24 ms·
Conspiracy theories are fundamentally a religious idea and the result of revulsion at the possibility that things might not happen for a reason. It used to be
by empath75 9y ago
Conspiracy theories are fundamentally a religious idea and the result of revulsion at the possibility that things might not happen for a reason.
It used to be that when an unexpected tragedy happened, people would look to supernatural forces as the cause, and some flavors of conspiracy theory still do this. You'll often find Satan used interchangeably with the illuminati or masons or Jews, etc, among conspiracy theorists of a fundamentalist mindset.
But if you don't believe in supernatural forces, then you have to reach for dark and shadowy organizations, like CIA mind control experiments and Russian spies, or crisis actors or George Soros.
Anything so you don't have to face the possibility that terrible things happened for no reason, or that worse, terrible things happened and your own country or politicians might even bear some responsibility for it.
Fundamentally, people believe in conspiracy theories because they don't want to really understand reality and be forced to act on that understanding.
The nature of the conspiracy theory itself is secondary to that, and arguing against the particulars of one will, at best, push them into the arms of another.
If you want people to turn away from conspiracy, you need to provide a way of understanding and coming to terms with reality.
I don't think there's one right way to do that-- after all we've been trying to figure it out for thousands of years.
- rangibaby 9y agoCIA mind control program was (is?) real though
- soundwave106 9y agoOne of the problems most conspiracy theories have is that they revolve around complex plotlines, that are executed in a flawless fashion. Very few things work out as neatly as a conspiracy theory in real life, and the CIA mind control attempts (eg MKUltra) is no execption. For all the awful details of that program, ironically one could argue that its most notable consequence was to help create 1960s counter-culture. (Without Project MKUltra, the life of Ken Kesey and Robert Hunter would have been very, very different.)
- empath75 9y agoSure. But is it to blame for all of societies ills? The freemasons and George Soros, and jewish people, and the pope, and the FSB and most other targets of conspiracy theories are all certainly real. The question isn't whether criminal conspiracies or secret socieities or various other organizations and people exist, but whether they're all-powerful forces that drive history or not. What drives a conspiracy theorist is the idea that there is some simple explanation for everything that happens. An all-powerful 'enemy' that is the cause of all of the world's ills. I'm personally a believer, for example, that Putin ordered the FSB to interfere in the election last year and that it had some impact on the outcome. But I think what happened in the election last year was the confluence of a lot of unrelated trends, and wasn't the result of some grand scheme hatched in the Kremlin. Compare that to some of the wilder corners of the twitter-sphere where everything that happened from Snowden to Charlottesville was the result of some FSB operation. At some point it just strains credulity. On the other side, you have, of course the Trump-ist idea that the entire mass media is engaged in a misinformation campaign backed by the 'deep state' who is attempting the overthrow the president an institute a "globalist" new world order. I think both sides are operating under the assumption that there is some natural order and stability in American society, and it would just continue indefinitely and peacefully if it weren't for outsiders and people who are otherwise 'un-American" attacking it. The reality is that there are underlying tensions and instabilities that have been festering for decades (or even centuries) and they are becoming harder and harder to ignore for a variety of reasons. The current crisis in America is one of those things that 'just happened', and people are having a hard time coming to terms with the new reality they're living with and want to find someone to blame.
- krapp 9y agoThe CIA attempted to study the possibility of mind control, but that doesn't make it reasonable to assume they ever could, or do, control people's minds. They also studied remote viewing and telepathy, but that doesn't mean the CIA has psychic spies.
- dionian 9y agoCertainly not true. Nothing to do with religion at all. A conspiracy theory is not necessarily false. Conspiracies are very common; (secret ones are less well-known). Some theories turn out to accurately reflect reality once the facts are apparent.