6 ms·
I honestly struggle to understand. Can't these guys see that the people they "envy" are actually on a worse trend? Eastern Europe benefited immensely by Europea
by toyg 9y ago
I honestly struggle to understand. Can't these guys see that the people they "envy" are actually on a worse trend? Eastern Europe benefited immensely by European manufacturers relocating there, to the direct detriment of their Western workers. The EU pumped zillions of Euros in their infrastructure and their economies; and for the trouble, more often than not we get back an insistence on regressive and retrograde policies, blocking ever-closer integration, and constantly sabotaging "solidarity" policies like refugee resettlement out of pure racism and egoism.
To me these people seem extremely ungrateful. I have said it before, and I know it's an unpopular opinion, but I really wouldn't cry if EU8 and their galaxy would just be left to their own devices. They don't want to feel like colonies? Fine with me, that's the door. Like us idiots in UK, they'll soon find out that life outside is not that great.
- nickbauman 9y agoI don't understand why you're being down-voted. I can disagree with your feelings about it, but you describe exactly what's going on. If they leave the EU, I'm not sure it would change their fate. Capital doesn't give a shit about what government is running the country. They just care whether they can get cheaper labor from that country or not. If they leave the EU because they don't like the policies they can just as easily experience capital flight.
- mschuster91 9y ago> and constantly sabotaging "solidarity" policies like refugee resettlement out of pure racism and egoism. No. This is mainly payback to Germany for how we treated all other countries, especially Italy and Greece, during the financial crisis. The refugee influx is the way for everyone else to "stick the finger to Germany", as Varoufakis once said... Germany did not show any solidarity at all with the worst-off countries, only with their banks (where, again, German banks are shareholders in, or have significant amounts of money loaned to/invested in these banks) and the arms industry. In fact, the French and German arms industries actually extorted that they be paid, or else Greece would get no cash (source: https://www.heise.de/tp/features/Griechische-Milliarden-fuer-deutsche-U-Boote-3386247.html https://www.heise.de/tp/features/Griechische-Milliarden-fuer...). > Like us idiots in UK, they'll soon find out that life outside is not that great. You Brits are not idiots, only your government is a spineless bunch of idiots. Fix that and I believe UK will be welcomed back into the EU - although I have to admit I'm glad there won't ever be a "British exception" any more, your politicians have held the EU back for far too long.
- lispm 9y ago> Germany did not show any solidarity at all with the worst-off countries, That's political propaganda. Germany has shown a lot of solidarity in the EU over decades. Greece and Italy are not the 'worst of' countries in the EU or Europe and Germany is not responsible for much of their economic policies.
- mschuster91 9y ago> Germany has shown a lot of solidarity in the EU over decades. That doesn't matter, because we Germans did all our best to fuck up Italy and Greece - it began with insisting on the Dublin Agreement so that IT/GR would be stuck with the refugees while Germany could continue to live without refugees, and it continued during the financial crisis and afterwards - hell, Germany made in 2017 1.3B € by loaning money for cheap on the markets and then loaning that money for more interest to Greece (source: http://www.zeit.de/politik/deutschland/2017-07/griechenland-krise-finanzhilfe-deutschland-verdienst-gruene http://www.zeit.de/politik/deutschland/2017-07/griechenland-...)! Fleecing a dead economy like Schäuble still does... well, I'm not surprised at all that other EU countries want to hit on Germany.
- lispm 9y agoGreece needs more money, where do you think it comes from? Greece didn't get any more on the markets, that's why countries like Germany had to step in and rescue them. No, sorry Germany is also not responsible for the economic crisis in Italy. That's mostly homegrown. Germany is also not responsible for destabilizing the middle east and north africa. Libya was an Italian colony and in 2011 Italy took part in the military invention in Libya. Since then Libya is a failed state and many refugees/immigrants are coming via Libya. The big players were the US, Italy, France, the UK,... those did take part in the regime change, but failed to bring peace to the region. Actually the situation in Libya is worse than it was before. Germany did not take part in these things and is not a big player in the middle east / north african politics and military interventions.
