This is an interesting point, although I think the cleaned-up question misses the mark. Most people asked about that murder would have similar definitions of 'm

This is an interesting point, although I think the cleaned-up question misses the mark. Most people asked about that murder would have similar definitions of 'murder', and you'd basically be gathering predictions about the state of the world. Many people asked about a blue car will have different standards for 'blue', so our data is distorted by the possibility that people can agree on the hue of the car, but not the 'blueness' of it.