3 ms·
The problem with conspiracy theorists isn't that they consider forbidden ideas. It's that they dismiss better ones. For example, the idea that the Pentagon was
by mikeash 9y ago
The problem with conspiracy theorists isn't that they consider forbidden ideas. It's that they dismiss better ones. For example, the idea that the Pentagon was hit by a cruise missile on 9/11 is worth brief consideration. But when you dig into it, there's no support, while there's plenty of support for the airliner.
To use your debugging analogy, it's like speculating that the bug happens because this particular variable holds 2 when it's supposed to hold 1. Then you check and it actually holds 1. But instead of moving on to the next idea, you decide that the CIA modified your debugger to lie about the value and proceed under the assumption that it really is 2.
- corpMaverick 9y agoBut they never commit to a single theory. They seem to move freely between multiple theories even if they contradict each other. The CIA killed JFK and/or the Russians killed JFK.
- splintercell 9y ago> For example, the idea that the Pentagon was hit by a cruise missile on 9/11 is worth brief consideration. But when you dig into it, there's no support, while there's plenty of support for the airliner. The way I convinced my buddy to get out of that 9/11 conspiracy mode was to ask him questions about the shitty conspiracy theories he thinks US govt comes up with. For instance: * Why claim that it was an airplane which hit Pentagon, when they can claim that terrorists got hold of a rocket launcher, or a cruise missile. Since they claim that it was a CIA agent who launched the missile, then it would be even better to claim that there is a 20th terrorist who is hiding among us, and thereby getting more advantage of what they did by claiming conspiracy (i.e. to create an environment of panic in public). * After I told about the ridiculousness of the 'conspiracy theory' like the point above, they would talk about Hitler's quote "bigger the lie, the more they'd believe it". When I tried to do more research on it, it turns out that there is no documented proof of Hitler claiming bigger unbelievable lies. In fact that quote was used by Hitler to claim the grand Jewish communist conspiracy theory of blaming Germany for the loss of WW1, which he had no proof for. Other than that, that's it. * Since the purpose of govt officials who conspired is the same as the purpose of 'alleged terrorists', i.e. to create widespread fear and panic (just for a different end goal), literally everything govt did, can be attributed to the terrorists. The terrorists performed the demolition, they destroyed WTC7 after stealing gold, etc etc. This way govt ends up with having an even more foolproof conspiracy. In fact, if the conspiracy theorist questions that by making terrorists do that many things, it would make things more ridiculous, then you can point them to "bigger the lie, more they'd believe it" statement. * Finally I asked my buddy, "Imagine if I was the person behind the attacks, I was one of the terrorists, how could I convince you that I did it, what proof can I provide you that I did it". Thankfully, my buddy hadn't lost all touch with reality, so he didn't really blame me for being a govt plant. He didn't really respond to me, but as far as I know that was the last time he advocated the conspiracy theories to anyone. And now we laugh at other conspiracy theorists.
- hungerstrike 9y ago> It's that they dismiss better ones. OK but who is deciding that it's better? You are. Unfortunately, there's no objective source for this :( > But when you dig into it, there's no support, while there's plenty of support for the airliner. But isn't support for the airliner relies on evidence that could easily have been staged or falsified post hoc? Also, why not use WTC 7 as your example? Similar buildings that caught fire didn't fall like they'd been demolitioned. IMO if you don't have any doubts about the official 9/11 story then you are not thinking about it enough.
- mikeash 9y agoNo, support for the airliner includes things like tons of people seeing the thing fly over I-395 right before it hit the Pentagon. There's a taxi driver who nearly got impaled by a lamppost the plane knocked over. One thing I've noticed with 9/11 Pentagon conspiracy theories is that people don't seem to understand the geographical context of the building. They talk about it as if it's some isolated installation in the middle of the woods or something. It's actually spang in the middle of the #6 largest metropolitan area in the country. The path that AA77 flew took it right over one of the busiest highways in the region. Literally hundreds if not thousands of people would have seen a cruise missile if it had been one. I've thought about this and looked into it extensively. I have not seen one single reasonable piece of evidence to support any of the "alternative" theories. Every one I've seen is based on speculation or outright falsehoods.