3 ms·
Perhaps grellas might shed some light on the laches issue, but aside from that I think this is legit. First, I notice the response from Facebook was that this i
by jeromec 16y ago
Perhaps grellas might shed some light on the laches issue, but aside from that I think this is legit. First, I notice the response from Facebook was that this is "frivolous" not bogus, which implies to me that Mark did sign that document. Second, from scrutinizing the hardly legible document it appears the claims are accurate, including the 1% ownership transfer to "Purchaser" for every day of delay in project completion after January 1, 2004. Last, the contract timeline does make sense to me. It sounds like a very young college kid in 2003 with his mind on many things, including a hobby project to connect students met a more experienced business man who wanted some street software developed. The business man recognized the value in the hobby project already begun by Mark which he loosely referenced as "The Face Book". The business man then covered himself to be well-positioned legally if this hobby took off. He paid Mark 1K for it (and another 1K for the street software), explaining Mark would still own 50% of "The Face Book" in case it did become more valuable... All hypothetical, but not hard to imagine.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- anigbrowl 16y agoTrue, but laches is is important. Given that I'm not a lawyer... FB must show laches applies, but this should be easy. It requires showing knowledge (obviously that existed, as Ceglia knows he had a contract), unreasonable delay (FB isn't hard to find), and prejudice (delay avoidably made the problem worse). Probably Ceglia just wants to be paid to go away. Edit: on reflection, all of that applies to Facebook, the company. Ceglia is also suing Zuckerberg as an individual, presumably for 84% of the value of his stake. I'm less sure of how that claim would fare - it's just as late, but is it prejudicial to Zuckerberg's interests? (Just wondering from a purely theoretical standpoint.)
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]