5 ms·
>Does that mean we should go to the opposite end of the spectrum and condemn all those who have read of the countless proven conspiracies in history and are con
by krapp 9y ago
>Does that mean we should go to the opposite end of the spectrum and condemn all those who have read of the countless proven conspiracies in history and are concerned with holding authorities accountable where little to no accountability exists?
No, and no one here is suggesting that, and neither is the article suggesting it. You're the one building the strawman.
- wu-ikkyu 9y agoDoes the author discern anywhere in the article on plausible theories/historical examples vs. the outlandish theories? If so I must have skimmed over it. If not, then how is it not implied?
- Jtsummers 9y agoConspiracy theories and conspiracies are separate things when people are discussing them like this. Someone claiming the moon landing is a hoax, conspiracy theory. Someone saying that Jack, Jim, and Bob conspired to rob a bank (perhaps without real evidence), is also technically a conspiracy theory, but it's more easily verified or dismissed. And depending on the people, may or may not be as outlandish as claiming that Kubrick filmed the Lunar Landing on a sound stage.
- krapp 9y agoDo they need to? Why assume that, unless the author explicitly mentions the existence of plausible theories and add a caveat that not all conspiracy theories are absurd, they must be arguing for the condemnation of anyone who believes in a conspiracy? Why not discern the authors' intent from their actual words? Actual, verifiable conspiracies do exist, meanwhile everything the article claims about the nature of conspiracy theory is also true.
- wu-ikkyu 9y agoYes, we should be specific in our definitions, otherwise the default would be the dictionary definition, which would have included the previously "absurd" theory (before Snowden) that the US government is performing dragnet surveillance on it's own citizens.
- hungerstrike 9y ago> No, and no one here is suggesting that, and neither is the article suggesting it. Yes, the article certainly does suggest that we need to "change [the] minds" of anyone who "believes" in conspiracy theories. (And if I'm not outright denying the possibility of a conspiracy the author considers me a "believer".) It's right there in the title and in the story of the moon landing. If you read the article, the author links to a study that allegedly proves that people who are open to conspiracy theories aren't being analytical enough and apparently that's somehow a problem for everybody and it needs to be stopped. It's as if the author thinks that they are able to accurately analyze every situation even though they weren't there (on the moon, etc) and that they have accounted for every possibility. He assumes that he has all the information. Clearly this is not the case. People who deal in hard sciences often behave like this. Perhaps the author should try analyzing their own propensity to be incorrect despite applying every analytical power that they possess because if one thing is certainly true, it's that humans generally have no idea how wrong they are - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E8V8rtdXnLA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E8V8rtdXnLA