3 ms·
Very interesting tech, though the article makes a piss poor job of explaining anything about how it works. Rendering surfaces is how literally 99.9% of 3D graph
by ricardobeat 9y ago
Very interesting tech, though the article makes a piss poor job of explaining anything about how it works. Rendering surfaces is how literally 99.9% of 3D graphics work, not a "breakthrough" of any sorts.
- yorwba 9y agoThe abstract is much better. At least they linked to it in the article. https://arxiv.org/abs/1704.00710 https://arxiv.org/abs/1704.00710
- averagewall 9y agoI think it describes it quite well as long as you assume the problem of making a 3D model from a picture is already a solved but computationally expensive problem. That's the part it doesn't go into but that's not what this research is about. Though I think most readers will still be interested in that - I didn't know it had been solved already. It's not making a surface mesh, it's putting voxels on the surface. Again, it doesn't make that distinction very clear up front so I guess it's not targeted at people familiar with traditional 3D surface meshing.
- jordancampbell 9y agoIt's inferring the depth of all the points on the surface, including those it can't see in the image. This isn't surface rendering, it's depth estimation.
- khedoros1 9y ago99.9% of 3D graphics: "Computer, here's a definition of some 3D surfaces and their properties. Produce a 2D projection." This: "Computer, here's a 2D projection. Infer the likely 3D data that would produce the projection."
- ricardobeat 9y agoThe comparison the article makes is against rendering a full voxel volume, as if occlusion was a great insight.