19 ms·
The Scotsmen Who Invented Modernity
- drfuchs 9y agoBut no true Scotsman would invent modernity.
- falsedan 9y agothat's pure braw pal
- CryptoPunk 9y agoIt should be noted that Smith's warning about the potential for merchants to collude is not an endorsement of government intervention to prevent such collusion. The collusion warning is followed by: >It is impossible indeed to prevent such meetings, by any law which either could be executed, or would be consistent with liberty and justice. But though the law cannot hinder people of the same trade from sometimes assembling together, it ought to do nothing to facilitate such assemblies; much less to render them necessary. A regulation which obliges all those of the same trade in a particular town to enter their names and places of abode in a public register, facilitates such assemblies. . . . A regulation which enables those of the same trade to tax themselves in order to provide for their poor, their sick, their widows, and orphans, by giving them a common interest to manage, renders such assemblies necessary. An incorporation not only renders them necessary, but makes the act of the majority binding upon the whole. Which again shows Smith viewed the respect for freedom as a moral imperative.
- etplayer 9y agoWhen freedom is defined as freedom within the capitalist mode of production for bourgeois interests to collude, I suppose you're right. He also said that the state, as it is instituted for the protection of property, is instituted as a device used in benefit of the rich for the detriment of the poor. I find Marx's critique of classical political economy to be more valuable, and the thinking it inspired. The quality of the freedom offered by the social anarchists (Proudhon, Bakunin, Kropotkin and Bookchin) I also think is much higher than Smith's.
- KekDemaga 9y ago>The quality of the freedom offered by the social anarchists (Proudhon, Bakunin, Kropotkin and Bookchin) I also think is much higher than Smith's. In practice or on paper?
- etplayer 9y agoBoth, I would argue. The application of their ideas in Catalonia was respected by Orwell when he stayed there (he even wrote a book about it, Homage to Catalonia). The current situation in Syria has spawned a man inspired by Bookchin's anarchism to start Rojava, which is a secular and multi-ethnic society in the region, fighting ISIS and against the Turkish forces which want to eliminate them. You can read about anarchists during the Russian revolution, Kronstadt, Makhno, and the Italian factory councils here, whuch is a great read: http://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/daniel-guerin-anarchism-from-theory-to-practice http://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/daniel-guerin-anarchi...
- KekDemaga 9y agoNot places I'd want to live personally, how are you enjoying Syria?
- etplayer 9y agoThat's not an argument against anarchism. I also wouldn't want to live in many other places, nor would I want to live there. The point is that it is a place Syrians want to live, as in, it is significantly better than theocratic regimes in the region, and much fairer to all. I really don't know how you can consider what you said to be against anarchism.
- KekDemaga 9y agoMy point is I typically judge governments by their ability to create a place where people would like to live and I have to say Syria is pretty low on most peoples lists.
- eigenschwarz 9y agoDavid Hume, Adam Smith, James Clerk Maxwell, Andrew Carnegie, Alexander Graham Bell, James Watt, Alexander Fleming, Lord Kelvin - the list goes on... For such a tiny nation Scotland has truly had a remarkable influence on “modernity”.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- randcraw 9y agoProbably they can thank John Knox's insistence on teaching everyone in Scotland to read for much of the country's competitive advantage in all those things that benefit from literacy.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- kej 9y agoThere's a decent book that covers exactly this point: https://www.amazon.com/How-Scots-Invented-Modern-World/dp/0609809997/ https://www.amazon.com/How-Scots-Invented-Modern-World/dp/06...
- markdog12 9y agoGreat book, highly recommend. Before this book, I had no idea of the prevalence of Scottish enlightenment. Incredible contribution to the modern world, especially per capita.
- Nomentatus 9y agoScotland had very high literacy rates, even hundreds of years before this time (as did much of Germany.)
