5 ms·
> Nobody disputes that the Bill of Rights is not exhaustive. Unfortunately, that is not true. Robert Bork famously disputed it, even going so far as to deny t
by lisper 9y ago
> Nobody disputes that the Bill of Rights is not exhaustive.
Unfortunately, that is not true. Robert Bork famously disputed it, even going so far as to deny the validity of the ninth amendment. Many conservatives support Bork's position today, e.g.:
http://www.nationalreview.com/article/336142/judge-borks-ink-blot-ramesh-ponnuru http://www.nationalreview.com/article/336142/judge-borks-ink...
They do this because it's a logical pre-requisite for overturning Roe v. Wade.
- MereInterest 9y agoWhich is really messed up, given that the Ninth Amendment explicitly states that the Bill of Rights should not be taken as an exhaustive list.
- Ntrails 9y agoThat's the least messed up part, if you dispute the validity of the ninth and it is also the first to explicitly state that the previous list is not exhaustive, then clearly your position is consistent...
- dragonwriter 9y ago> They do this because it's a logical pre-requisite for overturning Roe v. Wade. It's really not, though, it's just a convenience; one could easily find grounds tomreverse Roe.and even the subsequent abortion decisions without just ignoring the Ninth Amendment. The real reason is that the Ninth Amendment is irreconcilable with the narrow mode of textualism that I personally think of as “four corners” or “sola scriptura” textualism, that seems to portray the Constitution’s text as complete and needing no external historical, cultural, etc., understanding to interpret. Because the Ninth Amendment specifically lays out that their are rights which existed and remain protected wothout being enumerated in the Constitution, it necessitates looking beyond the four corners of the Constitution to identify what those rights are.
- alphaalpha101 9y agoAs someone that isn't American, I support things like abortion rights and such, but I still think that your constitution seems to be so incredibly broadly interpreted that it might as well just be judges choosing whatever they personally think the result should be. It's basically a 9-man supreme legislature. Abortion rights should exist. I just don't necessarily think they should exist because of an 'implied right to privacy'. Like, what? There are lots of things that Governments restrict that go on in private. I think nobody could really sensibly argue that the US Constitution actually says that the USA can't pass laws about what people do in their own privacy.
- lisper 9y ago> one could easily find grounds to reverse Roe No, it's not so easy. Conservatives have been trying unsuccessfully to overturn it for 44 years. (Actually, that's not quite true. The effort to overturn Roe didn't actually start until 1979, fully six years after Roe was decided on a 7-2 vote. And the truth is they don't really want to overturn it. They really just want to use it as a wedge issue.)
- dragonwriter 9y ago> No, it's not so easy. It's easy to construct a coherent interpretation of the Constitution that invalidates Roe without nuking the Ninth Amendment (the thing with fuzzy penumbras and unenumerated rights is that it is very easy to come up with equally coherent interpretations of what their scope is.) It may be hard politically to get a Court majority appointed and confirms that agrees with eliminating abortion rights whatever the logical basis (or even without consensus on the basis; court decisions where there is a majority on the result but not the rationale are possible, so you don't need a unifying rationale to get a result.) But that's a different issue and nuke-the-Ninth types don't help that.
- lisper 9y ago> It's easy to construct a coherent interpretation of the Constitution that invalidates Roe without nuking the Ninth Amendment Really? What is it?
- akvadrako 9y agoThat's not an honest depiction of the situation for 2 reasons. 1. If the 9th amendment is interpreted to mean the courts can declare anything they think is a right, it allows unlimited power. "The Ninth Amendment obviously does not create federally enforceable rights." 2. Overturning Roe v. Wade wouldn't require much legal logic, except the precedent has been upheld several times. Without that, you could question any of steps it relies on: a. there's an implied right to privacy (9th or 14th amendments) b. the federal government has a mandate to enforce it c. this right implies states cannot restrict abortion d. the "balancing test" is legit, terminating the right in the last trimester
- lisper 9y ago> If the 9th amendment is interpreted to mean the courts can declare anything they think is a right, it allows unlimited power. No, that's not true. The court can't just decide anything it wants. It can only decide cases that come before it. Before the court gets to decide anything there is a very long drawn-out process that filters out a lot of crap. Furthermore, the court has to decide on the basis of the arguments and evidence presented to it. The court can't just invent a new right out of whole cloth; it has to be on the basis of evidence that it is a right "retained by the people" who are, after all, the ultimate authority on everything, at least in theory. > Overturning Roe v. Wade wouldn't require much legal logic, except the precedent has been upheld several times. You undermine your own argument in the second half of this sentence. That's like saying, "Tearing down the pyramids at Giza wouldn't be very hard, except for moving all the stones." To overturn Roe you have to figure out why the original conclusion was wrong, and why all of the subsequent confirmations were wrong. That is not so easy.
- akvadrako 9y ago> To overturn Roe you have to figure out why the original conclusion was wrong, and why all of the subsequent confirmations were wrong. That is not so easy. It's obvious. The case was decided that way in the first place because the courts are political; they were "legislating from the bench".
- humanrebar 9y ago> They do this because it's a logical pre-requisite for overturning Roe v. Wade. It's not. They could just rule that fetuses of a certain gestational age are actually people and ban late term abortions (with fair exceptions). Or they could rule that those fetuses are people and leave it to individual states to decide how to balance the rights to privacy and speech in these cases. States have the ability to use capital punishment, so there's some precedence for encoding the limits of fundamental rights at the state level.
- lisper 9y ago> They could just rule that fetuses of a certain gestational age are actually people and ban late term abortions Late term abortions are already largely illegal even under Roe. The political constituency that supports overturning Roe is ideological; they want to ban ALL abortions. So you would need to declare not only that fetuses are people, but that embryos are people, and that is fraught with all manner of legal peril. Should embryos be counted in the census? What about frozen embryos?
- rayiner 9y agoBork didn't say that the Bill of Rights is exclusive, he said the 9th amendment is unclear about what other rights it is talking about: "We don’t have much evidence about what the Founders meant; they may have been trying to protect state-constitutional rights; we have good reason to doubt they meant the amendment to magnify the power of the courts to overturn laws." > They do this because it's a logical pre-requisite for overturning Roe v. Wade. I don't want to see Roe overturned, but I think the entire Griswold line is nonsensical. We have a perfectly good legal foundation for protecting abortion, which doesn't rely on conjuring rights out of "penumbras": https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/courts_law/the-forgotten-history-of-justice-ginsburgs-criticism-of-roe-v-wade/2016/03/01/9ba0ea2e-dfe8-11e5-9c36-e1902f6b6571_story.html?utm_term=.5d14841e0899 https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/courts_law/the-forgo....
- lisper 9y ago> We have a perfectly good legal foundation for protecting abortion No, unfortunately, we don't. A sound logical argument is not the same thing as a good legal foundation. Ginsberg's equal-protection argument has never been formally accepted -- or even considered -- by the court. And even on purely logical grounds it is fraught with peril because it assumes that a fetus is not a person. If a fetus is a person then they too are entitled to equal protection. Personally I'd rather cast my lot with the right to privacy and the ninth amendment. I value that right far beyond its ability to protect reproductive freedom.