The crucial difference is in distribution, not in usage. AMD and Nvidia distribute a binary module with a thin shim. It is the user who builds this shim and in

The crucial difference is in distribution, not in usage. AMD and Nvidia distribute a binary module with a thin shim. It is the user who builds this shim and inserts into his kernel. Neither AMD, Nvidia nor any Linux vendor[1] distribute any binary, that links into GPL-ed kernel. The combination is done by the user. And so does the ZoL project. They have the same trade-offs as AMD and Nvidia. It is just much more difficult to install Linux on a filesystem not supported by the installer, than not have working 3D acceleration at setup time though. [1] the distributions take care to have them in separate, third party repos and if you look more closely, you will find they are being build on the user machine using dkms, akmod or similar mechanism. That also trows a wrench into things if you want to use Secure Boot too.