4 ms·
Right to a fair trail is also a positive right. Ehh, I'm not sure. The actual right is better described as the right not to be unfairly tried, which is clearly
by icebraining 9y ago
Right to a fair trail is also a positive right.
Ehh, I'm not sure. The actual right is better described as the right not to be unfairly tried, which is clearly negative. The distinction is more than semantic: if the State launches an investigation and then drops it, leaving suspicion in the public's mind, you can't force them to go to trial to present your case and clear your name.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dieterrams 9y agoThe right not to be unfairly tried is easily satisfied by not having a trial at all. The right to a fair trial is about two things: you must be tried before being found guilty and punishment/sentencing is administered, and that trial must be executed fairly. In effect, you have the right to a (fair) trial. A trial and especially a fair trial are undeniably interventions on how things would otherwise proceed. But I agree with moomin that the positive/negative distinction is not really meaningful.
- Qantourisc 9y agoThere is still the option to mandate both. (No unfair tried, and a fair trial.)
- icebraining 9y agoA trial and especially a fair trial are undeniably interventions on how things would otherwise proceed No, because otherwise it would just be aggression. A trial is a method for the accusers to be able to show that their subsequent aggression (imprisonment, removal of property, etc) is justified.
- dieterrams 9y agoNo, it is to prevent the defendant from being unjustly blamed and punished.
- icebraining 9y agoUnjustly blaming and punishing someone is defamation and aggression. You don't need extra rights to be protected from that.
- dieterrams 9y agoHow about you read declarations of rights to a fair trial and point out where they imply that they are principally about ensuring the accusers' application of aggression is justified, as opposed to protecting the accused? Whether or not you think an "extra right" is necessary has no bearing on why that right is provided.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoWhat you're running into is the fuzzy distinction between positive and negative rights. Actually, in my mind there probably is no distinction and the classification of some rights as positive and others as negative is just a matter of wording, take this from James Sterba: What is at stake is the liberty of the poor not to be interfered with in taking from the surplus possessions of the rich what is necessary to satisfy their basic needs. Needless to say, libertarians would want to deny that the poor have this liberty. But how could they justify such a denial? As this liberty of the poor has been specified, it is not a positive right to receive something, but a negative right of non-interference.