- 9y ago
- bobthechef 9y agos/ungrateful/unappreciative/. You could say that some don't appreciate the changes that the region has gone through. Gratitude is a term you would use for things like gifts. You can, however, appreciate a good business relationship. The colonies bit you wrote was out of place. It sounds like you're saying "either be a colony, or get out". Calling the refusal to take in so-called refugees racist is inappropriate. I think you should do yourself the favor and delve into that subject a bit more instead of passively accepting certain ignorant narratives. The migrant crisis is a huge stain on Merkel's record, a demonstration of massive incompetence and blindness. Most migrants weren't even from Syria or affected areas. Also, note that no one seemed to notice how countries like Poland took in more than 1 million refugees from Ukraine following Russia's invasion of the country. Germany took in practically no one. W.r.t. solidarity, Germany has a spotty record where solidarity is concerned. Consider how Germany has refused the building of Nordstream gas pipelines through central/eastern Europe from Russia, instead opting to have them run through the Baltic at greater expense. This allows Russia to cut gas supplies to central/eastern Europe without affecting Germany. Russia, as we have seen time and again, does not hesitate to use energy supplies as a tool of political pressure. I think that while central/eastern Europe should recognize the massive changes their markets have undergone, it does not negate the other realities that are at play.
- bgarbiak 9y agoPoland took in not million but 183 refugees from Ukraine. (data from april 2017) The million people you're talking about are no refugees, they are cheap labour. They're allowed to stay only as long as they keep their jobs. And they're free to go to any other country in EU. To say that Poland's (and other central European countries) refusal to take in refugees from the Middle East is not driven by racism is to delude yourself. Some politics bluntly only agree to take in Christians. Not to mention that those countries are even willing to pay fines, just to keep these people away. Refusal to take in refugees is not an act of non-solidarity with Germany. It's mainly a not-solidarity with Greece, Italy, Spain - countries who deal with this issue for years, and for years pledged for help.
- bbv-if 9y ago
- ChemicalWarfare 9y ago>> Eastern Europe benefited immensely by European manufacturers relocating there... You're making it sound like these companies outsourced manufacturing to these lower cost countries against their will/interest which is obv not the case. >> sabotaging "solidarity" policies like refugee resettlement out of pure racism and egoism. "egoism" on a state scale basically means protecting the interests of it's citizens. isn't that what the state is supposed to be doing in the first place? just because other countries in the EU are acting in the irrational (and somewhat suicidal manner) when it comes to these things - this doesn't mean everyone has to follow suit.
- toyg 9y ago> like these companies outsourced manufacturing to these lower cost countries against their will/interest No, but they did it against the interests of their existing Western workers; and such workers in many cases accepted that as a price to pay for long-term peace and prosperity on the continent. Would I prefer a world where Western workers are better off but we still have a Cold War with bombs going off here and there, the constant threat of revolutions or dictatorships and so on? No, of course not. In this sense, the Ukrainian experience is a good example of what could have been for a lot of countries without the EU. > protecting the interests of it's citizens. isn't that what the state is supposed to be doing There are many ways of protecting the interests of its citizens; one of them is helping people in need in other countries, in order to foster peace and prosperity in the long run. The US turning a blind eye towards the plight of Jewish refugees in the 1930s would have "protected" the interest of its citizens already in the US, but it would have been bad in the long run. The same for Italians moving there around the same time. Helping poor nations getting better, by accepting migrants (who will send back a lot of the money they earn, and reduce demographic pressure), is a good move in the long run, or even in the short run in most cases (since they pay for retirement of older EU citizens, which would otherwise be unsustainable in most cases because of declining demographics). > irrational (and somewhat suicidal manner) Some things look irrational in the short term but eventually make sense. A lot of our current problems are due to humanity completely losing sight of anything that is not the next fiscal quarter.
- 9y ago
- bgarbiak 9y agoI see no reason why workers, who do exactly the same job as their counterparts in Germany, UK, France, should be grateful and just accept being paid many times less. The better they are paid the better the situation is for the workers in the "old union" countries.