usually a PO box somewhere in the midwest, but not the company's name). So without opening it, you can't tell that the piece of mail relates to medical information. Banks do this as well when mailing things like credit cards, to make it less obvious to a would-be interceptor of the mail that there's something valuable inside. (Of course, the deliberate inconspicuousness of it is itself conspicuous, but that's another problem).
- hammock 9y agoAlso there is something called a security envelope, which is printed on the inside with a pattern of lines that makes it difficult to read the contents of an unopened letter by holding it up to the light. Back when mailing checks to pay bills was a thing, everyone had a box of them and that's what you used. I imagine companies today should still use them.
- chimeracoder 9y agoNote that the USPS also scans and stores images of the front and back of all mail it delivers, even if you don't opt in for their digital delivery service[0]. So this means that the USPS - and anybody else with access to their images, which includes law enforcement - now knows the HIV status of these people. [0] http://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/03/us/postal-service-confirms-photographing-all-us-mail.html http://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/03/us/postal-service-confirms...
- AckSyn 9y agoMan, the lawsuit from this is going to be huge.
- jubabuba 9y agoIn practice USPS/law enforcement will have this image data but they will not parse it for some time (if ever).
- checker 9y agoAFAIK in this case law enforcement is the Inspection Service which is part of USPS; if images are divulged to any other agency, it's through USPSIS.
- bgirard 9y agoAnd I've seen a new complex in the bay where, for reasons unknown to me, it shows you the scans of all your neighbors.
- jacquesm 9y agoThis comment begs expansion.
- ianmiers 9y agoScarier point: USPS probably knows without that. If these letters are sent out in batches and the envelopes/timing/vender is unique, then all it takes is knowing that 1 letter is abut HIV and then you know all of them are without ever seeing the content.
- Allower 9y agoincompetence never gets old
- pluma 9y agoDoes the US not have standardized letter and envelope sizes? In Germany we have standards for paper sizes, window placement and the layout of business letters. Considering this type of letter is probably not typed out by hand, it's trivial to use a template with the correct layout. At that point the choice of letter becomes irrelevant. I'd expect the US to have something similar but maybe they don't? If there are standards, this boils down to either "Aetna used non-standard envelopes" or "Aetna formatted letter incorrectly".
- baddox 9y agoI don't know if there are actual codified standards, but I often receive letters (mostly bills) with the same envelope size and window placement. I would guess they just folded or ordered the contents of the envelope incorrectly.
- rdiddly 9y agoThere is no standard that I'm aware of. On a related note, if I had a dollar (or a Euro) for every US problem that the Germans solved long ago through straight thinking, I'd have enough money to move to Germany.
- munificent 9y ago> for every US problem that the Germans solved long ago through straight thinking Sad that we apparently need to add "outlawing Nazis" to that list now.
- bdamm 9y agoHave you talked to some Germans about how "straight thinking" they think their country is? When you don't get to see the sausage made it looks good but peel pack the process a bit and you'll see that there are still very significant issues. Note: I have huge respect for German society and governance.
- vidarh 9y agoThe standards for paper and envelope sizes [1] are so ingrained in me that it's almost like metric vs. imperial. They're ISO standards, though based on German standards, and being able to instantly know roughly how big a paper size is, is very convenient. E.g. A4 almost the size of US Letter, but from there we know if you take an A4 sheet, turn it 90 degrees and puts another one above it in the same orientation, you have A3. Repeat for A2 and so on. Or fold an A4 in half and you have A6. Meanwhile an A4 sheet will fit in a B4 or C4 envelope without being folded, or in a B5 or C5 envelope folded in half... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paper_size#International_paper_sizes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paper_size#International_paper...
- sjg007 9y agomassive HIPPA violation.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoSince most of this thread has turned into comparing the terribleness of insurance companies I'll say it again: A good said of less than legitimate identification documents are probably far more useful to someone needing urgent medical care than insurance coverage is.
- neom 9y agoA dude in my girlfriends class at a good university in nyc just had this happen and his roommate saw and went to the school and said they want him removed from the dorm, school obviously said no, but it was a huge ordeal.
- throwawaymanbot 9y agoNot only this, but I'm fairly sure that they send itemized bill to not only where you live, but to former addresses also. (To make sure you get you bill of course) If you dont live in a place for 5 years, someone can open your bill and find out what you are getting billed for. (HIV tests and all)
- kelukelugames 9y agohttps://vine.co/v/5hBviTJuHj5 https://vine.co/v/5hBviTJuHj5
- pasbesoin 9y agoSeparately, it has been reported in the last several years that the U.S. Postal System has implemented imaging every single piece of mail it moves. They have already OCR-ed addresses from mail, for years. If they are now retaining the raw images, does this mean that they've inadvertently collected and are holding the HIV status of all the Aetna customers affected by this information leak? So far, it seems the USPS is not selling what it's collected. (Although I'm sure some of the "make a buck any way you can" crowd in DC and elsewhere would not be above enabling and pushing them to do so.) But, next year? And in case you thing this is far-fetched, many state departments of motor vehicles (DMV) already make their drivers license photographs commercially available, IIRC.
- bridanp 9y agoThis is the kind of thing that induces panic attacks in my business because so much time is spent on the look and feel of any letter going out to customers, and so little time is spent on the finished product (ie QA process for the letter in the envelope). It's probably not a matter of the company being evil (although Aetna could probably be described that way at times). It's more than likely 1) the lack of proper procedure in place regarding mass mailing, 2) the lack of a standardized Quality Assurance program, and/or 3) a 3rd party was contracted out by Aetna to do the mass mailing and they you could probably wrap back through #1 and #2 for them as well. None of scenarios can diminish just how awful this is of course. There are some things you can get wrong on that envelope that are bad, but not really livelihood threatening. This is life changing for a huge number of people I'm sure, and the companies involved should be held accountable for the breach.
- jacquesm 9y ago> 3rd party was contracted out by Aetna to do the mass mailing and they you could probably wrap back through #1 and #2 for them as well. To contract this out would be a terrible breach of protocol.
- MaxfordAndSons 9y ago>To contract this out would be a terrible breach of protocol. That's false. HIPPA covered entities are allowed to engage contractors, who are allowed to handle protected health information (they also must comply with HIPPA, of course). Source: have worked for an HIO (health information organization, a type of HIPPA compliant contractor), and https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/faq/547/to-what-extend-does-hipaa-allow-third-parties-to-access-information/index.html https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/faq/547/to-what-...
- jacquesm 9y agoYou are 100% correct, I messed that up. What came to mind was the likes of Sendgrid or Mailchimp. Apologies and thank you for the correction.