3 ms·
> one could easily find grounds to reverse Roe No, it's not so easy. Conservatives have been trying unsuccessfully to overturn it for 44 years. (Actually, th
by lisper 9y ago
> one could easily find grounds to reverse Roe
No, it's not so easy. Conservatives have been trying unsuccessfully to overturn it for 44 years. (Actually, that's not quite true. The effort to overturn Roe didn't actually start until 1979, fully six years after Roe was decided on a 7-2 vote. And the truth is they don't really want to overturn it. They really just want to use it as a wedge issue.)
- dragonwriter 9y ago> No, it's not so easy. It's easy to construct a coherent interpretation of the Constitution that invalidates Roe without nuking the Ninth Amendment (the thing with fuzzy penumbras and unenumerated rights is that it is very easy to come up with equally coherent interpretations of what their scope is.) It may be hard politically to get a Court majority appointed and confirms that agrees with eliminating abortion rights whatever the logical basis (or even without consensus on the basis; court decisions where there is a majority on the result but not the rationale are possible, so you don't need a unifying rationale to get a result.) But that's a different issue and nuke-the-Ninth types don't help that.
- lisper 9y ago> It's easy to construct a coherent interpretation of the Constitution that invalidates Roe without nuking the Ninth Amendment Really? What is it?