2 ms·
Normally the way traffic works is small yields to big. Pedestrians yield to bikes who yield to light powered equipment (e.g. Forklift) who yield to cars/motorc
by dsfyu404ed 9y ago
Normally the way traffic works is small yields to big. Pedestrians yield to bikes who yield to light powered equipment (e.g. Forklift) who yield to cars/motorcycles/trucks who yield to heavier equipment who yield to trains who yield to ships.
This system where lighter classes of traffic yield to heavier classes of traffic is mostly compatible with typical road rules. There are specific exceptions such as crosswalks and implied exceptions like (like university campuses). Bike suck from a consistancy standpoint because they need to be treated like part of the cars/motorcycles/trucks class of traffic at some times and treated like pedestrians at other times. How they should be treated depends on a bunch of different details of the situation and the interpretation of those details depends on the driver/cyclist.
Drivers are hostile toward cyclists for the same reason drivers are hostile toward tourists who are traveling too slow, in the wrong lane for their turn, slam on the brakes to make the turn, etc. Both groups do not act in ways that are easily predictable to those around them and make those around them spend more effort keeping tabs on them making using the road more stressful.
Segregating different classes of traffic is how the problem is solved in any other case (Pedestrians get sidewalks or the shoulder, cars get the road, trains get rails, ships get water, forklifts and heavy haul trucks are restricted to areas where their interaction with the other classes of traffic is more controllable (when was the last time you saw someone driving a scissor lift down the road?).
Bike lanes solve the problem somewhat but what we really need are rules that better define who does what in what situation so that road users can better predict each other's behavior and not be nuisances to each other.
- enoch_r 9y ago> Normally the way traffic works is small yields to big. Pedestrians yield to bikes who yield to light powered equipment (e.g. Forklift) who yield to cars/motorcycles/trucks who yield to heavier equipment who yield to trains who yield to ships. Huh! This is exactly the opposite of my perception: In general the way traffic works is "big has a responsibility to not hit small." If you want to drive an 18-wheeler, you better get a special class of driver's license and special training, and you will certainly lose that special license if you expect "smaller" entities on the road to yield to you because you are larger. When you drive a car, you again will need to get licensed and registered, though it's less difficult than if you want to drive a truck. You must drive safely around pedestrians--and should drive like you expect them to behave in unexpected ways, in a way where you won't kill them if they do. You yield to pedestrians when turning, or in a crosswalk, or parking lots. You must give bicyclists enough room when passing them and in general treat them like another vehicle, even though they are physically smaller. When you're on a bike, you should absolutely yield to pedestrians, not the other way around. In fact, I can't think of a single case in these most common classes of vehicles (trucks, cars, bikes, and pedestrians) where the law gives right-of-way to the larger entity, in a way it wouldn't if the entity were smaller. Can you?
- dsfyu404ed 9y ago>I can't think of a single case in these most common classes of vehicles (trucks, cars, bikes, and pedestrians) where the law gives right-of-way to the larger entity, in a way it wouldn't if the entity were smaller. Can you? It's not about size it's about traffic class. In the absence of specific instruction smaller classes do not have the right of way. Flagmen direct traffic around construction. The flagman tells the cars to yield so (e.g.) a skid steer can cross the road. Crosswalks tell pedestrians where they have the right of way but sometimes other instructions supersede that right of way. Crossing at a crosswalk at an intersection with a "don't walk" light and you don't have the right of way. There's a reason most places have a law on the books that lets them fine people for jaywalking. People stop or slow for jaywalkers not because the pedestrian has the right of way but because hitting them is less preferable. Yes, people who drive wheeled vehicles are trained to expect the smaller classes of traffic to be idiots. The rules that people using the roads are supposed to abide by have many layers of redundancy to make up for stupid. Slowing for pedestrians who are crossing the street where/when they shouldn't be or other vehicles taking turns they shouldn't be is still preferable to just hitting them. Stop thinking of trucks as separate. Road vehicle with a license plate are the same class of traffic and follow the same rules. Big trucks just optimize their behavior for their size. The rules of the rod work on paper. The problem is that people don't follow them and there's a bunch of situational details that dictate whether or not the rules can/should be broken. It's everyone's responsibility not to crash into other stuff. You will have to yield to people not following the on paper rules to do that. Whether having to do so is reasonable is dependent on the situation.