3 ms·
The second question is based on faulty assumptions. Bitcoin uses orders of magnitude more energy per transaction.
by mikeash 9y ago
The second question is based on faulty assumptions. Bitcoin uses orders of magnitude more energy per transaction.
- ayemiller 9y agoDoes it? How many employees does bitcoin have?...
- mikeash 9y agoYes, it does. The figures are out there. Bitcoin is absolutely tiny on the scale of global finance, so the denominator is extremely small. Not having employees doesn't save it.
- honestlyreally 9y agoBut virtually all mining is done near cheap renewable power. People talk a lot about how much energy it uses, yet to see attempt at quantifying co2 emissions, they are likely quite low.
- ctz 9y agoIn a country with an electricity grid and 60% coal-based electricity generation.
- mikeash 9y agoCouldn't that cheap renewable electricity be transmitted and used elsewhere if the miners weren't using it? The disparity in energy use is so large that even if Bitcoin mining emitted only 1% of the CO2 per kWh that normal energy users do, it would still be far ahead.
- redcalx 9y ago> energy per transaction The lightning network may address this specific concern. I.e. bitcoin may become primarily a settlement mechanism for a much less resource hungry payment handling protocol/layer.
- yebyen 9y agoHumans are involved in banking transactions too, don't discount the carbon footprint of the collective of bankers and bank tellers. Those people won't go away if we eliminated the whole banking system, but their carbon footprint will not have been wasted on the tracking and transfer of assets!
- mikeash 9y agoA single bitcoin transaction uses about as much energy as the average American uses in 10 hours. As long as those bankers are doing at least a couple of transactions per day, they still come out ahead.
- yebyen 9y ago"They get more done" =/= "They do more things" =/= "They are more efficient" There is downward pressure on the transaction volume of bitcoin for bitcoin users, because each individual transaction costs so much. This is not exactly an advantage of Bitcoin, I'll admit, but there are some people who will consider Bitcoin a success if ultimately it is only used for larger settlements between payment companies (they would prefer to see Bitcoin is not involved in micro-transactions, they would raise the tx fees to make this use case impracticable.) All I'm saying is, don't look at Bitcoin handling an average of 7 transactions per second and say "that's less efficient" because your average Bitcoin transaction is currently trending toward being significantly more complicated than your average credit card transaction. (And even after the recent improvements and pricing hype, I'm not actually betting on Bitcoin myself.) The BTC system, by design, is unsuitable for trustless person-to-person transactions in the form of Point-of-Sale. Every merchant who operates Bitcoin is trained to know that the transaction is not over until it's mined and in a block, and it's really much safer to wait at least a few blocks. So if you're selling coffee, maybe you don't worry about it because absolutely nobody is waiting 30 minutes for their cup of coffee, and if someone defrauds you more than twice you'll surely remember their face. By then you're still only out ~$10, and the cost of each attack is high, and likelihood of success is non-zero but fairly low. So you can eat the loss for the cup of coffee, sure, but this is definitely not a great sales pitch for Point-of-Sale system at BestBuy or basically anywhere else. Ethereum, on the other hand, mines a block on average every 14 seconds. You could realistically be safe and use that in a Point-of-Sale system. (And I'm not the expert, there may be even better systems than Ethereum. But don't say Visa... :-)