4 ms·
> Automated driving is necessary if the systems cause fewer accidents than human drivers. True, but sounds like autonomous vehicles were a bitter pill to swall
by weinzierl 9y ago
> Automated driving is necessary if the systems cause fewer accidents than human drivers.
True, but sounds like autonomous vehicles were a bitter pill to swallow for less accidents.
> In the case of unavoidable accidents, classification of drivers is prohibited. This includes determining fault by age, sex, or physical and mental constitution.
Does that the imply that we should only be in favour of auotonomous vehicles if they are always better than the worst drivers?
EDIT: I probably misunderstood this one. After reading the passage in the origal report I think it means that the computer is not allowed (for example) to prefer to save a child over an adult.
> We must be able to determine the responsible party in an accident at any time: human or computer.
Desirable, but good luck with that one.
> Drivers must have proper documentation.
Not sure what that means.
> The driver should be able to decide who owns his vehicle data.
Why not simply demand that the driver owns the data. If we leave the decision to the driver we will know how it ends up. They will assign away all their rights for a free cookie.
Most importantly the article (didn't read the report) skips one of the most important and difficult ethical questions. How the balance the life of other with the physical integrity of those in the car, especially in the light of unavoidable false positives.
- _up 9y agoThe "proper documentation" part is about hybrid systems where the driver can be given control/responsibility in some situations. These situations must be clearly documented and should also be internationally standardized. They also specifically warn and advise to prevent data collection practices currently used by Search Engine and Social Media Companies. Original Report (German): https://www.bmvi.de/SharedDocs/DE/Anlage/Presse/084-dobrindt-bericht-der-ethik-kommission.pdf https://www.bmvi.de/SharedDocs/DE/Anlage/Presse/084-dobrindt...
- dx034 9y ago> Why not simply demand that the driver owns the data. If we leave the decision to the driver we will know how it ends up. They will assign away all their rights for a free cookie. The translation of the article isn't great. With "owning" data they mean to determine who has access to the data. The driver has to be able to deny companies using their data. If this is implemented it would be a good step, Tesla currently doesn't allow that.