- roceasta 9y agoDying of cancer, David Hume wrote some notes about his life. The final paragraph is rather moving because he speaks of himself in the past tense: >To conclude historically with my own character. I am, or rather was (for that is the style I must now use in speaking of myself, which emboldens me the more to speak my sentiments); I was, I say, a man of mild disposition, of command of temper, of an open, social, and cheerful humour, capable of attachment, but little susceptible of enmity, and of great moderation in all my passions. Even my love of literary fame, my ruling passion, never soured my temper, notwithstanding my frequent disappointments. My company was not unacceptable to the young and careless, as well as to the studious and literary; and as I took a particular pleasure in the company of modest women, I had no reason to be displeased with the reception I met with from them. In a word, though most men, any wise eminent, have found reason to complain of calumny, I never was touched, or even attacked by her baleful tooth: and though I wantonly exposed myself to the rage of both civil and religious factions, they seemed to be disarmed in my behalf of their wonted fury. My friends never had occasion to vindicate any one circumstance of my character and conduct: Not but that the zealots, we may well suppose, would have been glad to invent and propagate any story to my disadvantage, but they could never find any which they thought would wear the face of probability. I cannot say there is no vanity in making this funeral oration of myself, but I hope it is not a misplaced one; and this is a matter of fact which is easily cleared and ascertained. https://andromeda.rutgers.edu/~jlynch/Texts/humelife.html https://andromeda.rutgers.edu/~jlynch/Texts/humelife.html
- badcede 9y ago“To write against him, is, you may depend upon it, the very thing he wishes you to do.” Don't feed the trolls.
- emmelaich 9y agoAnd just further on, this brilliant quote from Adam Smith > "After Rousseau departed England for Calais, Smith asked, “What has become of Rousseau? Has he gone abroad, because he cannot continue to get himself sufficiently persecuted in Great Britain?” There is nothing new under the sun.
- rpeden 9y agoOnly tangentially related, but David Hume and Benjamin Franklin were close friends. Franklin has always stuck me as a very modern thinker for his time, too. I'd long admired both Hume and Franklin, but didn't realize they were close friends until I dug in and read a Franklin biography a few years back. Franklin actually stayed with Hume in Edinburgh for a while. I'm sure the Philadeplhia to London to Edinburgh trek was a tad more involved in the 1700s than it is today. :)
- markdog12 9y agoIt wasn't "An American Life" was it? https://www.amazon.ca/Benjamin-Franklin-American-Walter-Isaacson/dp/074325807X https://www.amazon.ca/Benjamin-Franklin-American-Walter-Isaa... Great book and what an amazing human being! I remember it covered some of his time in England, but don't recall him staying with Hume. I read it quite a while ago though...
- rpeden 9y agoI started with that one - I liked Isaacson's writing when I read his Steve Jobs biography, so I decided to read his Franklin bio as well. I very much enjoyed it. Afterward, I read this one: https://www.amazon.com/First-American-Times-Benjamin-Franklin/dp/0385495404 https://www.amazon.com/First-American-Times-Benjamin-Frankli... I think this one is probably where I read about his time with Hume. I don't find H.W. Brands' writing to be quite as smooth to read as Isaacson's, but I remember him covering parts of Franklin's life in greater detail. His bio of Ulysses Grant was a great read, too: https://www.amazon.com/Man-Who-Saved-Union-Ulysses/dp/0307475158 https://www.amazon.com/Man-Who-Saved-Union-Ulysses/dp/030747...
- markdog12 9y agoHave you ever read Ron Chernow bios? I've read Titan (Rockefeller): https://www.amazon.ca/Titan-Life-John-Rockefeller-Sr/dp/1400077303/ https://www.amazon.ca/Titan-Life-John-Rockefeller-Sr/dp/1400... and Alexander Hamilton: https://www.amazon.ca/Alexander-Hamilton-Ron-Chernow/dp/0143034758/ https://www.amazon.ca/Alexander-Hamilton-Ron-Chernow/dp/0143... Both incredible. I admit I've never been terribly interested in Grant, maybe I should give him a look. Tough when there's an infinite abundance of great literature. We're truly spoiled.
- danielam 9y agoIf anyone is interested in the problems inherent in Hume's arguments, I recommend Feser's series of blog posts on the subject: http://edwardfeser.blogspot.com/search?q=hume http://edwardfeser.blogspot.com/search?q=hume
- lsh 9y agostopped reading at 'bromance'. fuck your stupid vocabulary. please downvote me into nothingness.