4 ms·
Then trillions of dollars were extremely inefficiently allocated to the task of creating better worlds and a much better world could have been created with that
by jerf 9y ago
Then trillions of dollars were extremely inefficiently allocated to the task of creating better worlds and a much better world could have been created with that money instead, costing lives in the process.
Having noble goals doesn't immunize you from accounting.
- castis 9y agoAnd none of it means anything if we all die because the planet cant sustain us any longer.
- nyolfen 9y agoquite a nice little set of rhetorical positions you've constructed for yourself
- sadfsafaasdfsa 9y agoS/He's responding to "What if it's all a big hoax and we create a better world for nothing?" therefore in this scope there is no GW
- alistproducer2 9y agoI recommend you read "Money: The Unauthorized Biography [0]" You'll never look at money the same way again. Money is not a commodity even though we treat it as such. It certainly is not a finite resource. Plenty of money gets created everyday for thing far more stupid than trying to save the world. Look at how much money has been created (and will be spent) for no good reason at all in the current cryptocoin bubble. The massive capital gains are going to be cashed out and spent somewhere, creating market distortions, making people who contribute nothing insanely wealthy. Money is not sacred. Better we use it to try and save the world than to treat it as if it (and the market) are some all-wise, ever-perfect allocator of human and natural resources. [0]: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00F1W0DAO/ref=dp-kindle-redirect?_encoding=UTF8&btkr=1 https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00F1W0DAO/ref=dp-kindle-redirect?...
- smokeyj 9y agoActually.. Original money was just a highly marketable commodity. Salt, spices, gold, cigarettes in prison. I highly suggest a better biography of currency. Maybe something authored by one of those pesky Austrians.
- jasonwatkinspdx 9y agoThe book you want is David Graeber's, but it will not confirm austrian leanings, nor the history of money you present above.
- smokeyj 9y agoIt's not fair to just say go buy someone's book without a single supporting argument. Drop some wisdom on me, man.
- jasonwatkinspdx 9y agoThe tl;dr is that the commonly told origin of money, right back to Adam Smith, is a-historical assumption that is contradicted by archeological evidence. The a-historical account is that money was developed to make barter more efficient. This is not what we see in the records from Sumer, and there is similar evidence in the other locations where we know writing arose. Before the neolithic revolution societies economic structure was largely based on social ties and a sense of reciprocal behavior: a sort of informal communism. As sedentary agriculture lead to the development of temple complexes and cities, debt and credit records replaced these. Money was not developed until nearly 2k years later. Barter was actually uncommon in the ancient world and was typically reserved for interactions between strangers such as traders that had traveled long distance and had no social ties to one another. Coinage in particular typically arose as part of a complex that involved raising armies and funding them via taxation. The commodity theory of money is a-historical, and not what "original money" was. It's a great book, though Graeber has little restraint in taking pot shots at economists, which might provoke some readers to defensiveness.